So, I'm having some issues with one of my players. Specifically, the Paladin of Ragathiel.
She built the paladin in a very min/maxed fashion but considering I'm throwing the enemies as stronger than normal at the party that was fine.
A few things though. In the Mongrel Lair, they managed to find Radiance but she didn't connect the 'sword to be corrupted' from Hosilla's note to the sword they found. She took the pretty gold longsword that detected as magical however, because hey loot and I want! (I'm running that the sword doesn't shift to the favored weapon until it actually bonds with a mythic Paladin).
When they got out, I ran the commoner stage battle. She calmly watched a party member drop two of the commoners for being in their way to the Quasits, not a peep out of her. Here she figured out that the gold was only skin deep and it was actually cold iron.
After the session however, she commented that as soon as she could, she was going to sell the sword because it wasn't a bastard sword. (her favored weapon).
I had to come out from behind the DM screen at that point and go WTF?
I'm looking for people's thoughts on whether or not I should start pinging her for a possible fall.