Rogue Eidolon wrote:
That's all good news. I have a few other players pretending to be things they're not/pretending not to be things they are, which I dig in terms of the context of the AP. I think a lot of my big concerns are player-based: Does this person have the rules mastery, organizational skills, and RP chops to play the class effectively and not like, torpedo the party with OMGCRAZYPANTSTIME. Writing in some fey seems like a great idea if I get the impression that my player has a good grasp on his concept, and I love the idea of playing the party off of each other given that they've all got secrets like Laura Palmer up in this biz. The archetype looks delightful, but for whatever reason I keep thinking it's more suited (PC wise) for a campaign like Kingmaker. Ultimately, I hate telling players "No," unless I have really overwhelming reason to do. I will see what my player has to offer in terms of long-term vision and plan for his Reveler and go from there. Any additional weigh-ins are, obviously welcome. But Rogue Eidolon's response helped a great deal. <3
Rogue Eidolon wrote:
The note cards are an excellent suggestion!
I have a player proposing this class for an upcoming Jade Regent campaign I'm GMing. We're in the early planning stages, and I feel very hesitant for both mechanical and RP/Flavor reasons to permit the class in the campaign, despite how delicious it looks (so yummy). I've asked my player to submit a more robust outline of how he sees this PC evolving, and also what his in/out of combat roles would be, for both party balance and "do you actually know what you're getting into?" type of reasons. As a GM, I tend to be cautious about when I allow someone to play "Probable Psychopath" in the context of an AP (as opposed to a homebrew). So far, I'm not seeing too many connections in the Jade Regent AP for fey involvement If anyone has run/played Jade Regent and looked at the Masquerade Reveler in detail, please hit me up with your thoughts?
*Pretty!* Bard/Philosopher
Actions:
The Mistress of the Moon, the Lady of the Seas, the Keeper of the Night retreats to her Moon, and is pleased with her handiwork. They each now think of me as a loving friend, and a bearer of great gifts. Perhaps I will be those things – I’ve not yet decided. But now, I need my own Citadel! A place where my new friends may visit me and give me gifts and names and power. It will be a grand place.
Actions: [5 AP Imagine Plane: Mare Ingenii]
A three layer plane, home to the Lady and her court. The first layer is the Sea of Pearls, a luminous body of water populated entirely by kelp and oysters whose pleasure it is to make pearls to adorn the Mistress of the Moon. Guests to her plane are encouraged to bathe or go diving here. The second layer is the everlasting banquet, where the Lady greets all guests warmly with a generous feast that is renewed every evening as the sun descends and the moon reigns over the evening sky. The final layer of this plane is the Lady’s actual homeland and the location of her [2 AP Weave Sanctum] Sanctum, a pearlescent open air bungalow on the edge of Mare Ingenii. The only inhabitants of this layer of the sanctum are her prolific, numerous [1AP: Create mundane life] pet rabbits, honored guests, and occasional consorts.
*Pretty!* Bard/Philosopher
Actions:
In the blazing Light of the Citadel of the Sun, a golden-haired female figure appears. She wears the moon around her wrist. “Greetings, King of Heaven. I must say, You’ve done well for Yourself. You are a beacon in the void! Oh… this? This was a gift to me from the Lord of the Earth! Isn’t it lovely? He said I could live on the Moon that He made, and now I am Mistress of the Moon. In return, I traded Him great oceans to protect His beloved Earth from scorching under your brilliance, and He named me Lady of the Sea, giving the Moon dominion over the tides. Stole it? I did no such thing, your Grace. It was a gift! … Oh, You say it was Yours as well? How funny, the Lord of Earth didn’t mention that to me. Well. Perhaps I can give You something to offset Your loss. How would that be? Here, take this.” Actions:
The Mistress of the Moon waves her hand, and a great mantle of stars envelope the King of Heaven, and billions of twinkling lights spill across the sky, surrounding his citadel. “As a gesture of my friendship and love, take this mantle of stars. Let us share the skies, my citadel and yours, and allow their light to keep us warm in the cold Darkness over which the Lord of Earth presides. I ask in return that You simply name me Keeper of the Night, since my Citadel will shine at night, when You are away. What do You think? Does my gift satisfy you?”
