Lamontius wrote:
I'm going to go back to voting.
Everytime I look at this thread I like this community a little bit less.
It can be pretty merciless. Thanks for pointing that out - I'll try to be more gentle if I comment in the future.
Lots of items cop criticism because of what this competition in particular is looking for.
But in an actual home brew campaign, who really cares? There are items I consistently vote down here which could still be loads of fun around a table.
Outside of this competition, if your gaming group enjoys it and it makes your game fun, that's all that matters. No one at your game table will care whether you got the price right, remembered to italicise spell names, or just happened to design a torc the same year six other people did.
It's good to see so many people getting into the spirit of a fantasy RPG and then sharing their creativity publicly in this competition.