|
|
I have been playing Pathfinder Society since 1E’s fourth or fifth season. The one thing I’ve really appreciated about organized play is the flexibility of being able to drop in and out week by week. Although the scenarios are often a bit too easy, it’s fun having a weekly option for gaming. However, recent events have left me much less enthused.
Further back in time, I was hesitantly interested in the shorter one shots of bounties. It did seem to draw in some people to try the game out at our local con. However, I quickly discovered that the short quests and even shorter bounties did not hold my gamer’s narrative attention nor even provide interesting combats. Now all scenarios are effectively quest-length sessions, and honestly, I’m completely uninterested.
I understand why the decision had to be made. The smaller workload for a shrinking company is necessary for Paizo’s survival and I applaud that. That doesn’t change how I feel about the uncomplicated shorter experiences of these scenarios. I’m curious to see if others feel this way, because at this point I’m realizing that I would just rather prioritize home games again, despite the added commitment.
The Raven Black
|
Our forever PFS GM expressed the same feeling in our most recent game, planning to maybe do adventures or APs with some PFS thrown in rather than all-out PFS as we did for years.
For my part, I felt doing bounties/quests that each took almost an entire game session to gain half a scenario's XP felt bad. But now we might even end up doing 2 full scenarios in a single game session. Which feels too fast.
Interestingly, neither issue appeared in our SFS2 games.
|
Yeah, I haven't run PFS scenarios much in the past 3 seasons for the reasons you mentioned. I'm much more interested in running APs and other adventures for PFS credit. Leaning MUCH more into running home games, too.
And this started before layoffs. The quality control on PFS scenarios feels like it hasn't really existed in a while.
|
|
| 4 people marked this as a favorite. |
I've only played a few of the shorter scenarios, but I must say, they really don't scratch that same itch for me. Somehow, that extra fight in the old style just gives a better experience, IMHO. I'm guessing because it allows for an extra story beat that allows the narrative to unfold. Now it's really just setup - complication - conclusion, which is not enough to balance a story around.
I've heard a lot of good things about the shorter scenarios. It makes things easier to plan and slot in, but it just leaves me unfulfilled. Maybe it's just recency bias, but the older scenarios could fill a whole evening. Now it's just a quick game and you're done. It leaves time for other stuff, but I don't really get my gaming fill. Like RPG junk food, rather than a full meal.
|
|
I understand why the decision had to be made. The smaller workload for a shrinking company is necessary for Paizo’s survival and I applaud that. That doesn’t change how I feel about the uncomplicated shorter experiences of these scenarios.
Ugh, that came out wrong. Let me fix it:
I understand why the decision had to be made. Although I don’t like anyone losing their job and despise that one company should have to account for the bad choices of another bankrupted business, the smaller workload for a shrinking company is necessary for Paizo’s survival. I hope they can weather this storm and in the future provide more work for new employees. That doesn’t change…
Down with RPG junk food, up with a solid meal that leaves you satisfied!
|
|
For my part, I felt doing bounties/quests that each took almost an entire game session to gain half a scenario's XP felt bad. But now we might even end up doing 2 full scenarios in a single game session. Which feels too fast.
Interestingly, neither issue appeared in our SFS2 games.
Now that is fascinating! I know that SFS has been doing these shorter scenarios for a while. Why do you think their scenarios are more satisfying?
The Raven Black
|
The metaplot scenarios for SFS season 1 really flow together, so the developing story really shines through. That story consistency on the Starfinder side really goes back to SFS1.
I think this is a big factor for sure.
I guess the authors for SFS have a keener understanding of the appropriate flow for short scenarios too, having more experience writing those.
One key factor too IMO is that the SFS scenarios take full advantage of the setting's variety to ensure scenarios feel different even when they follow basically the same pattern.
Some PFS scenarios are like this too, with writers using the theme to the max (the Tanuki spring to mind).
Finally, whereas some PFS scenarios are burdened with having to fit subsystems, especially the despicable Influence one, I feel SFS scenarios are not similarly cluttered yet.
