Risen Demon wrote:
Having never played in PFS before, I'm not too certain on the ramifications of the roleplay of something like the Vigilante. Do you think it would be difficult to utilize both personalities?
Personally, I like to roleplay vigilantes in adventures as always in their vigilante identity, then at random points in time my social identity shows up and "helps out these poor adventurers" or tasks them with jobs that would boost my vigilante's renown.
Eventually I'll reveal my social identity to my party as a huge "HOLY S~!% IT WAS THAT GUY ALL ALONG!?" moment, especially since (thanks to my epic GM) none of them know I'm a vigilante, they all think I'm a rogue.