I would like to rate this low because I didn't like playing it. But the fault is not with the writing (which is quite good) but rather with my subjective response to the content. I wasn't expecting this adventure to be so full of dead children. Having played it, I go back to the description and yes I can see how I could have concluded that from the "academy for youth" now being lost in the "drownyards". And yet at the time I was playing I found the scenario more than a little ghoulish. On one hand it's awesome that it's one of the most atmospheric scenarios I have ever played. If I had known ahead of time it was going to be a horror-toned scenario I would have been better able to appreciate it. Or avoid it, depending on my mood.