For example, using the starship rules once in a while is OK. But, if it was becoming a required part of too many SFS scenarios, it would quickly grow stale and boring too.
|
I'm not too happy with the shorter format either, especially it happening mid-edition.
As an organiser, when scheduling, you now have to consider the length of every scenario, and the length varies wildly between 90min and 3 hours, so you can't reliably schedule 2 scenario in the same time slot as an old format scenario. The new ones that do last the 3 hours however are pretty nice, and I don't think the writers are doing a worse job in the new format.
I do however like that by design the new format basically intends for you to go 'all out' every combat. It keeps the pacing higher than it used to, but the combats tend to feel easier because the encounter math does not take into account that you're less concerned about managing your daily resources. It also means that you can do awesome stuff all the time, and particularly in the higher level ranges it thoroughly reduces the choice paralysis.
There may be a cost reduction aspect in Paizo's decision, but I also see and understand the choice to focus more on the 2-3 hour format from a 'life has changed' perspective: Life is busy and way more so than it was 20 years ago. Offering more content that you can easily fit into an evening is welcome for many gamers and shops. WotC seems to have picked up on that years ago with the content they offer for 5E, and that seems to work really well during weekday game nights, whereas for PF2 scenario you had to rush and cut encounters to finish within the opening times of the shops (at least that was my observation here in the Netherlands).
|
|
Good point about mid-edition change. It makes things difficult to explain to newer players who aren't as entrenched as others why some scenarios last longer than others. Hell, it happened mid-season, even (IIRC). A nice season change would also have been good. But changing things up mid-edition just messes with expectations.
Also, I just love the timing of this thread just hours before (or on the same day, at least), as Paizo saying, "we're no longer doing scenarios now." :P
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I suspected some of the issue is that the Starfinder 2e scenarios were all planned from the start to be 2-3 hour affairs while the change to season 7 was a last minute change that forced cuts. That being said, we're still seeing some short PF2e scenarios (For the Love of Vanity is really unfortunate in that regard.
|
|
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Quentin Coldwater wrote:Also, I just love the timing of this thread just hours before (or on the same day, at least), as Paizo saying, "we're no longer doing scenarios now." :PHuh?!? Where was this announced?
The September Update
https://paizo.com/blog/september-2026-organized-play-monthly-update"These are the final Pathfinder Society scenarios currently scheduled to be published by Paizo."
PFS Scenarios are abolished, and we are being directed to the Paizo Printables Adventure line. (which I have many Opinions about)
A blogpost to explain this is due on 21st September.
|
Now I am curious if Pathfinder Infinite scenarios will be based on the same lengths as bounties, quests, and original scenarios. Since fans will be writing these scenarios, I’m also hoping we get some that are linked into arcs of 1-3 sessions.
"Length
Scenarios are designed to be played either within 2–3 hours or within 4–5 hours." [From the 'Infinite page.]
|
|
steelhead wrote:Quentin Coldwater wrote:Also, I just love the timing of this thread just hours before (or on the same day, at least), as Paizo saying, "we're no longer doing scenarios now." :PHuh?!? Where was this announced?The September Update
https://paizo.com/blog/september-2026-organized-play-monthly-update"These are the final Pathfinder Society scenarios currently scheduled to be published by Paizo."
PFS Scenarios are abolished, and we are being directed to the Paizo Printables Adventure line. (which I have many Opinions about)
A blogpost to explain this is due on 21st September.
I'm honestly still not clear on how this is going to work, but it sounds like the Printables stuff will have scenario-length adventurers available that are sanctioned. Plus, Infinite content that was created through the rules to be a society scenario are also an option.
So I guess how much content is available is going to depend in part on how many folks sign up to write Infinite scenarios and how well those sell.
I've only played a few of the shorter scenarios, but I must say, they really don't scratch that same itch for me. Somehow, that extra fight in the old style just gives a better experience, IMHO. I'm guessing because it allows for an extra story beat that allows the narrative to unfold. Now it's really just setup - complication - conclusion, which is not enough to balance a story around.
