Summoner playtest: Half-Eidolons and related topics


Round 2: Summoner and Witch


Summoner Playtest Download wrote:

...The eidolon takes a form shaped by the summoner’s desires. The eidolon’s Hit Dice, saving throws, skills, feats, and abilities are tied to the summoner’s class level and increase as the summoner gains levels. In addition, each eidolon receives a pool of evolution points, based on the summoner’s class level, that can be used to give the eidolon different abilities and powers. Whenever the summoner gains a level, he must decide how these points are spent, and they are set until he gains another level of summoner.

The eidolon’s physical appearance is up to the summoner, but it always appears as some sort of fantastical creature. This control is not fine enough to make the eidolon appear like a specific creature...

Given that the eidolon takes a form shaped by the summoner's desires, I think it reasonable to assume that some summoners are going to pick something incredibly sexy looking of the opposite gender... And that furthermore some are going to go so far as to mate with their eidolon, repeatedly.

Whether a summoner needs to invest evolution points in an eidolon to be able to produce off-spring from such unions, or whether it can happen anyway without any such intent by the summoner, it seems to me likely that the patter of tiny feet is going to occasionally result, so what exactly are half-eidolons?
Are they a sort of native outsider variant of a doppleganger?

Dark Archive

Honestly, I wuld have never throught of that.


David Fryer wrote:
Honestly, I wuld have never throught of that.

Nah, thats what Polymorph is for...or animate dead...

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

David Fryer wrote:
Honestly, I wuld have never throught of that.

Actually it wasn't my ... first ... thought! But I did think of it.

My guess is that there would be no offspring of such a union. Just because "it" may have a female form does not mean that it would have famale funtionality.

Dark Archive

See, I was imagining something like this.


It is possible to physically 'mate' but not produce offspring. Some species just dont mix. And somehow I am extremely doubtful paizo will ever include a fertility evolution.


Clearly, you fellas don't watch enough (too much?) Japanese anime...

As soon as I saw the tentacle evolution, I started wondering how many tentacles you could put on a Eidolon...

I also like how some assume it will be a male summoner with a female Eidolon. The reverse is also possible.

Off the cuff, since the Eidolon is an outsider with a "fiendish" trend, I'd suggest half-fiend -- if that sort of thing is allowed in your games.


Kolokotroni wrote:
It is possible to physically 'mate' but not produce offspring. Some species just dont mix. And somehow I am extremely doubtful paizo will ever include a fertility evolution.

The Porphyry House Horror (written by James Jacobs and published in Dungeon magazine) would appear to indicate that more species mix than you might initially think (or at least back in third edition D&D).

Edit:
Warning! The Porphyry House Horror was the only sealed content I have ever come across in Dungeon in the sixty or so issues I purchased Dungeon for. Content may possibly offend some readers.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

Kolokotroni wrote:
It is possible to physically 'mate' but not produce offspring. Some species just dont mix. And somehow I am extremely doubtful paizo will ever include a fertility evolution.

I was also thinking that a Summoner's Eidolon would be effectivly a "robot" so it would have the appearance and feel of a woman, but none of the internal (fertility type) abilities.

I bigger problem would be the "sentience" of the Eidolon. Would it/she be aware of her enslaved condition and therefore hate her master? Or would she become both incredibly needy and possessive of her master?


I love these boards!

I consider myself a pretty sick puppy and then I realize that there are whole realms of depravity that I've yet to consider.

Dark Archive

Disenchanter wrote:

Clearly, you fellas don't watch enough (too much?) Japanese anime...

As soon as I saw the tentacle evolution, I started wondering how many tentacles you could put on a Eidolon...

I also like how some assume it will be a male summoner with a female Eidolon. The reverse is also possible.

Off the cuff, since the Eidolon is an outsider with a "fiendish" trend, I'd suggest half-fiend -- if that sort of thing is allowed in your games.

Not really commenting on the other stuff, but I really don't see the fiendish trend. It could just as easily have a celestial or any other outsider type trend.


What about the witch and her octopus familiar...
*shudder*


TomCollins wrote:

I love these boards!

I consider myself a pretty sick puppy and then I realize that there are whole realms of depravity that I've yet to consider.

Spoiler:
A bunch of summoners and their eidolons are running a brothel and competing with the doppelgangers across the street...
The Exchange

Sounds like we have a new PC race to make.


Pathfinder Adventure Path, Rulebook Subscriber
Spacelard wrote:

What about the witch and her octopus familiar...

*shudder*

How about the wizard and his raven familiar polymorphed into a comely elf?

