A couple of weeks ago I posted a little question with regards to the magical mysteries of the Oracle spells list – particularly at what level to consider bonus mystery spells that are either higher level (of other classes) than the Oracle has access to or spells that are different levels for different classes.
The general consensus on this board was to consider those bonus spells to be the highest level that the Oracle can cast. This is a fair interpretation of intent, but I found some … hiccups –in regards to the Haunted Oracle Curse (since it also adds spells to the Oracle’s spell list).
First off, at level 1, the haunted Oracle gains Ghost Sound and Mage Hand as bonus spells. If we follow the above logic, that would mean that these two Sorcerer / Wizard Cantrips are level 1 spells for the Haunted Oracle (which I might be able to accept, as those spells are outside of a Cleric’s usual bag of tricks, but even then hardly comparable to a Cure Light Wounds.
Now, let us consider the Gnome’s Favored Class option for Oracle, in which they can add +1/2 level to the effective level of their Oracle Curse. So, in this scenario, a level 10 Oracle, considered level 15 for the purposes of his curse, and thus would add Reverse Gravity (level 7 Wizard Spell) to his oracle spell list. If we go with the above logic once again, this particular Oracle would continue its amazing career casting Reverse Gravity as a level 5 spell.
Or, consider this, a level 1 Haunted Oracle (lets say Lore) switches careers and becomes a Bard. Upon hitting the 8th level of Bard, he is now considered level 5 for the purposes of his curse, and would add Levitate and Minor Image to his spells known (as a level 1 Oracle Spell?). Of course there are likely bigger concerns at level 19, but this same character would be casting Telekinesis as a level 1 Oracle spell as well (?) – and making quite a business making one of a kind wands of Telekinesis.
I enjoy the Oracle. I have a long standing weak spot for spontaneous casters. All the flavor of the Oracle is right on the money – but some of the finer points of the mechanics have ended up being … undefined.
Is there an official answer to this issue?