I've heard a lot of good things about the shorter scenarios. It makes things easier to plan and slot in, but it just leaves me unfulfilled. Maybe it's just recency bias, but the older scenarios could fill a whole evening. Now it's just a quick game and you're done. It leaves time for other stuff, but I don't really get my gaming fill. Like RPG junk food, rather than a full meal.
I just played PFS games at a con last weekend and we were doing older scenarios. We had pretty significant time pressure. We had 6 players, one of which was new and another one of which basically only plays at this one con so was rusty on how things work. So things were not moving super fast.
In that sense at the speed we were going, a 4 hour scenario is hard to actually fit into 4 hours. Some scenarios have a "if you're pressed for time you can skip this encounter" moment, and I see that get used a lot. So a ~3 hour scenario that skips that fight but is otherwise the same fits in our time slot a lot more comfortably because it's got some buffer to account for a slower group.
Now, a faster group might finish that in 2 hours and 30 minutes and that could feel pretty lame. It's hard to get right for everyone. But some of the old scenarios are so long that I don't see how they actually fit into 4 hours even if you're moving at a good clip, let alone if its a slower group with new players.
So one that is a solid 3 hours could work pretty well for us. If it's closer to 2 hours... yeah that's just going to be unsatisfying. The shortest stuff like bounties doesn't tend to draw much interest around here as people like that scenarios have some meat to them.
Driftbourne
|
I've been in games where the GM filled out the chronicles in the parking lot because the store closed.
The first 2 shorts scenarios I GMed ran 1:45, and the other I got to 2:15. After that, I said never running that short again, and started modding scenarios to run longer. I now average 3:30 to 4:40 for most 2 to 3 hour scenario, to fit in a 5-hour time slot.
I find it easier and more fun to run a short scenario longer than to rush a long scenario. Mostly, I just add maps and pawns to social encounters; it helps the players engage in the game and role-play more instead of just asking what skill to roll because they forgot by their turn. There have been a few scenarios where I have added 4 maps. Part of running longer sometimes is just time changing maps, which also gives the player a chance to be social. Something we didn't get to do when running long scenarios.
I had an NPC that was supposed to give the party an item, so I brought a deck of cards and made it look like the PCs had to gamble for it. I still left it up to the skill check to get it. I even gave the winning player a poker chip as a hero point, which really was just for the hour.
If I start running too long, I don't have to skip anything written in the scenario; I can just cut the things I added or planned to stretch out.
With everything being repeatable now, I've run the same scenarios 2 weeks apart and had some of the players in both games. To keep it interesting and keep the repeat players off guard, I just changed up the things I had added to the first game, mostly just by changing maps and pawns. One encounter had 4 of the same creature on a forest map. In the second game, I used a forest stream map. I kept the same stat blocks for the creatures, but used 2 sets of pawns so it looked like 2 forest creatures and 2 creatures from the stream; players had no idea it was the same encounter.
That's much easier to do with short repeatable because there was room to add stuff in the first place that could be easily changed up without having to change the scenario.
Most of this I picked up playing Starfinder since Starfinder has had longer to get used to the short scenarios. Might not be for everyone, but there are ways to make short scenarios work.
| Warmagon |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The shorter format is something our local PFS organizers complained about too, and playing 8-04 and 8-4 it definitely felt like they were rather unsatisfying. The shorter time was also a bit awkward, since some of them were short enough that organizers who had played them felt comfortable scheduling them as "double features" with other short adventures to fill up the 4 hour time slot they reserve. But others were long enough that this wouldn't work. And even as a double feature, it still kind of felt like we got 8 XP for half an adventure...
