ICPD wrote:
...I think that Precise Companion isn't the greatest class feature and doesn't help the Hunter. This class feature shoehorns the Hunter into being some sort of archer.
I agree both that it isn't the greatest class feature and , to a lesser degree, that it shoehorns overly much.
As I see it, if someone will go an archer path with this class, they are going to be taking the Precise Shot feat anyways as this does nothing to stop the penalty from your fighter buddy alongside your target. Otherwise, you're pressuring the Hunter to fight only with the animal companion for his bonus.
I believe that were to push the ability back some levels and change it so that the animal companion didn't provide cover from the Hunter it would benefit more builds, specifically benefiting reach weapons which has a lot of potential synergy with animal companions and teamwork feats. Pushing this backwards in levels would give less gain for dipping in multiclassing, while giving a portion of the benefit of a feat which is very difficult for a 3/4 BAB class to obtain.
Unfortunately, I cannot think of a manner to change this ability to keeps its theme while functioning for more builds.