Battle Harbinger Cleric of Brigh? Build ideas for Outlaws of Alkenstar


Advice

Silver Crusade

I'm joining an Outlaws of Alkenstar game at level 2, and I'm not sure what to Bri(n)gh to the table.

The party already covers the Player Guide top class spots: Alchemist, Inventor, and TWO Gunslingers (and one Exemplar). The Player Guide also recommends Dwarf, Dwarven language, Brigh Lore and Craft, and given that the party is missing a spellcaster, I thought of Dwarf Cleric of Brigh. Battle Harbinger seems a good option given the martial weapon proficiency, the large party benefiting from Bless, and the fact that I'm not that big on spellcasting anyway outside of support and occasional healing. Something on the lines of:

Ancestry: Dwarf (Talos)
Stats: 3 0 2 2 3 -1
Class Feats: Battle Harbinger Dedication (Toughness), Aura Enhancement (level 4)
General/Skill Feats: Battle Medicine, Assurance (Craft) (free, background), Toughness (free), Armor Proficiency (heavy, level 3)
Ancestry feats: Unburdened Iron, Dongun Education (level 5)

That said, the concept feels quite generic and lacking substance, plus I find Brigh quite underwhelming too - Light Hammer? Really?

Any ideas on how to give this build its own shtick and make it mechanically more unique? Otherwise, any other ideas for different builds that also tie in with the party and AP?

Thanks!

Cognates

I would ask the DM if they can bump you up to a 2-slot caster in line with magus and summoner, especially since you're lacking a dedicated caster (though alchemist does provide caster-esque) utility.

Silver Crusade

1 person marked this as a favorite.
BotBrain wrote:
I would ask the DM if they can bump you up to a 2-slot caster in line with magus and summoner, especially since you're lacking a dedicated caster (though gunslinger does provide caster-esque) utility.

It's an interesting idea but I'd like to stick with the game as is. I'm not married to the Battle Harbinger build, so if it's far from being the best fit, I'd rather change it entirely than house rule around it.


Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Pathfinder Rulebook, Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber

Unfortunately, the battle harbinger cleric isn't that good unless you want to focus on bane or bless (or other battle auras) and mostly using weapons instead of spells. Especially with the reload limitations with firearms in Outlaws of Alkenstar.

You might consider a "plain" warpriest cleric of Brigh instead. You gain proficiency in all martial weapons at 3rd, but start at 1st level with proficiency in light hammer and simple firearms (hand cannon and/or shield pistol, for instance). If you have your heart set on a clan pistol at 1st level, you can always take the Clan Pistol or Dwarven Weapon Familiarity ancestry feat and retrain it after reaching 3rd level.

Alternately, instead of a cleric you might consider an animist. Crafter in the Vault, Steward of Stone and Fire, and/or Witness to Ancient Battles could be appropriate apparitions; possibly Lamentation of Sinister Deals and/or Speaker in Sibilance, depending on the character's background and personality. You should probably take Dwarven Weapon Familiarity as your 1st level ancestry feat in this case (allowing the character to treat a clan pistol and some other martial weapons as simple weapons for proficiency).

As the only dedicated caster, the flexibility of the animist apparitions can probably help a lot.


Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Pathfinder Rulebook, Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber

Side note: I'm a little surprised that there are two gunslingers instead of at least one volatile spark magus.

Silver Crusade

Dragonchess Player wrote:
Unfortunately, the battle harbinger cleric isn't that good unless you want to focus on bane or bless (or other battle auras) and mostly using weapons instead of spells. Especially with the reload limitations with firearms in Outlaws of Alkenstar.

That is indeed the point. As stated in the OP: "I'm not that big on spellcasting anyway outside of support and occasional healing". Which means that whatever build I end up playing, it should have standard martial weapon progression if possible (expert at lvl 5) - Warpriest is cutting it close with its delayed expert proficiency.

Animist goes against all that as it's a full spellcasting class with terrible weapon proficiency (as normal for full casters). I can tolerate Focus spells or spellcasting classes with other non-spellcasting things going on (e.g. Bard), but I'd exclude pretty much anything that heavily relies on options with a daily turnover.

Dragonchess Player wrote:
Side note: I'm a little surprised that there are two gunslingers instead of at least one volatile spark magus.

Can't say, but they are Drifter and Pistolero if that helps.


Gray Warden wrote:


Animist goes against all that as it's a full spellcasting class with terrible weapon proficiency (as normal for full casters). I can tolerate Focus spells or spellcasting classes with other non-spellcasting things going on (e.g. Bard), but I'd exclude pretty much anything that heavily relies on options with a daily turnover

However, Witness to Ancient Battle mitigates that to some degree. You will gain a proficiency to martial weapons if you decide that you are done casting support spells and then just attack and keep attacking each round. Then you can always return to casting if needed. It’s not ideal but can open opportunities that other classes might not offer.

Liberty's Edge

Also I feel the true strength of the Animist is in its focus spells. Which do not have a daily turnover.


Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Pathfinder Rulebook, Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber

If you want more fighting and less spells, the vindicator class archetype for the ranger might be a decent choice over a battle harbinger cleric.

