Misunderstood Monk |
OK, so there was a Wall of Fire. There were some baddies on the other side. A PC shoves his weapon through the Wall of Fire to strike at a square that held a baddie in the last round in the hopes he was still in the same square. The PC rolls percentile for his miss chance and hits because the baddie was still there. The PC does enough damage to kill the baddie. The PC goes to attack another baddie within range, using his Cleaving Finish feat. I said no because the Wall of Fire would have prevented the PC from seeing the baddie die and without that knowledge the Cleaving Finish feat is not inspired.
I understand that this is not RAW but our group generally plays RAI which often leads to bending rules on both sides of the screen to better fit the rules into the context and spirit of the game.