I roll initative for everyone at the start of combat and will post a list that looks like this
Example 1 wrote:
Initiative
Combat modifiers like bless or inspire courage are posted here
Player A
Player B
- - -
Enemy 1
- - -
Player C
Player D
- - -
Enemy 2
In this case Player A and Player B can act, and Players C and D can not. If Player B posts his action those action are resolved and I change the tracker to:
Example 2 wrote:
Initiative
Combat modifiers like bless or inspire courage are posted here
Player A
- - -
Enemy 1
- - -
Player C
Player D
- - -
Enemy 2
- - -
Player B
If Player B wanted to wait to see what Player A did before acting he needed to either wait with posting or put in conditional clauses in his post like
Player B wrote:
If Player A flees the combat
Bertrand runs after Aloward, deciding that this enemy is too much for them to handle
If Player A casts a spell
Bertrand gawks at Alowards and mumbles "I didn't know you could do that!"
In any other case
Bertrand steps up to the Aspis agent and attacks him with his greatsword[/b]
In other words: in the same initiative bracket your actions get resolved in posting order, not initiative order.