Flamifur's Shackled City Discussion Thread


Play-by-Post Discussion

151 to 200 of 396 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | next > last >>
Dark Archive

Flamifur, kudos for the wonderful intro. Everybody represented, as well as their respective deities, I believe. Can't wait to start...oh silly me, we already started here in the discussion thread... it's apparent that we are all excited.


Male Human - dash of elf Miniature painter/ Heroic
Niklaus Wright wrote:

That's right! No effeminate knickers for Nik, but leather pants --oh yeah!

Of course given the technology and cash available to him its either leather or wool. He really doesn't have much choice.

Haha, Jessa was referring to any kind of underwear, implying perhaps that Nik "goes commando". Probably enough to make the young ranger blush.


FabesMinis wrote:


Haha, Jessa was referring to any kind of underwear, implying perhaps that Nik "goes commando". Probably enough to make the young ranger blush.

More than probably.

Liberty's Edge

Zoo seeing all looks from the group on him averts his eyes and begins to walk away......

Cool intro, can't wait to get this rolling...


Female Half-elf Druid 1

"Ach, he's like all these fellers; ya give 'em a piece o' yer mind and they scuttle away." Jessa says contemptuously, "Nothing to worry about. Y're safe, Nikky-boy."


Sorry, it's been a while coming but we're now up and running on the play thread.

See you on the other side.......


male Human ranger 1
Jessa Ventris wrote:
"Ach, he's like all these fellers; ya give 'em a piece o' yer mind and they scuttle away." Jessa says contemptuously, "Nothing to worry about. Y're safe, Nikky-boy."

Now Nik glowers briefly, " Yeah, but ..." . Shaking his head, he turns away to look for a new napping spot.

On the Zoom question, Jessa seems to be more or less the party's focal at this point. At least she's been the most out-going. She's said Eichandar's harmless, he's probably in. After all we have a good bit of the voyage to talk. But if Eichandar wants to stay on the outside for character reasons, that's good too. Up to him really. I imagine we'll get some combat together on the trip. Nothing like a DnD fight to bring folks together.

edit: sorry about talking about you in third person Zoom. After all you are right here. Not very polite of me.


When I asked about background material, one of you suggested Greyhawk Gazeteer. I found this here on the Paizo site. Does any of you have an opinion on its relevance/quality? Did the setting change much from AD&D to 3E ?

AD&D World of Greyhawk Fantasy Game Setting PDF

at $4 the price is right. I just don't want to be working from an inaccurate world view.


Male Human - dash of elf Miniature painter/ Heroic

From 1E to 2E, the world went through a massive series of wars so there were some changes, but from 2E to 3E I don't think there was anything massive. (unlike say The Forgotten Realms)

Dark Archive

I have a copy of the Gazeteer, and I found it very informative. However, it was published before SCAP. Hence, you won't find any mention of Cauldron in that book.

You might wanna check out "From the Ashes," though. It's available here at Paizo.


Thanks guys.


Last minute assignment in Butler, PA. Hopefully I can get the internet to work. If not I'll check in with you guys middle of next week.

-- TOm

Dark Archive

Stilgar and Nik are off to go to the Temple of Kord...Don't worry Stilgar will take care of him.


Male Workaholic, level 10
thereal thom wrote:

When I asked about background material, one of you suggested Greyhawk Gazeteer. I found this here on the Paizo site. Does any of you have an opinion on its relevance/quality? Did the setting change much from AD&D to 3E ?

AD&D World of Greyhawk Fantasy Game Setting PDF

at $4 the price is right. I just don't want to be working from an inaccurate world view.

Having bought the original Living Greyhawk Gazetteer for $27 several years ago, I would say that for $4 dollars you are getting a good deal - the map portion is what I may be curious about in terms of appearance.

I would agree with Fabes - it provides a fairly udpated background of the world of Greyhawk through 3.5 edition (considering it was the original AD&D world - that's quite a bit). As Radavel mentioned, it doesn't include the current campaign, but I believe for our purposes it would provide background for our characters more than a direct reference (but of course our DM may have other plans).

