|Paizo Pathfinder® Paizo Games|
|About Paizo Messageboards News Paizo Blog Help/FAQ|
I'll respond to the second part first. Not all charms work that way. In fact, "charm person" says nothing about turning someone against their former friends. Nothing. And then there is the whole illusion argument, or incapacitated argument, or the enemy pretending to be a friend argument... Allowing it wholesale to all creatures is simpler.
Now, as to the first part... Yes, I read the mention of "foe" in the section introduction, but its only mentioned once, and that as part of an EXAMPLE of what is possible. I don't believe it is RAI. If you keep reading, it says "each character or creature...". There is no "friend forcefield" preventing me from dragging an incapacitated ally to safety, or pulling a friend back to the curb from the aforementioned bus. It not only doesn't make logical sense, its also not cinematic. I want the big bad evil guy to be able to shove minions out of his way, and I want the PCs to be able to pull villagers out of harms way. It makes rules sense, and makes better stories.
Back to the original question... I say go for it.
EDIT: I had originally said you should be denied dex until your next turn, and went into the reasoning... However, WRAITHSTRIKE MADE A GREAT ARGUMENT. I am now convinced that a ranged "cure" bomb should not be treated differently than a "touch" cure. If you are not denied dex bonus on one, then you should not be denied dex bonus on the other.
Why can't you reposition, bull rush, or use ANY other combat maneuver on an ally? Being an ally doesn't make you suddenly immune to these maneuvers. If my friend steps in front of a bus (a dangerous thing), I'm going to pull them back onto the curb (ie, reposition them).
Also, if you are saying you CAN'T use a combat maneuver on an ally, what happens if they are charmed by something, or believe an illusion, and are walking to their doom? You just have to stand there because they are not an enemy? What if they are tied up or otherwise unable to move? We just leave them? No. I'm not buying it. (As an aside, a CM against someone tied up or otherwise incapacitated automatically succeeds, core rulebook, page 199). Or, what if you consider them a friend, but they secretly hate you? The character relationship is irrelevant. Combat Maneuvers ARE possible on an ally. If it has a CMD, its fair game.
My opinion (since you are asking):
This makes perfect sense for creatures with animal intelligence. Not as much for normal (or higher) intelligence. If the PC's can use tactics, so should the badguys.
Also, I may have missed it, but did you consider a cavalier challenging his enemy? Thematically, that seems equivalent to causing a mark. It is directly provoking an opponent. However, does that replace an existing mark, supersede a new mark, or allow a creature to momentarily have 2 marks.
Finally, I can see PCs abusing this system. Imagine a high-damaging pc (like a wizard at the start of the day, fresh with spells) acting just 1 initiative step before a lower-damaging one. Under this system, an intelligent opponent could still be forced to ignore the person causing him/her the greatest pain, because someone else managed to hit him just before (s)he acted. Better yet, I could see PCs forcing an opponent to run a gauntlet of AOOs and flanks, just to get to the archer 30 ft away. An intelligent opponent wouldn't do that.
I'm going to say that they don't make pooper-scoopers that can accommodate what a brachiosaurus leaves behind. You think the fine is stiff for not picking up after your dog? Man, you don't want to be the guy with a pet brachiosaurus.
I kind of get a Third Reich vibe from Chelax. I see the cleric's operating as a pseudo-gestapo, while the hellknight's act as a pseudo-SS. Most of the military division's are probably geared toward quick & powerful strikes, rather than prolonged campaign's.
Four kittens were tortured to bring you this message.
Long term, I like leveling. It offers both the players AND the GM some variety, by presenting both with new combat options. It's not any more fun for the GM to run the same set of monsters over and over again, than it is for the players to fight them. After a while, the whole table is ready to mix things up a bit. Leveling is a good way to do that.
Oops, I missed that. For some reason, I thought this was a general advice forum. I've never played PCS, but I understand that the GMs have to run the adventure as written.
In that case, yeah, alerting the enemies and allowing them time to buff might be your best option.
Well, not sure what level, but it is using one of the charater's wild shape uses per day. So one option is to throw more combat at the party. They may start to wish they hadn't wasted the wild shape.
Other options include having the character encounter:
Underground reservoirs of water or underground rivers
Hot steam geysers
Rooms lined with a cheap metal (lead, tin, etc)
Something interesting.... Oops, it was explosive runes.
An enemy which would have been unaware of the party, but now has several round to buff.
An enemy druid (at a CR appropriate for the party)
Monsters that can chase the druid with burrow or earthglide.
Or... You can do the opposite. Have the rest of the party experience combat while the druid is off scouting. Let's face it, combat is fun, and part of the reason people play.