Someone also just ran 1-12 A Burden of Envy where the PCs are trying to smuggle refugees out of a Runelord's city. And the contrast between that adventure and 8-1 and 8-4 is quite striking. Envy has some set pieces and constraints to be sure, but a lot of it is kind of player problem solving. A lot of the skill things felt like more organic stepping stones for making contact and getting around this oppressive city. It's actually like playing an RPG normally. You could take the adventure, give it up some touch ups, and use it in a home campaign. Now, to be fair, it did seem a bit overstuffed for a 4 hour time slot - we definitely skipped over some stuff. It's a scenario with ambitions, even if it seems to fall a bit short at points.
And that's not something I can say about the season 8 ones I've played. They've seemed rather phoned in even by average PFS standards IMO, and those weren't high. 8-1 is like a bottle episode where you sit in a room and make skill checks at a magic item. Your semi obligatory VP subsystem skill challenge in Riddleport seems even more forced than normal for instance.
I don't know if its a coincidence or not, but a month after a low level season 8 double feature, we now have someone running sanctioned adventures like the old beginner box instead of the PFS specific adventures.
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
The Elsewhere Feast has been a shock to me. After playing it, I've downloaded it just to verify that it was not an issue with the GM.
I remember very specifically the "Diplomacy check to convince an NPC to help", with no information on what help the NPC was supposed to provide and a single line of description of said NPC, focusing on physical features. That's when we moved from a clear description of the environment and player agency at the core of the experience to just pointless dice rolls without really knowing what's happening.
It's the moment I've decided to stop GMing PFS, as it was too far away from what I can GM. I continue to play because I like my gaming group and the game in general. But I'm happy about Pathfinder Infinite becoming a thing as I expect some adventures to be of good quality and to resume my GMing.
I can't speak for others, but from my point of view the new adventures are the worst I've ever seen in PFS by a significant margin. I'm puzzled people are not reacting more negatively towards them but to each their own.
Driftbourne
|
I remember very specifically the "Diplomacy check to convince an NPC to help", with no information on what help the NPC was supposed to provide and a single line of description of said NPC, focusing on physical features.
This is exactly the kind of thing I look for when looking to make a short scenario run longer. If I don't have time to fill in the NPC's details myself, I just use the Deck of Endless NPCs. How the NPC is supposed to help is something I would need more context to figure out, since I haven't read The Elsewhere Feast.
______________________________________________
Some general thoughts to other comments:
Starfinder has had over a year of shorter scenarios. I started looking into word count now that we have the rules for making Infinite scenarios. The typical word count for a 2-3 hour scenario is 4000 to 5000. The shortest SDSF2e scenario I've found so far, and I think it only has one contender I haven't checked yet, is 4702 words. The scenarios that I've been able to run up to 4:30 hours are around 5500 words. PF2e 8-1 Intro Year of Clockwork Mystery is only 4207 words. When I played in 8-01; our session lasted 3:15 to #:30 hours. The GM didn't try to run it longer; it was largely the party that made the game run long.
We had fun with it, but 8-1 did feel a little short; I think its becuse it's only one map, and the point of focus on the map is one object that didn't move, instead of exploring the map and having encounters in different locations.
I wouldn't judge all 2-3 hour scenarios by 8-1, since there are 800 to 1300 words left that could go into a short scenario. I've played in 8-04: A Theft in Riddleport; I don't remember offhand if it felt short or not, but it could be because I'm used to SF2e scenarios.
The first PF2e organized play group I played with; we were always playing as fast as we could to be done before the store closed. Playing like that, PF2e felt like a tactical combat game, where the players never had time to talk OOC. The door opened: get your drink and be ready to play in 5 or 10 minutes. The current group I play with is not rushed; some of us show up an hour early to set up or just hang out and talk. Games typically are not rushed, unless there is a following event. People sometimes hang out after the games. The 2-3 hour scenarios give more
room for role-playing and table talk in and out of character.
I'm wondering if you're in a situation where you're used to running 4-5 hour-long scenarios and have to focus on the game to get done on time without a lot of table talk and role-playing, and run a 2-3 that same way as a 4-5, the 2-3 will run really short. The prep time for the 2-3 hour scenarios is shorter; that saved time is what I use to find ways to make them run longer.
