Janzir's page

Can someone please explain how the rogue, who gets a sneak attack if his opponent is caught unawares (no DEX bonus) and that only lasting one round except in special circumstances, that simply because the rogue is now flanking an opponent gets unlimited sneak attacks?

Since the inception of the rogue, 1E, a sneak attack was a once per opponent per battle thing and it involved sneaking. That is, hide in shadows/stealth.

So we come to 3E and it is possible to flank and get a sneak attack (something that has been done since 1E, but without the pretty name). But again, only one sneak attack. After that, the opponent was aware of you can could defend, thus preventing further sneak attacks (again barring special circumstances).

Now all of a sudden a rogue can flank (because a name was added to the manuvuer) and they can sneak attack each round without limitation? Regardless that the opponent has his DEX bonus and can defend? This makes the rogue the best melee class. How did that happen? Was I asleep? This seems like massive powergaming from a perspective of 32 years playing.

I would really like to see an official Paizo staff member explain. Further clarification in the books or updates or srd would be wonderful.