It's not as good in the party support role immediately, and casting anything other than focus spells will have to come later, however. You can take Domain Initiate as a 1st level ranger as an archetype feat to slightly speed up taking the Cleric Dedication (at 6th, after another vindicator archetype feat at 4th), if you want to go that route.

With a vindicator ranger instead of a cleric or animist, it might be a good idea for the alchemist to handle more of the party support role.

Silver Crusade

steelhead wrote:
It’s not ideal but can open opportunities that other classes might not offer.

I don't really want to settle for "not ideal" to be honest. I appreciate the Animist suggestion, and I did go back to give it a proper look, but it's not really speaking to me (hah!).

It is interesting that three people are recommending it though, is it a particularly fitting class for this AP or is it "just" for the flexibility?

Dragonchess Player wrote:
If you want more fighting and less spells, the vindicator class archetype for the ranger might be a decent choice over a battle harbinger cleric.

Is there any particular reason for choosing Vindicator over Battle Herald? I don't see any particular hook for Vindicator that would significantly take it apart from Cleric - outside the fact that they are different classes of course - or am I missing something?

Also, from what I've read there are a lot of Clockworks or Constructs in general in the AP, and Vindicator seems to have some spirit damage going on. Nowhere near game-breaking of course, but given that I'm pretty much still shopping for options, I don't really want to choose a class that's already starting with a feature that I know won't work often.

I think I'm getting quite fond of the Dwarf (Talos) idea, but everything else is still open. If Battle Herald is so bad (for some reason?), how about Metal/Air Kineticist? Or some flavour of Druid perhaps?


Adventure Path Charter Subscriber; Pathfinder Rulebook, Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber
Gray Warden wrote:
Dragonchess Player wrote:
If you want more fighting and less spells, the vindicator class archetype for the ranger might be a decent choice over a battle harbinger cleric.
Is there any particular reason for choosing Vindicator over Battle Herald?

Just as a more combat-focused option with a similar flavor.

You could probably go fighter with the multiclassed cleric dedication, I suppose, if you want more slot spells instead of focus spells.

Gray Warden wrote:
how about Metal/Air Kineticist?

Elemental instinct barbarian with the multiclassed kineticist dedication might work (wielding a gun sword, perhaps). Using the kineticist impulses mainly for support; Wood would likely be better for a support role (Timber Sentinel, especially).


Another option is a Thaumaturge with scroll thaumaturgy.


Warpriest really is your best bet here. Your rank 1 slots are for magic weapon until everyone gets their weapon runes and then you can move into bless afterwards.

Since you don't want to play a control caster, you can start +3/0/+2/0/+2/+2 and go right up champion for the reaction. For your other spells, just pick generic buffs or saveless whatever. You can use gortle's spell guide if you don't know what the good spells are.

Alternatively, since you seem like you only want some casting out of a feeling of obligation in a 0 caster party, skip all that and just play whatever.


Access to electricity damage is by far the most important thing level 1-4 of OoA for, uh, reasons anyone who lives in Alkenstar knows (fire, cold and ghost touch are also good). The Alchemist has that covered (the first book of Alkenstar can genuinely be won by oops all Alchemist because Bottled Lightning is stronger than any purely physical martial build, though oops all primal spellcaater can meme just as well), the Exemplar and Inventor are one feat away from switching their damage type and the gunslinger have Fatal on their side, but Battle Harbingers have no damage (not accuracy) boosters, and you don't have the lightning domain nor Conductive Weapon as a granted spell so you're going to hit for 0 damage waaaay more than you like.

If you still want to Harbinger, I could suggest Cixyron, daemon harbinger of gun trade, who gets flintlock muskets as deity weapon, or Ferrumnestra, elemental evil of metal who uses the pick, both of who fit thematically as an outlaw in Alkenstar. Both get conductive Weapon, which is two combats of gleeful slaughter of metal things (at 2nd level), and Cixyron gets Lightning while Ferrumnestra gets Decay domain which is also handy here. You already have Deadly Simplicity for free, so grab Domain Initiate if you like or Emblazon Armament if you don't care.

As a third option, archetype into Druid of Hedge Mage at 2nd to pick up electric arc. You don't care about increasing the spell DC slower anyway.

Silver Crusade

Ryangwy wrote:
Access to electricity damage is by far the most important thing level 1-4 of OoA ... Battle Harbingers have no damage (not accuracy) boosters, and you don't have the lightning domain nor Conductive Weapon as a granted spell so you're going to hit for 0 damage waaaay more than you like.

Jolt Coil is a 60gp item. Electric Arc + added electricity damage on Strikes for two rounds after casting.

Ryangwy wrote:
If you still want to Harbinger, I could suggest Cixyron, daemon harbinger of gun trade, ...

The whole point of going Cleric is to be a Cleric of Brigh, given the relevance to the AP. I'd rather not pick a divine class at all otherwise, plenty of other options.

Dragonchess Player wrote:

Just as a more combat-focused option with a similar flavor.