And I picked raven so the familiar can talk dirty to him.


Drakli wrote:
Spacelard wrote:

What about the witch and her octopus familiar...

*shudder*

How about the wizard and his raven familiar polymorphed into a comely elf?

And I picked raven so the familiar can talk dirty to him.

There are all sorts of things wrong with what you just said there...

Dark Archive

Spacelard wrote:

What about the witch and her octopus familiar...

*shudder*

Clearly spoken bysomeone who has watched to much anime. Anyone for Legend of the Overfiend?

Scarab Sages

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Drakli wrote:
Spacelard wrote:

What about the witch and her octopus familiar...

*shudder*

How about the wizard and his raven familiar polymorphed into a comely elf?

And I picked raven so the familiar can talk dirty to him.

...and that's where Tengu come from.

Dark Archive

Quote:


I love these boards!

I consider myself a pretty sick puppy and then I realize that there are whole realms of depravity that I've yet to consider.

Welcome to life in general, dude. As the Apostle Paul said "Brothers, be knowledgeable of what is good, and be as babes in evil..."

So I find that statement is quite applicable most of the days of my life. To be quite bold, I only recently found out what the word "Sodomy" meant. (And I'm not that young, nor sheltered, I just choose not to pay much attention to everything that comes my way.)

Back on topic, I think this is an excellent Idea. I don't think it would be an issue in any campaign I ran, nor would I think it to be an issue of the Eidolon necessarily hating or needing their master. In fact, I don't see why you can't just increase the Eidolon's Intelligence Score as you gain levels.

I don't see this as being an issue of perversion either, because the two entities could very much love each other, their relationships being borne out of affection and friendship rather than carnality. If one of my players was just doing this to be horny at the gaming table, I'd not allow it, but if the player built the Eidolon right, I don't see any issues, especially if they increased it's Intelligence score.

Dark Archive

Here's what I'm thinking for Half-Eidolon:

The Half-Eidolon is the offspring of a Summoner and their Eidolon. Most of these unions are made by consensual partners, the Eidolon and Summoner not viewing their relationship as Master and Servitor, but rather seeing each other as partners and sharing their love for one another often times, if the Summoner is skilled enough, leads to the birth of a Half-breed. Unlike most Half-breeds, the Half-Eidolon is usually brought up in a caring environment, a physical seal of the Eidolon's commitment to it's summoner. The Half-Eidolon also bears a measure of it's Otherworldly parent's power, able to take on a limited number of evolutions and the ability to change it's form from the standard Bipedal form it was born in, to a form it chooses to practice from a young age.

Type: Outsider (Native)

+2 to STR or CHA, -2 to CON or INT

+2 bonus to Disguise skill checks

Alter Form (Su) 1/day: The Half-Eidolon gains the ability to shift it's base form from Bipedal to either Serpentine or Quadrupedal (Chosen at first level). The Half-Eidolon's Ability scores are not altered while in this altered form, but gains natural attacks and evolutions as an eidolon of their size and form. They may change back to the base Bipedal form at any time, but must wait until the next day to change into their chosen alternate form. This is a Supernatural Ability

Size: Small or Medium (If small, it gets all appropriate modifiers)

Evolutions: The Half-Eidolon chooses any 1 point Evolution from the Summoner class features list. At 6th level, increase the number of evolution points available to 2 plus 1 for every three levels thereafter. A Half-Eidolon cannot choose the Large or Huge size increase, or any evolution that requires a feature that the Half-Eidolon does not possess. Every time the Half-Eidolon gains a level, they may "respend" their evolution points to change their options.

Alignment: Most Half-Eidolon's are born to a Summoner and their Eidolon, and the resulting half-breed is usually a little wild and adventurous, seeking answers to questions they cannot express. Half-Eidolon's thus tend to be Chaotic, but may be Lawful, seeking some sort of solidity to their existance.

Favored Class: Summoner or Bard. The Half-Eidolon was raised with love and care, unlike most half breeds, and thus finds no opposition to finding their own strength of will suitable to the art of the Summoner. The few who came from more carnal relationships find the life of a wandering bard more to their liking.

