Considering the animal change was just in name and appearance, as long the stats are the same than the ones for an "official" creature like a dog, it has no impact on the game, so I don't see any problem with that. It is just a cosmetic change, reskinning, as you said, Kris.
It's like a player saying "So my elf has blue hair and only four fingers on each hand, due to her fey heritage".
On the contrary, it recognizes a little bit of imagination and creativity from the player and allows her to have some fun. That's what the game is supposed to be about. By ruling this out, it frustrates the player and even causes her to leave. That's too bad.
TriOmegaZero wrote: They're beautiful, have a good heft, and are excellent for throwing at unruly players. >:3 +20 Many years ago I was thinking it would be so cool to have a set of metal dice.
If you drop the monster hit dice and start from the bottom, it would give this: Medium Humanoid (Goblinoid)
If you think that's unbalanced, you can tone it down: Str bonus lowered to +2
I have mixed feelings about the CN alignment. On one side, I have seen bad players using it as an excuse to play psychopaths with no responsibility, disrupting the game and annoying the other characters for selfish pleasure.
On another side, I have seen a few others exploring the entropic aspect of the alignment, anarchists with no commitment to anything, but still living a rich life as mercenaries and daredevils, becoming actual heroes without a cause.
Basically that's in the hands of the player. That's his responsibility to make some concessions to the game and have a minimum of group spirit.
|