I wouldn't "punish" the player, but dungeons are dangerous, and there are several good reasons why it is generally not wise to split the party.
Bjørn Røyrvik wrote:
Orcus is the Latin spelling of the Greek god Horkos. He is NOT WotC property, though the specific mechanics may be.
TSR used a lot of obscure Greek and Roman deities when they created their demons and devils. Another example is the devil Dispater, which is an alternate spelling of Dis Pater (in Latin, Dis = Hell, Pater = father).
I see the thread got derailed... I'm partly to blame.
I'm ok with cdg. It is unwise to leave a potential threat behind you as you move forward in combat. It's quicker to cdg than search them to see if they have a potion of healing. Also, helpless doesn't always mean negative hit points. A sleep spell can render someone helpless.
If you are talking about real life: Even a dying person can pull a trigger on a crossbow...
Yes. The idea of knights being unable to get on their horse is just as exaggerated as the effectiveness of the longbow . Recent rain had softened the ground, and the French had a narrow avenue of attack, up hill (not only eliminating the advantage of numbers, but turning it into a disadvantage), so the ground along the attack route was torn up very badly by hundreds of people and horses, and turned into a thick mud that sucked at the legs of the French knights traveling uphill. It was slow, plodding movement, and if you slipped, you likely fell in the mud and suffocated or were trampled by your allies. The real reason for the English victory was the proper use of terrain and tactics by the English, NOT the longbow. The arrowheads on the English arrows were made of a softer, thinner metal than the French breastplates.
Anyway, what he said. Military armor was heavy, but not so heavy that a knight needed a crane to get mounted. Think about it... Where did they keep the cranes when they were hundreds of miles from home, invading enemy territory? Even if they had them (they didn't), what use is an army that can only get ready for war 1 or 2 knights at a time because they had to wait their turn to get mounted?
Yeah. When I ran this, my players actually had a harder time with the goblins than Tsuto. They killed Tsuto in 1 round.
The reason it was so easy for my group was the terrain. Tsuto is trapped. He had to go through the PCs to go anywhere, whereas the goblins could move around and use the terrain.
If you want a suggestion, I would move Tsuto to another location. One with more room. Let him run and regroup if things are not going well.
Chris Shaeffer wrote:
Before I saw this, I actually came up with a similar themed item...
Aura moderate enchantment; CL 15th
Meme shoes have a continually changing set of abilities. All save DCs begin at 25, but are reduced by 1d6-1 points annually. When an ability becomes DC 0, it no longer functions, but a new random ability is created. Currently, meme shoes have the following abilities:
Harlem Shake: once per day, the wearer can begin dancing as a full round action. While dancing, when the wearer utilizes the command words “The Harlem Shake”, all creatures within a 30 ft. radius must immediately succeed on a will save (DC25) or begin dancing as if under the effects of irresistible dance. This is an enchantment (mind control) effect that lasts as long as the wearer continues dancing, or the affected creature is no longer within the area of effect.
Opa Gundam Style: once per day, the wearer may dance as a standard action in a quirky and slightly humorous fashion. While dancing, when the wearer utilizes the command words “Hey sexy lady”, all creatures within a 100ft radius must succeed on a DC20 will save, or become fascinated. This is an enchantment (mind control) effect that ends once the wearer stops dancing, or the affected creature is no longer within the area of effect.
YMCA: Once per day, the wearer may shout “Its fun to stay at the YMCA!” as a swift action. All creatures within a 30ft. radius must succeed on a D10 will save, or drop any held items and immediately spell out the letters Y, M, C, and A with their arms. This is an enchantment (mind control) effect that only functions at wedding receptions.
Macarena: This ability no longer functions.
Electric Slide: This ability no longer functions.
Moonwalk: This ability no longer functions.
The Hustle: This ability no longer functions.
The Twist: This ability no longer functions.
A 5 ft step will rarely avoid a full attack from an enemy. They can 5ft step too.
As far as speeding up combat...
I use some custom made cards (roughly 3x5) in combat. Each card is prepared in advance of the game with init mods, attacks, damage, saves, HP total, and special abilities.
After init is rolled, I organize the cards in order of init (each pc has a card too). If a creature takes dmg, I mark it on the card. Once they are dead, I remove it from the stack. If someone holds an action, I turn the card sideways, then place it in the stack in their new position when they finally take the action. I've made my own cards, but I've seen a 3rd party publisher sell a similar item as well.
Doing this, I rarely look at the book during combat, unless I need to see a skill mod, because all the non-combat info is removed from my vision, leaving only the essential info.