Being something of an old school D&D player, I found it great to read - it does for Greyhawk/Oerth what has been done for many other campaign worlds - it gives you a broad overview and complete pictures of the whole world. The thing to remember about this world is that, unlike many game worlds, it started in a piecemeal fashion - I don't think the designers at TSR were shooting for such a comprehensive setting - it just grew out that way. It makes the world both very organic and somewhat odd at the same time - parts and pieces were kind of mixed and matched at first and it could be confusing to know what was going on. Still, it makes for some interesting mesh of traditional fantasy and midevalism.

Still, it remains a good baseline for getting to know the world. I know Wizards tried to increase interest for a few years with several additions that updated several regions with further deatils, including:

*Player's Guide to Greyhawk
*Several adventure modules - with at least one involving Mordenkanen and the Circle of Eight. There were also a few that revisited famous Greyhawk sites; and now there's the Castle Greyhawk one.
*Some bigger expansions updating several of the more famous villains/factions - like the Scarlet Brotherhood, Slavers, etc.
*I recall that Dungeon had a mini-campaign (similar to the Adventure paths) that involved solving the problems of the nation of Sterich over 3 or 4 issues.

I feel like maybe I'm geek rambling too much, so I hope that helps at this point.


Male Workaholic, level 10

By the way, in my last post I kept talking about the Living Greyhawk Gazeteer. I just realized that there's a also a smaller version called just the Gazeteer - which I think Wizards put out as sort of a gamer's primer to get you interested in the bigger game world materials. Not certain if it is has been put out - given that it's basically a short term summary of what's in the bigger book. I have copy I picked up awhile back.


"So yous two go off gallivantin' off whilst we do all the leg work, is that it? We'll make sure y' get the best seats, milord." That was perfect, Fabesminis. Absolutely perfect.

Still haven't had a chance to read the Greyhawk pdfs. My regular work laptop wasn't available. So I had to borrow an old one. I was going to read the pdfs on the trip to Pittsburgh. The borrowed computer had no Adobe reader, no wireless card, and the hotel had no wireless receivers to loan. Oh well. Sometime this week. How's it with ya'll?

Dark Archive

PsionicFox, you ok there buddy? You've been silent for a while. Hope there's nothing wrong at your end.


Male? Lung Dragon Beyond Mortal

Thom, the OA game has started in the play by post section.


The Celestial Dragon wrote:
Thom, the OA game has started in the play by post section.

Thanks, much, Fabesminis.


I'm a little worried now about the dissapearance of Psionic Fox. We've had no posts since the 18th and he hasn't posted anywhere else since then either. I do hope he's ok.

In light of this and the fact that the party really needs a Arcanist of some description we need to think about replacing Eerion at some stage.

I was going to suggest carrying on as is until the party gets to Cauldron and then talk to our 'subs bench' to see if any of then fancy playing a wizard or the like. At the rate we're going this gives Psionic fox a while to re-surface before we have to make Erion an NPC. I will keep the character around whatever happens - Psionic Fox did a really good job of creating a character I wanted to see develop.

What do you guys think ?


Also, whilst I'm navel gazing and bearing in mind that this is the first PBP I've run do we think we're going at a fast enough pace, etc ?

I'm trying to give everyone some chances to interact with NPCs as much as they want but I am aware this slows down progress. Some feedback on this would be good. For instance, do you want me to make more of it skill check based so the pace picks up or are we ok with it as it stands ?

Let me know.


Male Workaholic, level 10

Concerning Psionic Fox, I'll admit I'm also starting to get a little worried - I keep wondering if he lives in the San Diego area or something like. Sorry if that sounds a little over-reactive.

I'd hate to replace him, but I can see where you have enough going that running him as a constant, active NPC would be problematic for you. I do agree that maybe we should ask one of alternate folks to at least start prepping a character.

My suggestions would be someone we meet on the caravan road, but won't be active until we get to Cauldron proper as you mention. Otherwise, if we wish to delay it a little more, maybe a Cauldron "local" to help join the band?

Still, I'll say I hate to have Fox miss out because of something like a busted PC.