I have nothing against 4-5 hour scenarios if you have time to not rush through them. I do think the shorter scenarios are great for new GMs
|
|
This is exactly the kind of thing I look for when looking to make a short scenario run longer. If I don't have time to fill in the NPC's details myself, I just use the Deck of Endless NPCs. How the NPC is supposed to help is something I would need more context to figure out, since I haven't read The Elsewhere Feast.
That's exactly what I feel I have to do, as I'd be ashamed to run it as written. But that would lead to a few issues:
- The adventure would last easily 4-5 hours, sometimes even more. That's not expected by the players.- The amount of work would be enormous, I don't take an already written adventure to put that much work into it. I can just write my own if I want.
|
|
I can't speak for others, but from my point of view the new adventures are the worst I've ever seen in PFS by a significant margin. I'm puzzled people are not reacting more negatively towards them but to each their own.
It's possible they just haven't had a ton of play yet. The changes were announced a while and people that wanted the more fleshed out scenarios are probably just going to self-filter by avoiding these until they run out of other stuff to play.
That said, a lot of the reviews in the Paizo store for these season 8 ones are complaining about the length, so it seems like that isn't a super popular change.
I know the last one I played was a season 7 one and even that left me at the end feeling like it set up a political problem that we didn't do anything about at all because the scenario ended at that point.
Chopping an hour off that when it already felt incomplete is going to leave some very bare bones adventurers with little room for story telling.
Driftbourne
|
SuperBidi wrote:I can't speak for others, but from my point of view the new adventures are the worst I've ever seen in PFS by a significant margin. I'm puzzled people are not reacting more negatively towards them but to each their own.It's possible they just haven't had a ton of play yet. The changes were announced a while and people that wanted the more fleshed out scenarios are probably just going to self-filter by avoiding these until they run out of other stuff to play.
I'm starting to notice a trend; often the worst reviews are written before or right after the release of a scenario, so I'm guessing it's people who played them early at conventions or within a few days of release. That's a time period when GM's have the least or no advice from other GMs who have already played the scenario. I don't go to conventions, but I'm imagining conventions don't allow playing 2 short scenarios back to back in the same time slot?
One way Starfinder 2e season 1 handled short plots was that most of the non-meta plot scenarios had sequels. I think Starfinder might have an advantage because of how easy it is to get from one star system to another; it's easy to mix unrelated scenarios. Short Starfinder scenarios also tend to have a longer word count than some of the Pathfinder sceason 8 scenarios.
So I think there can be good short scenarios from what I've seen in Starfinder; for stores that close early, they are a necessity, but also, if you've got the time, some people will always prefer longer scenarios, so having both as options is best.
Driftbourne
|
Driftbourne wrote:This is exactly the kind of thing I look for when looking to make a short scenario run longer. If I don't have time to fill in the NPC's details myself, I just use the Deck of Endless NPCs. How the NPC is supposed to help is something I would need more context to figure out, since I haven't read The Elsewhere Feast.That's exactly what I feel I have to do, as I'd be ashamed to run it as written. But that would lead to a few issues:
- The adventure would last easily 4-5 hours, sometimes even more. That's not expected by the players.
- The amount of work would be enormous; I don't take an already written adventure to put that much work into it. I can just write my own if I want.
Making a 2-3 hour scenario last over 5 hours would indeed be a lot of effort; adding an hour or an hour and a half to the average 2-3 hour scenario is not.
Adding to something as short as the Season 8 intro would also be a lot of work. The biggest problem with the Season 8 intro is that it's all in one room, and it's the shortest word count I've found so far. Despite I still had fun playing in it. Even for someone who mods almost every scenario they run, I would put it in the run 2 scenarios back-to-back category, although I have posted my ideas to run it longer in the GM discussion section; it is the first time I've considered writing a completely new encounter to add to a scenario.