Actions: She smiles generously and extends her hand, awaiting a response.
[3AP to create the Milky Way Galaxy.]
*Pretty!* Bard/Philosopher
Actions:
In the Darkness of the Citadel of Earth, a black-haired female figure appears. She wears the moon around her neck. “Greetings, Lord of Earth. I must say, You’ve done well for Yourself. You are a beacon in the void! Oh… this? This was a gift to me from the King of Heaven! Isn’t it lovely? He said I could live on the Moon that He made, and now I am the Mistress of the Moon. In return, I traded Him a Mantle of Stars to keep Him warm in the Darkness over which you preside, and He named me Keeper of the Night. Stole it? I did no such thing, my Lord. It was a gift! … Oh, You say it was Yours as well? How funny, The King of Heaven didn’t mention that to me. Well, perhaps I can give You something to offset Your loss. Here, take this.” Actions:
The Mistress of the Moon waves her hand, and the seas rise to meet the land. “As a gesture of my friendship and love, take these oceans. Let the connection between the tides and the Moon You have given me symbolize our connection, and my gratitude for Your gift. The seas will keep Your beloved Earth cool, and shelter her from the hot rays of the sun. I ask in return that You allow me to be Lady of the Sea, since my moon will have dominion over the movement of Your oceans. What do You think? Does my gift satisfy You?” Actions: She smiles generously and extends her hand, awaiting a response.
[3AP to create the oceans of the Earth.]
@Mark: I meant to ask what the age-range of your players was, and totally failed to do so! My initial assumption was that they were in the adult range, but I recognize players can be much younger (and might find different story telling styles more appealing). Also, out of curiosity, as a GM do you speak in the first person? Or are you a disembodied third person narrator? One of the parlor tricks I sometimes use is to speak in the first person, only to have the players find out at the boss battle: I'm that skeleton on the floor over there. "You enter the room where I died. I see you all for the first time, and it is like greeting friends I've never known. The foul monstrosity that flayed me alive and left me to die towers in the corner. I know you will avenge me." I've also GM'd in the voice of the boss monster, which can get downright creepy if creepy's what you go for. Pick a PC to 'possess' as your eyes and ears. It gives you a chance to foreshadow and otherwise play with their perception of their surroundings. It can add an element of fun, it doesn't change the substance of the adventure, but it sure can change the flavor (especially for players who may have run a scenario before).
Nawtyit wrote:
My favorite way to buck that trope is to act like I, as the narrator, am reacting in equal surprise to the presence of said dragon. Example: Players: "we break down the door" Me: the door buckles under your weight and OH MY FREAKING GOLDEN TAP SHOES YOU GUYS THERE IS ABSOLUTELY A DRAGON IN HERE AND SHE LOOKS CHEESED AT YOU. The room is a broad expanse of thick stone and the floor is littered with bones and broken wayfinders. That would likely be startling if it weren't for the sulfur fumes and dripping acidic saliva that is pooling next to your shoe as the HOLY CARP DRAGON RIGHT IN YOUR FACE blinks her eye and prepares to annihilate you so thoroughly that it actually hurts your ancestors retroactively. Roll for initiative. Aim high. This is going to hurt.
