margret weis and tracy hickman do not reference the d&d rules system anywhere in their works. if a book was written like a d&d tabletop session, then yes, it would be boring. but these authors don't do that. a good author can write a book in any setting and hold the readeres attention. to say that reading a book set in a d&d universe is not good, you are showing how closed minded you are, and that you haven't read any. as for those who say you can't put lotr into d&d, read this: http://www.merp.com/downloads/Ea-d20/
a book is a form of storytelling. storytelling has been around longer than books. storytellers don't tell their story to one person at a time4, they like to gather a group and tell it. same in d&d and novels, they are meant to be shared by many that's why their isn't just one copy of lotr. margret weis and tracy hickman are just two authors who have written novels based in a game world, and they are well written. the fact that they are in a gamew setting does not detract from their enjoyability in the least.
thanks for your input guys this has been fun... now i'm gonna make your head spin :) the valar were cylons! (as in the new battle star galactica) galactica finaly found a world to settle on (middle earth)
-it has been so long since humans colonized middle earth they have forgotten their technology and view the cyclon technology as "magic"
lotr has been compared to D&D since it's inception, this article is from 1977, only a few years after D&D came out.
the article is 30 years old. what are the time restraints on copyright? i am not making a profit off of, or taking away from dragon magazine in any way.
more like "apple to basket of fruit" the basket being d&d (because it is the definitive fantasy role playing system)
(anyone who creates a fantasy setting before or after d&d is subject to have their work translated into d&d system by fantasy geeks worldwide)
will o wisp stats:
they are invisible when they attack but their attack isn't, it's lightening. you can see lightening.
|