In addition, I give players about 60 seconds to make a decision on their action (10 times the length of time their characters have to make a decision). If they don't decide in that time, they automatically go full defense and I move on to the next creature. Note: they don't have to finish their action in this time, but they must at least start it. I figure, they have all that time when other people are acting to plan ahead, plus the 60 seconds in case the situation changes enough to cancell their plans.
You are talking hypotheticals, so there is no right answer. However, there are SOME answers:
The Day the Earth Stood Still
Star Trek: First Contact
1 Borg Cube
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace
1 Droid Control Ship + apx. 20-40 other battleships
1 mothership for every major city (200???)
War of the Worlds
impossible, regardless of numbers
My own thought process believes an alien-human air war would be unlikely. A handful of well placed EMPs would shut down the power grid for all of North America. Add a few more for naval and air bases, and America would be mostly defenseless to an alien air attack with only 15-20 EMPs.
Repeat for the other major military powers of Russia, China, India, U.K., France, and Germany. Then round out the nuclear club (Pakistan, North Korea, Israel) and about 150 EMPs worldwide would wipe out any major air resistance as well as a significant portion of the human ground resistance. Do it in January, when most of the above countries are experiencing freezing temps, and millions of non-military humans would also be eliminated. The aliens would effectively own the skies before the first flying saucer was launched from the mothership. Considering that EMPs are a technology we as humans possess, it is likely any aliens would as well (only better).
Or, they could all be like E.T.
First, let me say I don't believe ANY class is absolutely necessary. However:
The "classic" setup is cleric (healer), fighter (tank), rogue (trapfinder), wizard (artillery).
In your group, the barbarian fills the traditional fighter role, the oracle fills the traditional cleric role, and the sorcerer fills the traditional wizard role. That leaves rogue...
I think a rogue/fighter would be just fine. That would round out all the traditional roles, particularly if you went rogue early.
However, more important than filling any role is playing a class you would enjoy, because enjoying the game is the most important part. If you WANT to play a fighter/rogue, do that. If not, do something else.
I think they should make a Dragonlance movie. I've heard there is an animated movie (I've not seen it), but I'd like to see a live action version.
In the "WHY" category... Battleship. I know its not a book, but that movie left me with so many unanswered whys:
Why THAT game? Why aliens? Why cast an actor with an Irish accent to play an American admiral? Why didn't the movie studio have their security remove whoever pitched this disaster to them? Just WHY???
This closely represents my process for the original item I was going to submit. I worked and reworked it over and over again, but despite chopping off as much as I could, I was still over 300 words. In the end, I gave up and wrote items B, C, and D... and item C is the one I submitted.
Also, on the subject of pay, I've sat in on 2 writers seminars at Gencon, and based on the information there, I would say the standard pay seems to be 1 cent/word for inexperienced writers, to 3 cents/word for the average writer, to 5 cents/word for the "A list" writers.
It was also mentioned that the pay has remained the same for decades, while inflation has continued to rise, meaning that modern writers are actually getting an effectively smaller paycheck than their predecessors. Fortunately, most RPG writers are not doing it (only) for the money.
I've heard more than once: "The best way to make a small fortune in the RPG industry, is to start with a large fortune."
Bjorn Turoque (the "j" is pronounced like a "y")
Plus, these also work without changing them...
I thought that was what email is for. (or voicemail)
1) email is free,
That might be the first time it didn't annoy me.
Well, it could be. One if my groups (the one I play with the most) uses the crit and fumble decks. We confirm fumbles just like we confirm crits, meaning that you roll again. If you still miss, its a fumble. If you hit in the confirmation, then its not a fumble. Thus, its easier for bad things to happen vs tough opponents, but rarely happens against weak ones.
EDIT: Deathquaker, that same group does that, though we don't call it "exploding". It's a rare event when someone confirms a crit with another crit, but when it happens, it is exciting for the whole table.
This would have been my suggestion.
If it were a bow, I would give an equivalent penalty (confirmed critic, but you need to spend a standard action to re-string). For a bludgeoning weapon, I'd confirm the crit, but say it got wet with blood or sweat or whatever, causing the character to drop it.
naw, the only downside of playing as a dwarf is roleplaying tha accent.
Yeah. Most people play dwarves with a Scottish accent, but since they come from Norse mythology, they should probably have a Norwegian accent. Yet, the Scottish tradition is so prevalent, anything else just sounds wrong.
