Allip damage question

[Cardinal Chunder]

I'm prolly over thinking this but...
1: An allip hits a PC does it do d4 WIS damage AND they have to make a save to prevent a further D4 damage from its Touch of Insanity.
2: An allip hits, the Touch of Insanity is the attack and the PC only takes WIS damage on a failed WILL save.

Thanks

[kinevon]

Number 2 is correct.

[Cardinal Chunder]

kinevon wrote:

Number 2 is correct.

Thanks...I thought one was very harsh!