So after all of their shenanigans on the Wormwood (see my last post in this thread), Captain Harrigan wants the party off his ship, foisting them onto Scourge's Man's Promise. They're told to go get their stuff but I'm a nice DM and don't force them to accept an escort belowdecks.
So that troublesome half-orc from last time hasn't earned any of his equipment back and since the entire crew is on the main deck (and Grok is unfriendly) he can't even buy his stuff from her.
He breaks into the store and TAKES his equipment back, including that sack of coffee and his earthbreaker. I remind the player that this stuff belongs to Harrigan now and that he'll have to walk past him on the way to the new ship. He shrugs his shoulders nonchalantly and says that's fine.
Back on the main deck he's stopped by the cap'n himself.
"You've got some brass balls to steal from me, swab. I've keelhauled folk for less."
"I'll pay you more than they're worth from my share of the booty." (Fool forgot honourifics AND the respectful tone)
"What if I'm not interested in yer gold? I'll give ye yer stuff - got no need fer it anyway - in exchange fer two of yer fingers."
The player asks me what the game penalties for losing fingers are. I say -1 Dexterity for every thee fingers lost. The character says okay, grits his teeth, draws a knife and cuts off the little finger from each hand.
"Those weren't the fingers I wanted." Harrigan says with an evil smile.