Snark Powers activate

[Vadims Hesins]

Argh, a ZZ-laden spell-in-a-can versus a self-advertising item :|
I guess I will vote for the first one in hope that it was made by a first-time designer.

[The black raven]

You are cute. And your second ability is a great idea that should have been your focus IMO. Nice try though.

[The black raven]

flykiller wrote:

Argh, a ZZ-laden spell-in-a-can versus a self-advertising item :|

I guess I will vote for the first one in hope that it was made by a first-time designer.

I think I got that exact same pairing just a few minutes ago :-/

[The black raven]

That is a wonderful use for this spell. I would like to see more from your designer. And Keep it is.

[The black raven]

Meta item :-(

[The black raven]

Several items that have additional abilities when used in conjunction with other items. Some in the PRD, others not.

IMO, your item should stand on its own.

[The black raven]

That is an Emo item

[Kobold Catgirl]

Shot you a PM, Black Raven.

[The black raven]

You should have checked what other items with this price do. You would likely have realized that your item is OP.

[The black raven]

Item with non-PFRPG formatting vs Item for Occult Adventures :-/

[The black raven]

That last ability makes it a SiaC and a SAK. You should have focussed on the item's theme, not on its imagery.

[The black raven]

This niche item is the perfect countermeasure to the weaponized drawback I saw yesterday :-))

[The black raven]

This weapon just gave me a cute idea for a wondrous item :-)

[The black raven]

And another undead-making item

[The black raven]

The black raven wrote:

And another undead-making item

And another one

[The black raven]

Is that a real word ?

[Vadims Hesins]

I have seen several items which color-code human emotions. Is that an IRL thing too?

[The black raven]

flykiller wrote:

I have seen several items which color-code human emotions. Is that an IRL thing too?

I blame Geoff Johns ;-)

[The black raven]

Slot Armor s Slot Armor. Fight

[The black raven]

Uninteresting wins against overpowered.

[Brigg]

I WILL SHOUT MY ITEM NAME AT YOU!!!

[John Whyte]

A drinking item with a random bonus, vs something I'm pretty sure is stolen straight out of a joke from a webcomic.
Also one of these is 83 words and the other is 298
I've seen both before and selected the opponents each other time.
I don't know....

[Brigg]

If your magic armor or weapon does not contain any iteration of "This +x weapon" or "This +x Armor" within the first 2 sentences, I'm most likely going to vote for the other item.

Unless the other item does it, too. Then you just got lucky.

[Flanwaw]

John Whyte wrote:

A drinking item with a random bonus, vs something I'm pretty sure is stolen straight out of a joke from a webcomic.

Also one of these is 83 words and the other is 298
I've seen both before and selected the opponents each other time.
I don't know....

People seem to think that alcohol can do anything - and any ability fits the theme of booze.

It makes me wonder if some among us need to take a few weeks off the sauce.

[Rei]

Overpowered item vs. overpowered item. At least one of them is vastly underpriced so I know which one to go for.

[Dave_Vader]

No formatting and confusing description vs item with an effect that is completely useless. Useless it is I guess...

[John Whyte]

Spell in a weapon Vs horribly horribly under priced benefits for any social orientated character.

Making matters worse this is the third time I've seen the weapon, and the third time I'm voting for it. The alternatives are always worse.

I need a shower

[pH unbalanced]

Is it just me or are there a *lot* of Books and Tomes this year?

That might be my takeaway meme.

[frank gori]

That's so Meta Item, check

[enderxenocide0]

Is it just me, or are there a lot of "Take that, ghosts!" entries?

[The black raven]

There are several items that describe in great detail what the non-magic base item does. Too bad that Round 1 is to design a magic item and not a mundane piece of equipment.

[The black raven]

Wrong type for this season, no matter what the added properties do.

[The black raven]

Blood items twice in a row :-/

[Brigg]

Um...I don't think ANYTHING in Pathfinder EVER will EVER cost that much. That is an Artifact!

[The black raven]

And another Wrists vs Wrists duel. Engage.

[The black raven]

People do like Djinns apparently.

[The black raven]

And canaries too :-)

[The black raven]

2 consecutive items with prisms.

And another of many items dealing with the planes.

[The black raven]

Djinn vs Banshee - Fight

[The black raven]

And it's a charge item that makes my Keep list. Goes to show that strong visuals, appropriate (not OP) abilities and well-priced item will always win the day ;-)

[The black raven]

You give me absolute power for less than 10,000 gp ? Where's the catch ?

[DM_aka_Dudemeister]

Snake. Snake? Snaaaaaaake!!!!

[The black raven]

You are overcomplicated.

The other item is far worse.

Take my vote.

[pH unbalanced]

Don't use the words 'should' or 'should not' in your description -- you job is to tell us what the item does, not to give advice to the user.

[Joseph Kellogg]

I don't wanna be that guy who's constantly asking other people if they have change for a platinum.

[RonarsCorruption]

Found a weapon that grants blanket trap immunity... Okay then.

[RonarsCorruption]

If that armor wasn't written in a way that makes it sound more like a plot hook, it might be exceptionally interesting.

[frank gori]

ack I need an ADULTER ADULT I'm not Adult enough for this.

[Darklord Morius]

Food in a can!

[Molechaser]

Flagon item vs. dragon item. Where's Danny Kaye?