Hai gaiz, long-time lurker, first-time poster. My question:
What if we just made muskets into breech-loading versions?
Apparently, this was tried in the past, but it could never work properly as the break leaked too much gas. So, what if Alkenstar has fixed this problem? Then, musket-wielders could have breech-loaded rather than muzzle-loaded muskets, thus making the reload times far more believable. Still almost supernaturally fast, but no longer ridiculously so.
No change to mechanics, just to flavor. I like this reskin a lot, as does my gunslinger in the RoW campaign I'm running. A reload for him goes like this (with the breech-loaded version):
Break; stuff pre-wrapped ball into hanging barrel; pour powder on top of ball; close barrel; cock hammer.
Much more reasonable than imagining the pour, stuff, and ram version of a muzzle-loader, all in less than six seconds, IMO.
As for powder in the pan, we reskin that as percussion caps or a wheel-lock.
What do you think?