Male Workaholic, level 10
Flamifur wrote:

Also, whilst I'm navel gazing and bearing in mind that this is the first PBP I've run do we think we're going at a fast enough pace, etc ?

I'm trying to give everyone some chances to interact with NPCs as much as they want but I am aware this slows down progress. Some feedback on this would be good. For instance, do you want me to make more of it skill check based so the pace picks up or are we ok with it as it stands ?

Let me know.

I'll admit I'm very new to all this, but so far Flamifur it looks fine. I would say it's more our RPing mischief that are slowing things down - the interaction is giving us a chance to "warm up" to how things are going.

I think in terms of switching to skills checks or speeding things up, maybe if you read it as there's not much we are going to gain by the interaction - then proceed ahead. If you think there's something worthwhile for us to hit onto - or maybe one of us has something significant to do - then maybe some NPC actions are warranted.

For example - if you think the caravan trip will have some interesting moments you want us to experience - then by all means switch to deeper conversations. If it's more of a random monster encounter - then maybe more skill checks and less interaction?

Just positing a suggestion - please don't take it as what I am expecting. Hope that helps.

Dark Archive

A suggestion - If we can play out the journey to Cauldron...perhaps we can have enough time to be certain if PsionicFox is coming back or not. Besides, at its present size, the party needs additional xp opportunities from random or not so random encounters. Also, it gives the characters a chance to bond and get to know each other's style of play before facing the menaces of cauldron. Any subs will also benefit if we play out the journey, both in terms of XP and bonding with the rest of the party.

As to pacing, I think we're doing fine...but I have no objections to speeding up.

Flamifur, you're doing fine. I was in fact surprised when you said that this was your first time running a pbp.


Male Human - dash of elf Miniature painter/ Heroic

I don't have objections to speeding up either - Jessa complains but it does make things funny.

The polearms conversation makes me hoot. It's almost Simpsons-esque - "Stop saying 'polearms'!"

Liberty's Edge

I'm happy how things are going, the begining of an adventure is always a little slow to start anyway! As for Fox, I say we wait a week and see if he shows up hopefully!
Just a thought here, I am always curious where people are from when I play these pbp. Knowing might also help out if a person disappears for awhile and we see on the news that that city is having some problems like San Diego is having and might explain why they disappeared!
Well anyway, I am in Seattle, Washington, USA and yes it does rain here a lot..heh

Dark Archive

I think PsionicFox said at the start of this thread that he is from the East Coast of Australia.

I'm in the Philippines by the way. So when most of you guys are sleeping, I'm slaving away at the office. But we just had a long weekend on account of the Barangay Elections last October 29 and facing another long weekend starting November 1, so you can't see me complaining.


Male Workaholic, level 10

I think you're right, Rad - my bad for panicking.

I live in Naples, Florida - which is on Gulf coast for those of you who are geographically curious. Most of my posts usually come in the late evening, EST.


Flamifur wrote:

I'm a little worried now about the dissapearance of Psionic Fox. We've had no posts since the 18th and he hasn't posted anywhere else since then either. I do hope he's ok.

In light of this and the fact that the party really needs a Arcanist of some description we need to think about replacing Eerion at some stage.

I was going to suggest carrying on as is until the party gets to Cauldron and then talk to our 'subs bench' to see if any of then fancy playing a wizard or the like. At the rate we're going this gives Psionic fox a while to re-surface before we have to make Erion an NPC. I will keep the character around whatever happens - Psionic Fox did a really good job of creating a character I wanted to see develop.

What do you guys think ?

I'd like to give Psionic Fox the best chance possible to continue. I think your plan is sound to carry on as is until we reach Cauldron. If you don't want to DM-PC Erion he could stay in port taking care of his concerns here and catch up in Cauldron. If the caravan trip is mostly low-level combat his absence shouldn't hurt us much and we've got extra combat types anyway.

The pace is fine, I like interacting with the other PCs and NPCs. I'd kind of like to get out of port and on the road.

Edit: I'm near Boston, MA, USA. Eastern time zone.