You could probably go fighter with the multiclassed cleric dedication, I suppose, if you want more slot spells instead of focus spells.

I still don't understand the issue with Battle Herald to be honest. Please don't misunderstand me, I'm really not insisting on that option, I'm just trying to understand the mechanical reasons behind the skepticism.

My main issue with it is the fact that's it's kind of a monolith with almost no customization potential:

- No 1st level class feat
- 2nd level is forced Dedication
- 3rd level general feat must be Armor Training for Bulwark if we want any Reflex saves at all, which means...
- 1st level Dwarf feat must be Unburdened Iron if I don't want to move 15ft, which gives us the ability to use Tower Shields unimpeded I guess
- 4th level Tandem Onslaught, not because it's a must have, but because it's required by Empowered Onslaught
- And so on.

But none of that is about game mechanics. If I wanted to play exactly that build, it wouldn't have bothered me. So is there something else that makes this class suboptimal in a way that's better supplanted by other classes?

Gesalt wrote:
Warpriest really is your best bet here. Your rank 1 slots are for magic weapon until everyone gets their weapon runes and then you can move into bless afterwards.

Before level 5 there isn't much difference between the two to be fair. Warpriest is slightly ahead though, with 3 spells per rank, vs 2 spells of the Battle Herald, but both can cast Runic Weapon if they need, with Bless stacking accuracy. The main differences start at level 5, with Battle Herald losing the 1st rank spells but getting Expert weapon proficiency. Might consider Warprierst and maybe retrain at 5 if GM allows.

Northern Spotted Owl wrote:
Another option is a Thaumaturge with scroll thaumaturgy.

Interesting, will check it. Shame for the Charisma, I was hoping to dump it.

Dark Archive

I remember a single scene where the clergy was involved, i would not advise to play a cleric of brigh just for story reasons if you do not like what the class has to offer, just ask your GM and develop a background story that involves them and you - the vast majority of followers of brigh (or any other faith) are not clerics, after all.

How about a Maestro/Warrior bard? Your martials will love you for your corageous anthem, and you can use martial weapons yourself.
Do get the Jolt Coil though^^

Silver Crusade

Dr. Frank Funkelstein wrote:

I remember a single scene where the clergy was involved, i would not advise to play a cleric of brigh just for story reasons if you do not like what the class has to offer, just ask your GM and develop a background story that involves them and you - the vast majority of followers of brigh (or any other faith) are not clerics, after all.

How about a Maestro/Warrior bard? Your martials will love you for your corageous anthem, and you can use martial weapons yourself.
Do get the Jolt Coil though^^

I was thinking just that. Scrap the whole thing and go Maestro Bard with Commander Dedication. With at least 3 characters needing reloading (Inventor is Munitions Master), the Reload! tactic alone is a lot of value.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

The thing about Battle Harbinger in OoA is that unless you plan to keep the character and take them into another campaign, its going to end before you get any of the Battle Harbinger's interesting things. You won't get Master in Martial Weapons and you won't get Empowered Onslaught.

Sure you end up being an Expert in weapons for two more levels compared to the Warpriest, but I don't think that's worth losing the Heal Font, which is the BH biggest oof. Losing 4-5 top level heals to get an extra 4-5 1st Rank spells that do not scale at all is a terrible trade.

And without going into too many spoilers, Brigh and her clergy are an afterthought in the AP. Unless your GM is willing to add more for your character to do in that regard, its not a character concept with any more legs than simply being a Brigh worshipper.

Silver Crusade

TheFinish wrote:

The thing about Battle Harbinger in OoA is that unless you plan to keep the character and take them into another campaign, its going to end before you get any of the Battle Harbinger's interesting things. You won't get Master in Martial Weapons and you won't get Empowered Onslaught.

Sure you end up being an Expert in weapons for two more levels compared to the Warpriest, but I don't think that's worth losing the Heal Font, which is the BH biggest oof. Losing 4-5 top level heals to get an extra 4-5 1st Rank spells that do not scale at all is a terrible trade.

And without going into too many spoilers, Brigh and her clergy are an afterthought in the AP. Unless your GM is willing to add more for your character to do in that regard, its not a character concept with any more legs than simply being a Brigh worshipper.

Understood. Thanks!


Gray Warden wrote:


I was thinking just that. Scrap the whole thing and go Maestro Bard with Commander Dedication. With at least 3 characters needing reloading (Inventor is Munitions Master), the Reload! tactic alone is a lot of value.

Seems like you have a good idea (though, with so many Int characters out there, shouldn't one of them get the Commander dedication?) though you're going to need to plan around a looot of mindless construct enemies early on (they call off later). But you probably know that and are getting a jolt coil already.

And yeah the main time being a cleric matters... screws you over, IIRC. Darn anti-clergy undead. At least bards can deal with ghosts and undead easily-ish

Liberty's Edge

Before you get a Jolt Coil, use Cantrip Decks (5-pack) for Electric Arc.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / Advice / Battle Harbinger Cleric of Brigh? Build ideas for Outlaws of Alkenstar All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Advice