Sample first level Half-Eidolon Fighter::

Adun, Half-Eidolon (Outsider, Native) Fighter 1, Chaotic Good

+STR: 16 +3
DEX: 14 +2
CON: 13 +1
-INT: 9 -1
WIS: 11 +0
CHA: 15 +2

FORT: +3
REF: +2
WILL: +0

BAB: +1
AC: 18
T: 12 FF: 16

CMB: +1
CMD: +1

Evolutions:
Spell Like Ability: True Strike 1/day, Bipedal

Alter Form: Serpentine 1/day

Outsider Traits

Size: Medium

+2 to Disguise Skill Checks

Skills:
Intimidate: +6 (Class, Trained)
Disguise: +4

Feats:
(1) Power Attack
(F) Cleave

Attacks:
Greatsword: +4, 2d6 +4, x2
Claws: +4, 1d6 +3, x2

Armour:
Breastplate: +6 AC, etc.

Other Gear:
Backpack
Bedroll
Flint and Steel
3 Sunrods
10 days trail rations

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

Adun wrote:


Quote:


I love these boards!

I consider myself a pretty sick puppy and then I realize that there are whole realms of depravity that I've yet to consider.

Welcome to life in general, dude. As the Apostle Paul said "Brothers, be knowledgeable of what is good, and be as babes in evil..."

In a demonstration of my level of depravity, when I read "and be as babes in evil ..." my brain immediately went to ... "be as babes in evil ..."


Adun wrote:

Here's what I'm thinking for Half-Eidolon:

The Half-Eidolon is the offspring of a Summoner and their Eidolon. Most of these unions are made by consensual partners, the Eidolon and Summoner not viewing their relationship as Master and Servitor, but rather seeing each other as partners and sharing their love for one another often times, if the Summoner is skilled enough, leads to the birth of a Half-breed. Unlike most Half-breeds, the Half-Eidolon is usually brought up in a caring environment, a physical seal of the Eidolon's commitment to it's summoner. The Half-Eidolon also bears a measure of it's Otherworldly parent's power, able to take on a limited number of evolutions and the ability to change it's form from the standard Bipedal form it was born in, to a form it chooses to practice from a young age.

Type: Outsider (Native)

+2 to STR or CHA, -2 to CON or INT

+2 bonus to Disguise skill checks

Alter Form (Su) 1/day: The Half-Eidolon gains the ability to shift it's base form from Bipedal to either Serpentine or Quadrupedal (Chosen at first level). The Half-Eidolon's Ability scores are not altered while in this altered form, but gains natural attacks and evolutions as an eidolon of their size and form. They may change back to the base Bipedal form at any time, but must wait until the next day to change into their chosen alternate form. This is a Supernatural Ability

Size: Small or Medium (If small, it gets all appropriate modifiers)

Evolutions: The Half-Eidolon chooses any 1 point Evolution from the Summoner class features list. At 6th level, increase the number of evolution points available to 2 plus 1 for every three levels thereafter. A Half-Eidolon cannot choose the Large or Huge size increase, or any evolution that requires a feature that the Half-Eidolon does not possess. Every time the Half-Eidolon gains a level, they may "respend" their evolution points to change their options.

Alignment: Most Half-Eidolon's are born to a Summoner and their Eidolon, and the resulting half-breed is...

This is horrifying and wrong.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

John Falter wrote:
This is horrifying and wrong.

Horrifying? Silly perhapse, but Horrifying?

As to Wrong: It should be written in Pathfinder RPG Format

  • Stat Bonuses should be +2 Bonus to one physical, +2 Bonus to one mental, an a -2 penalty to one stat.
  • Favored Classes have been changed in the game. The are selected by the character at creation.
  • I don't believe that Summoners have an alignment restriction, so the assumption of "raised with love and care" may not be valid.

    With the structure, I might suggest statting it up as a Template, applied to the summoner's base race.

    That said: I still see Eidolons as effectively sentient robots, so I do not forsee them breeding with a mortal being.


  • Lord Fyre wrote:

    ...That said: I still see Eidolons as effectively sentient robots, so I do not forsee them breeding with a mortal being.

    (edited)

    I might have expected them to have the 'construct' type with the (extraplanar) subtype in a similar fashion to retrievers if they were sentient robots.
    The only reference to type and subtype that I can find them as having, however, is that of 'outsider'.

    RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    Lord Fyre wrote:

    ...That said: I still see Eidolons as effectively sentient robots, so I do not forsee them breeding with a mortal being.

    (edited)

    I might have expected them to have the 'construct' type with the (extraplanar) subtype in a similar fashion to retrievers if they were sentient robots.
    The only reference to type and subtype that I can find them as having, however, is that of 'outsider'.

    My point was that an Eidolon is "not real" in the sense that this thread is going.

    Yes, I understand that they have a Constitution Score, but that does not make them the same as a "living being."