The NPC cards make a LOT of sense. I have a ton of trouble keeping NPC's from a Skull & Shackles campaign straight in my head, and have considered drawing them all (I'm a face/feature person followed by a story person) and making writing down conversations my character Cassia has either had or overheard involving them to keep them all sorted. Simple notes don't do much for me, especially since a lot of that particular campaign is spoken-only. Kinesthetic learners (like me) are likely to have the most difficult time, so the cards (or a sketch pad or moleskin) might really work for me as a /player/! Great idea! rabbit
Have you considered supplementing with pictures or really good miniatures? My GM's often simply say, "you see this... <show terrifying picture of a gibbering mouther>. If we have an expert in <knowledge whatever>, more could be learned." The other tactic I sometimes use is I have the narrator (me) tell a personal anecdote (either something that actually happened to a character I play or know with a monster of a similar type, or a made up folk tale) of how creepy, terrifying, or certain-deathy a given monster might be. People process information really differently, and auditory learners are actually much rarer than visual learners. It may be that without visual input, the theater of the mind is simply not connecting for your players. For a serious moment or series of moments in an adventure, I might also do things like light candles or incense, or play music or sound effects I've selected in advance (drippy sounds for a cave, feet on sand and stone for an abandoned ruin, it's easy enough to set up with a smart phone). Small tricks like that contribute to a more robust experience for a player who might process information more emotionally in an olfactory or non-verbal way, too. I'm a very new GM in Pathfinder, but I did a lot in the World of Darkness and Deadlands settings. So the tricks I'm suggesting might not port as well as I'd hope. My favorite GM's in Pathfinder Society are just really excellent at 'doing the voices' and acting out particular NPC's. Goblins are a favorite. The theatrics of GM work are actually what I enjoy most about the enterprise. I'd love to watch this thread more, and see what others suggest! Great question. (:3
Shelyn: Love Me Like A River Does, Melody Gardot
As a self-identified sapiosexual, body-positive, sex-positive, and consent-positive cis-woman reading this thread, I found myself both pleasantly and unpleasantly surprised in turns. I'm going to keep my comments on the positive side because I think that's Important to Try To Do. Things that happened that were Totally Awesome:
I'm new to this community, and don't always know how much is safe for me to say or share as I explore the game and its players. I'm fortunate to have a really amazing group of people I play with in both the Society, and AP's. Some of you out there are doing a great job showing me that the culture I expected is far less vitriolic and hazardous than I imagined. Thank you for helping to create safe and happy and intellectually rigorous space for non-traditional players and the characters they build and love. Rabbit.
If food/game nerds are interested in collaborating to come up with real-life options for in-game food -- Hi, I'm Darling Rabbit. Let's chat. @Matt_T: while ancient mayan/incan cuisine probably doesn't resemble modern (especially modern served-state-side) Mexican, Arcadia would probably be the business end of our Columbian exchange. That means things like maize, potatoes, tomatoes, coffee, etc would be native to the area. I feel like for fun purposes, I'd fudge it and just make lingua all day every day because why not. The interesting part for me is to see what cultures are interacting where (and when) to determine what the cultural fusion might yield. What are subcultures up to? Can I research this. Will there be footnotes. Can there be footnotes. tl;dr I could probably brainstorm this all day instead of working.
I keep hitting "refresh" in the hopes that this thread will blow up, and I can start making Golarion selections for my AP group.
Vudrani and Arcadian seem like the easiest to extrapolate or embellish. Varisian also doesn't seem hard (plus, who doesn't want to make Paprika Hendl? People I don't know, that's who).
I'm working on a Lyra Silvertongue and Mrs. Coulter, both from His Dark Materials.
I also have an Orual from "Till We Have Faces" by C.S. Lewis, but even a biblio-nerd like me wouldn't call that 'pop' culture. Other ideas I have floating around include Mina Harker (archivist), Babydoll from Suckerpunch (Dervish Dancer, or possibly a battle oracle), Queen Boudicca who will likely be a barbarian with a dip in Oracle, Malificent, and there might be a few ladies from greek mythology bumping around in my brain. I'm an RP/story heavy player (and also quite new, so my characters are often interesting but extremely imperfect), so I like the exercise of seeing how close I can get to the spirit of the character from within the confines of the rules and skills available. |