To the op, I may be biased (check out my avatar pic.), but I disagree. You can't compare any of the core races to the aasimar, because the
I don't think its possible without a major redesign of the rules. To ballance out the issues others mentioned, you would have to make CASTING a skill as well, like knowledge. For example, Casting Arcane (Divination) or Casting Divine (Conjuration). But once you get to that point, you are basically talking about a classless system, or at best, a semi-classless system like M.E.R.P./Rolemaster/H.A.R.P. You are better off just picking a system that does most of what you want.
You could just give everyone (adults anyway) a free level in an NPC class, and call that adolescence. It's the trade everyone was taught by their parents or guardians while growing up. No one teaches their kid to be an adventurer.
With this method, your average NPC would end up with 2 HD, and the PCs might think its cool to take a rank in aristocrat (comes with some minor title or official govt appointment), or warrior or adept (for the combat advantages). Some might even select expert for the skill bonuses.
Of course, more HP to start still doesn't solve your problem at higher levels.
A siege would have to be like an imprisonment, not a traditional siege. As you said, they don't need food or water, so time is on their side.
Look at the Battle of Alesia, when Julius Caesar defeated Vercingetorix, for an example of what I mean. The Gauls were inside a walled city, and outnumbered the Romans. So Caesar ordered a wall... built around the wall. He encircled the entire city with another wall, defended by the Romans, effectively turning the city into a prison. Of course, the Gauls were forced to action by virtue of their larger army needing more food, but besieging and undead army could be just a safe(er) way to deal with the threat than attacking their castle.
I like them for the jokes, which can be udderly amusing. No bull!
But I would steer clear of calling a minotaur cowvalier "Sir Loin". They might look pasture human faults, but most minotaurs will get mad (cow) if they field like you are insulting them. They will have a beef with you till the day you die. It is farm more safe to moove away and hoof these jokes in a place where you can't be herd by the minotaur. As humans, most minotaus can taurus limb from limb. You better bellieve it! I'd steak my reputation on it. But hay, who am I to offer advice? I tend to cattle, er, prattle on.
...Ok, that last one was a stretch. I think I've milked about every pun I could out of this.
As someone pointed out... Don't think of hit points as the amount of damage you can take. Think of it more as your endurance. How long you can continue to duck and weave to avoid the real hits... Which are anything that takes you negative HP or causes bleed or some other condition.
However, if you truely don't like the HP concept (ill admit to prefering systems with health levels myself), feel free to change it. Just keep in mind that spells beyond 1st level will become MUCH more effective if you limit HP. To the point of game unballancing. So you will need to limit the damage output (and healing factor) as well. Maybe even standardize damage for all spells of the same level (single Target spells should do more damage than multi-target spells).
Then of course, if you do that, then resistances to energy types become more powerful if spells deal less damage, and DR becomes overpowered... You might end up rewriting a significant portion of the game, as each change has a butterfly effect on everything else.
Instead of rewriting a core mechanic like HP, I suggest looking for the D20 Game of Thrones RPG (not the current one in print, the out of print one), which did pretty much what you are describing. Characters got 1-3 HP when they leveled, based on their class. Of course, magic is far less common in Westros, so you don't have to worry about a TPK from a single fireball.
Yes alcohol is a poison. So are drugs. In fact many drugs (even legal ones) are modified forms of natural poisons. Other times, the line between poison and food (or drug) is really just a matter of how much was ingested, and there is no difference.
Alcohol and drugs should count as poisons for all game mechanics. They are toxins that modify the body chemistry.
You said it yourself. The bad guys don't know the party's low on fuel. If they went in with guns-a-blazin, then at least SOME of the badguys will think that this is a tough group. I'd let them get away with it once. Maybe the bad guys try to gather reinforcements before attacking, or only the people that think the party is low on power attacks... Which will ammount to a probing attack if any of them escape.
I don't think that they necessarily need to be the most powerful if they are the most numerous. There is roughly 500 years of history involving European colonialism, that shows you can still be the most powerful while being vastly outnumbered. Go back even further and the Mongols, Romans, and Macedonians also showed power and numerical superiority were two different things.
You can still have humans, elves, or even orcs be the most powerful race, even if half elves are more populous. The empire fell for a reason...
That is an iconic adventure. Real old school stuff, back in the day when Arneson and Gygax got along, if I'm not mistaken. I've always wanted to play that, its been talked about enough. I started with this edition of DnD ("basic" was not its official name, just something it acquired when "advanced" came out), but I never got to play Keep on the Borderlands.
To the OP, you really want to see a difference in editions, pick up "basic".
EDIT: Nope, Borderlands was published in '79, Arneson left TSR in '76 and didn't work with them again till '86. So, Borderlands came out at the height of the feud.