    Dark Archive

    Lord Fyre wrote:
    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    Lord Fyre wrote:

    ...That said: I still see Eidolons as effectively sentient robots, so I do not forsee them breeding with a mortal being.

    (edited)

    I might have expected them to have the 'construct' type with the (extraplanar) subtype in a similar fashion to retrievers if they were sentient robots.
    The only reference to type and subtype that I can find them as having, however, is that of 'outsider'.

    My point was that an Eidolon is "not real" in the sense that this thread is going.

    Yes, I understand that they have a Constitution Score, but that does not make them the same as a "living being."

    Exactly, The class description states that you are just summoning a portion of the eidolon's essence, not the actual entity itself.

    Contributor

    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    I think it reasonable to assume that some summoners are going to pick something incredibly sexy looking of the opposite gender...

    Somewhere in here - past my thoroughly creeped outness - is an " "interesting" " idea (I'm double quoting that). Assume, however, that mixed drinks and Barry White have no special effects on ediolons and that any "adventurous romance" (though I could think of much shorter words for this) is going to get you nothing more than the MOST AWKWARD morning after ever. I mean, might be time to change classes after than @#$%.

    Not saying something like this CAN'T happen (we've got the owlbear after all and that baby's parents didn't meet at the club), but trust such things to the "Mad Wizards" of first edition lore and keep your wandering hands off your ediolons (you'll probably go a lot worse than blind if you don't).

    I'm so glad this didn't come up when we released the druid.


    F. Wesley Schneider wrote:
    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    I think it reasonable to assume that some summoners are going to pick something incredibly sexy looking of the opposite gender...

    Somewhere in here - past my thoroughly creeped outness - is an " "interesting" " idea (I'm double quoting that). Assume, however, that mixed drinks and Barry White have no special effects on ediolons and that any "adventurous romance" (though I could think of much shorter words for this) is going to get you nothing more than the MOST AWKWARD morning after ever. I mean, might be time to change classes after than @#$%.

    Not saying something like this CAN'T happen (we've got the owlbear after all and that baby's parents didn't meet at the club), but trust such things to the "Mad Wizards" of first edition lore and keep your wandering hands off your ediolons (you'll probably go a lot worse than blind if you don't).

    I'm so glad this didn't come up when we released the druid.

    Given that the Summoner's casting ability stat is Charisma, it seems to me that some of them are prime candidates to be the sort of egotistical narcissistic maniacs for whom other mortals 'simply wouldn't be good enough', but who would prefer an amorous associate who didn't come with the agenda of a firre or ghaele attached. (Or that of some other more independent other-planar nature.)

    And how many times in real world stories do we see characters depicted who are looking for that perfect 'Mr. Right' (or 'Miss./Mrs. Right') of their dreams?
    Well in Golarion any Summoners (if the class ends up being published approximately as has been written here in the playtest) of such tendencies have the tools at their disposal to sate those desires. Yes, they may be regarded with horror or denounced by other Summoners, clerics, or the public in general, but someone with Charisma of 15+ is sufficiently self-assured that they can derisorily dismiss such reactions with 'let the plebs talk - their opinions do not matter'.

    Edit:
    Anyway, back on topic, if Paizo introduce eidolons, I think that half-eidolons are something which need some serious consideration for inclusion.

    (And for James Jacobs, a taxonomic query - are eidolons possibly related to haveros?)

    Dark Archive

    F. Wesley Schneider wrote:


    I'm so glad this didn't come up when we released the druid.

    Damn Wes, now I have to get a red hot poker to burn that out of my mind.

    Contributor

    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    ...someone with Charisma of 15+ is sufficiently self-assured that they can derisorily dismiss such reactions with 'let the plebs talk - their opinions do not matter'.

    Too true. I would say that nothing comes of it though. As has been said above, you're summoning up mainly an impression of the creature, not it's true being, and though an eidolon can certainly be shaped to look like a duck and sound like a duck, it will never truly be a ducks. And you're not a duck either, so even if it was a real duck, you wouldn't be getting any ducklings. (I think my metaphor just ruined the whole duck pond.)

    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    (And for James Jacobs, a taxonomic query - are eidolons possibly related to haveros?)

    Playing the role of James Jacobs today will be Wes Schneider: No. Haveros have more to do with Lovecraftian ideas of things that come from the voids between the stars, where eidolons are more things that come from the rampant potentiality between the planes and similarly ill defined places of endless possibility.

    Dark Archive

    Did you play Final Fantasy 6?


    F. Wesley Schneider wrote:
    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    ...someone with Charisma of 15+ is sufficiently self-assured that they can derisorily dismiss such reactions with 'let the plebs talk - their opinions do not matter'.

