I wrote a longer post, but then the store threw an error when I tried to post it. I'll make it short and sweet this time: I was missing five minis from having a complete set (38, 39, 47, 50, 51). I have two broken minis. Several minis feel like they will probably fall off of their stand in the near future. I would give the paint/sculpt job an average of 4 out of 5. Some of them get a 5 for being awesome, while some get a 2. (What is wrong with Seltyiel's face?) I'm questioning if I want to continue my subscription since $400 to be missing so many and have such quality issues seems like a bad investment. Looking at the price for singles for previous sets, I'm guessing I will have to pay yet another $40 to complete my set.
I just purchased this after seeing it on the front page. I'm really enjoying it so far. Some positives that stand out:
+Looks rather professional. Quite a bit of nice art throughout and few grammar issues. All it is missing is color.
+Classes feel unique. I dislike it when a 'new' class seems like it could be made with a couple of alternate class features or feats. (As a side note, I like it how Pathfinder seems to focus on versatile base classes rather than creating a ton of different prestige classes.)
+Many cool feats. I expected most of the new feats to be made specifically for the new classes, but I was wrong. Several of the feats caused me to say, "Awesome!" due to the mental image they evoked.
Some concerns:
-Some of the feats seem like they might be overpowered. Now, most of the more powerful feats did require a skill feat (which makes it almost like two feats from a combat perspective) but I'm still not sure.
-I would have liked to see more feats specific to the new classes (the Shadow Assassin in particular.)
-Some wording is fuzzy. For example, does Acrobatic Dodge give you a five-foot step every time you make the check or only if you succeed it? I expect the latter, but it sounds like the former to me.