Since shorter scenarios take less prep time, the time saved can be used to pick a map, find a pawn, and draw 4 cards from the deck of many NPCs and you're done; sometimes I do that 3 or 4 times. When I don't use the deck of many NPCs, I just use index cards and write a line or 2 about an NPC. I don't consider that an enormous effort; I find it easier than prepping the rest of the scenario. Since it's a creative process, I don't consider it work; I find it fun. For Starfinder, I post my mods so other GMs can copy my work if they don't have time, or can get ideas on how to do their own mods.
Something else I started to think about is: what do you do if you have a TPK in the first combat? Doesn't matter how long the scenario is if everyone dies half an hour into the session. The best suggestion I've found is to give the players pregens to recover the bodies and finish the mission. The point is, however short a scenario runs for whatever reason, be prepared to fill out the session.
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I'm starting to notice a trend; often the worst reviews are written before or right after the release of a scenario, so I'm guessing it's people who played them early at conventions or within a few days of release. That's a time period when GM's have the least or no advice from other GMs who have already played the scenario. I don't go to conventions, but I'm imagining conventions don't allow playing 2 short scenarios back to back in the same time slot?
I assume those who play them right after release are those who play "everything". The others may choose their adventures. If I was not playing everything, I'd definitely spend 10 minutes reading reviews to avoid the bad adventures.
Overall, it's hard to properly assess why there are trends in reviews. There can be so many reasons.
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
l can't speak for others, but from my point lookof view the new adventures are the worst I've ever seen in PFS by a significant margin. I'm puzzled people are not reacting more negatively towards them but to each their own.
It might just be that most chapters aren’t using them. In our local PFS group we play one season behind to allow conventions the opportunity to highlight the newest releases. Additionally, I’ve told my PF captain (?) that I’m completely uninterested in both GMing and playing shorter scenarios. I get the sense that other players have said the same thing.
I just hope that Infinite provides convenient and robust feedback and rating mechanisms (crowd sourced or otherwise). Life’s too short and expensive to spend it wasting time on well-trodden and poorly written RPG stories.
Driftbourne
|
Short doesn't mean poorly written; it just means short.
If you run a short scenario as written, expecting it to run longer without any modifications, that's a choice with predictable results.
I'm running a short 2-3 hour scenario this weekend for the 3rd time; to me, it feels like a familiar friend.
Choices.
Driftbourne
|
I have run about 3 scenarios in succession to justify a game day, but even running and scheduling them online... they are unsatisfying and struggle to justify the effort to set things up.
I hope they move away from just offering the shorter content.
The way I run short scenarios long is easy in an in-person game; I don't use VTTS that might make a huge difference in how hard it is to run long?
|
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Short doesn't mean poorly written; it just means short.
It has an impact on how it is written, by setting time constraints.
I've played living campaigns for long enough to see that the 4-5 hour length is used on all of them. There's a reason to that. If they could make it shorter and keep a similar experience, they'd have done it. But 2-3 hours is just not long enough to tell an interesting story.
Driftbourne
|
My only experience with the scenario length was a Gencon, and I truly hope they can figure this out before next year. Most of my tables finished around the 90 minute mark, which I felt wasn’t the experience I had paid for.
Which scenario?
The only PF2e scenario I own is 8-01 Intro to the Year of Clockwork Mystery. By my word count, it's shorter than all the SF2e 2-3 hour scenarios. I'm courious what the word count is on the other PF2e session 8 scenarios 8-01 is only 4207 words by my count. Some of the SF2e 2-3 hour scenarios are over 5500 words. I'm counting from Adventure Background to end of the end of adventure part of the scenario including stat blocks if at the end , but not handouts. If Include handouts the longest SF2e short scenario I've found so far is 6318 words, that's a huge difference compaitred to 4207 words.I'm wondering if the problem isen't all 2-3 hour scenarios but just the PF2e season 8 scenarios are all on the short side of the 2-3 hours scenarios. Of all the SF2e season 1 theres only 3 that stand out as on the short side of the 2-3
Driftbourne
|
Driftbourne wrote:Short doesn't mean poorly written; it just means short.
It has an impact on how it is written, by setting time constraints.