Male Human - dash of elf Miniature painter/ Heroic

I'm in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

England to be precise. ;D


FabesMinis wrote:

I'm in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

England to be precise. ;D

Me Too !

Where in Blighty are you by the way ?

Dark Archive

It's October 31 where I am and getting near midnight. Just wanted to greet you all "Happy Halloween."


Radavel wrote:
It's October 31 where I am and getting near midnight. Just wanted to greet you all "Happy Halloween."

Just gone midnight here. No beasties or maniacs with knives to report....yet !

Have fun.


Male Workaholic, level 10

Happy Halloween to all...and to all a good fright.;-)


Oh. My. God.

I have just had the most INSANE three weeks.

We've had this guy at work (my direct superior), act like a total jerk, I've been pulling REALLY long hours, AND the jerk just got fired (meaning I'm currently doing his job at the moment too.

Thank you all for your concern, but hopefully things have died down now, and I can resume my regular posting schedule. I'd go into more detail, but I am absolutely exhausted at the moment. When I return to consciousness, I'll catch up and jump back in - assuming I'm still welcome, of course...

Again, sorry folks.

Dark Archive

Welcome back, Erion.


That was fast. :P

Thanks Rad!

Dark Archive

You're in Australia, right? I'm in the Philippines, just a few hours of difference.


Cool - Its like 12:13 AM for me right now. I need a shower, and then I need sleep.

See you in a few.

EDIT: And yes, I'm in Australia. About and hour and a half north of Sydney (The capital of New South Wales).

Dark Archive

Good night... It's 9:10 PM here and I'll catch some sleep myself in a few hours time.


Male Workaholic, level 10

Welcome back, Erion!

The workday is underway here (10 AM), and I'm in the midst of it - but wanted to say hello. Sounds like its been a bear. Sleep well.


And I have awakened.

I'd like to start off by saying 'thank you' to you all for your concern and patience with me during the last few weeks. Once again, I feel I must apologize profusely for my disappearance, but I am very glad that you all had the grace to wait for me to return. I should be able to post most days, and likely not more than once a day (unless its a quiet weekend or something). Of course, this limit only applies to IC posts. OOC I can probably post more.

Secondly, I feel honored to be part of a writing group who thinks so much of me, and my skills a writer:

Flamifur wrote:
I will keep the character around whatever happens - PsionicFox did a really good job of creating a character I wanted to see develop.

Never before have I received praise for the way I write, and I just wanted to say that I am very glad to have returned in time - as this has been one of the most fulfilling DnD games I've ever played, and we haven't really done anything yet!

I'll cut it short here, but I'll say this again.

Thank you. Thank you all.

-Erion Gilor (PsionicFox)


Welcome back PsionicFox!!!

Let's get it in gear and smoke some tires!!


Male Human - dash of elf Miniature painter/ Heroic

"Oh, back are ya? Let's get a move on, then!" as Jessa might say to Erion. ;)


I've Just had a mad 2 days which (included my computer deciding to try and destroy itself again) which is why I haven't posted.

I'm so please Erion is back in Psionic Fox's hands and I'm, obviously, even more glad Psionic Fox has surfaced !

I'll get everything going again tomorrow morning (GMT).

Probably time to make stuff dangerous...............


Answer my IC question first!

AHHHH!

EDIT: Just kidding - get some rest.


The Shackled City Narrator wrote:
I can assist I think' said a gentle voice from the shadows and the tall, androgenous figure of an elf was next to them, clad for travel with muddied boots. 'I have a piece I'd like to see used - it's not totally mine but enough of it is to be of use.'

I have a question - if the book is meant to represent me, what the hell does that quote mean?

Yes, I know, I'm harping on the initial post again - but it was so well done, and I just have to ask!


Male Human - dash of elf Miniature painter/ Heroic

Because Erion worships Wee Jas as well as Corellon was my guess. I hope Corellon asked before taking it!


You know what, I had totally forgotten that - and its my own frigging character!

Hah, I'm such a moron sometimes.

151 to 200 of 396 << first < prev | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | next > last >>
Community / Forums / Online Campaigns / Play-by-Post Discussion / Flamifur's Shackled City Discussion Thread All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.