    Too true. I would say that nothing comes of it though. As has been said above, you're summoning up mainly an impression of the creature, not it's true being, and though an eidolon can certainly be shaped to look like a duck and sound like a duck, it will never truly be a ducks. And you're not a duck either, so even if it was a real duck, you wouldn't be getting any ducklings. (I think my metaphor just ruined the whole duck pond.)

    Charles Evans 25 wrote:
    (And for James Jacobs, a taxonomic query - are eidolons possibly related to haveros?)
    Playing the role of James Jacobs today will be Wes Schneider: No. Haveros have more to do with Lovecraftian ideas of things that come from the voids between the stars, where eidolons are more things that come from the rampant potentiality between the planes and similarly ill defined places of endless possibility.

    With regard to the 'even if it was a real duck' observation that you make, what about dragons? Are dragons the same sort of ducks as elves, humans, half-elves, ogres, etc, etc? If not, then it seems to me that by your reasoning half-dragons should not exist, if I have understood you correctly.

    With regard to how much an eidolon is actual and how much an impression I would like to observe that the link which allows it to ignore protection spells seems to also indicate that the greater the proximity to the Summoner who called it, the more 'there' it is, whilst the reverse holds true to the point where an eidolon (or what for the purposes of the summoner is the eidolon) completely fades away if it becomes too remote. On a Tolkien note, the maia Melian formed a bond/pairing with the elven lord Thingol, which allowed her to take on the raiment of the flesh of the children of Arda, and to bear Lúthien...

    As to haveros, I ask since those seem to be mutable creatures (although perhaps not to quite the same extent), and I wondered if possibly they could be eidolons cast out from or exiled from whatever other plane that they called home aeons ago, confined to the spaces between the stars and become diminished, bitter, and malevolent in their brooding in all the time that has passed between? But okay, if they're not related, then they're not related.... Well probably not, unless a havero Summoner happens to... ;)

    This is a fun debate! Thanks. :)


    Draeke Raefel wrote:
    Not really commenting on the other stuff, but I really don't see the fiendish trend. It could just as easily have a celestial or any other outsider type trend.

    Claws, Horns, Poison, Tentacles, and "burned skin or cold breath" (for the resistance evolution) don't read as celestial to me. Definitely reads as a more fiendish trend.

    Does it have to be? No. But the trend is there.


    Lord Fyre wrote:
    Yes, I understand that they have a Constitution Score, but that does not make them the same as a "living being."

    Actually, it does. Constitution defines a creature as "living." Name one living creature that doesn't have a Con score, or one non-living that does, in the game.

    David Fryer wrote:
    Exactly, The class description states that you are just summoning a portion of the eidolon's essence, not the actual entity itself.

    So... The children of deities are from the mortal parent and the god itself? There is no way for an aspect of a deity to create offspring? That dangerous ground to tread with regards to most mythologies.

    F. Wesley Schneider wrote:
    I'm so glad this didn't come up when we released the druid.

    It did, and has. Maybe you just missed those threads.


    as per ability... Aasimar are the children of angels (which are outsiders) and mortals. I would assume it's POSSIBLE.

    That being said, this thread is so wrong in oh so many ways...

    RPG Superstar 2010 Top 16

    Disenchanter wrote:
    David Fryer wrote:
    Exactly, The class description states that you are just summoning a portion of the eidolon's essence, not the actual entity itself.
    So... The children of deities are from the mortal parent and the god itself? There is no way for an aspect of a deity to create offspring? That dangerous ground to tread with regards to most mythologies.

    Including Golarion's:

    Spoiler:
    Doing as he was told, <redacted> ingested the coin, not realizing the truth of what <redacted> had provided him. Mammon, the Lord of the Third, is in fact all the treasure that comes to lie within Hell's vaults, being a creature of no forms and of many, a profane genus loci, an animating spirit. Thus, by swallowing the coin, <redacted> allowed Mammon to temporarily possess him and impart his foul immortal seed unto the criminal's unsuspecting wife.

    (Character names removed from the spoiler to minimize actual spoil potential, because I think naming the source would be an even bigger spoiler. This is GM-only text.)


    Just spotted a poster whose PC is, well, in love with their eidolon: *link*

    Community / Forums / Archive / Pathfinder / Playtests & Prerelease Discussions / Advanced Player's Guide Playtest / Round 2: Summoner and Witch / Summoner playtest: Half-Eidolons and related topics All Messageboards
    Recent threads in Round 2: Summoner and Witch