PossibleCabbage wrote:
I believe canon is that all the gods except Pharasma were totally caught off guard by Aroden's death/disappearance but the Lady of Mysteries is not inclined to answer questions.
Well, I suppose Nethys knows, because omniscience, but your odds of getting an answer from him are probably worse.
If I'm not mistaken, I remember reading a j.j. post. He said that pharasma and the other deities do not answer the question. All divination inside the eye of abendengo show only the remains of a ship (that's written in a manual companion). Ther's also a prestige lass (Storm Kindlers) followers of Gozreh that thinks it's his manifestation and can develop strong powers related to the storm. While the boggards of the Sodden Lands believe it is connected to their patron god, Rovagug. I think it could be both. But how and why i dunno. But my question is:
If Aroden was killed, who had the strength to do so and why did he/she not turn out or make other actions after getting it out of the way? If Aroden was attacked, how could he not be able to send a "help" request to other good deities or a message to his clerics?
Answer: No enemy at the time was free and had the strenght to kill Aroden (supported by Iomedae) and if he was killed there would be no reason for Iomedae and the other deities to hide the culprit. They are hiding it because they are preventing something.
I think that is how things have gone: Aroden and the other deities found a way for the prophecy of Rovagug to not come true. And that method involved Aroden's death because the prophecy concerned him directly. But noone could know what a propecy break would have caused. Rovagug or his followers could have try to come out from the earth-prison causing disasters and Gozre fought them and maybe sealed the "breach" with his storm. Maybe here ther's an other of the lost "Star Towers" the deities used to seal Rovagug. "Many Star Towers now lie forgotten" paizo say. "but some are known:
The Tower of Slant Shadows
The Vale of Shadows
The Star Tower of Castle Scarwall
The Star Tower of Vekheen"
But there are more. who know how many...
And ofc if thats the reality of the facts, deities cannot tell to golarion "Hey! Rovagug is coming back, we are going to sacrifice Aroden to prevent it, ok?!"
That's the only reasonable reason why they could want to keep it secret