Hey, don't we all borrow a little from those that have come before? I think Tolkien standardized Dwarves, Elves, Rangers, WIzards and Hobbits. Whether GG felt like he was inspired by Tolkien or not, it would be hard to say there was no influence. Just like it would be hard to say Barbarians in D&D weren't somewhat influenced by Robert Howard.
It would kind of like saying that comic book writers today weren't influenced by Superman. Maybe they don't take direct inspiration from Supes, but as a genre-defining icon, the fact that there was an influence seems hard to deny.
Joel Gates
www.greengatesinc.blogspot.com