I've played living campaigns for long enough to see that the 4-5 hour length is used on all of them. There's a reason to that. If they could make it shorter and keep a similar experience, they'd have done it. But 2-3 hours is just not long enough to tell an interesting story.
Starfinder disagrees. Starfinder Society Scenario #1-04: The Great Absalom Relay is the 3rd shortest scenario I've found in SF2e season 1. The shortest reported run time is 1:45. And the longest is 2:25. Out of the 14 reviews, 13 are 5 stars, and there is one 4-star review. You don't get those kinds of reviews for a poorly written scenario.
I do think the short scenarios might be a bad idea for expensive Gen Con tables. And there's nothing wrong with preferring longer scenarios if you have the time slot for them; not everyone does. I do think short scenarios are better when they run on the long side of 2-3 hours.
|
|
The shorter scenarios (for both PFS and SFS) have been a boon for games at our local store, where we can only fit in about 3 hours, maximum, on our scheduled night. The general consensus among our regulars is that, given that limited timeframe, we'd rather play a 2-3 hour adventure, which leaves us a bit of time to have fun roleplaying our characters, than try to speed-run through a 3-4 hour adventure in only 3, or split the latter over two nights.
I haven't been to a GenCon since well before I started playing PFS 1E, but given the current ticket prices, I'm not at all surprised that players there are complaining about the average game being an hour shorter. That con needs longer games to keep players from feeling shortchanged after paying an utterly astronomical price for an event ticket. (I was priced out of ever attending again YEARS ago.)
At the smaller cons that I go to (and even Origins is tiny compared to GenCon) event tickets for Paizo OP are free, and the OP staff are fighting to keep it that way. This past year was awkward to schedule because of SFS being all shorter adventures and PFS changing run length mid-season. Origins's organizers ended up prioritizing the new shorter slot time, with one slot a day (the last evening one, IIRC) being longer to accommodate a few SFS 1E and older PFS 2E scenarios. It did mean that there was a shortage of tables for higher-level fare from the past season or two of PFS, which IME is highly sought-after at cons. Until recently, I was expecting next year to be a bit easier in that respect, with both campaigns in sync time-wise. But the news about shifting OP content to Infinite and Printables has introduced quite a bit of uncertainly back into the equation. I do not envy our con committees wrestling with how those changes will affect the landscape of our hobby.
|
|
Starfinder disagrees. Starfinder Society Scenario #1-04: The Great Absalom Relay is the 3rd shortest scenario I've found in SF2e season 1. The shortest reported run time is 1:45. And the longest is 2:25. Out of the 14 reviews, 13 are 5 stars, and there is one 4-star review. You don't get those kinds of reviews for a poorly written scenario.
It's one of the 2 year 1 adventures I haven't played, so I can't know.
Anyway, the reviews of a single adventure can't really tell us anything about the interest of a 2-3 hour format compared to a 4-5 hour format.
I may have jumped to the conclusion too quickly, but there's certainly a thing around the 4-5 hour format that pushes everyone to adopt this one. I have my own point of view, but that's obviously just an opinion.
Driftbourne
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Driftbourne wrote:Starfinder disagrees. Starfinder Society Scenario #1-04: The Great Absalom Relay is the 3rd shortest scenario I've found in SF2e season 1. The shortest reported run time is 1:45. And the longest is 2:25. Out of the 14 reviews, 13 are 5 stars, and there is one 4-star review. You don't get those kinds of reviews for a poorly written scenario.It's one of the 2 year 1 adventures I haven't played, so I can't know.
Anyway, the reviews of a single adventure can't really tell us anything about the interest of a 2-3 hour format compared to a 4-5 hour format.
I may have jumped to the conclusion too quickly, but there's certainly a thing around the 4-5 hour format that pushes everyone to adopt this one. I have my own point of view, but that's obviously just an opinion.
I think it's great that the Infinite Scenarios can be either 2-3 or 4-5 so people have a choice. I'm in a weird spot trying to write an Infinite Scenario because if I write the way I run a 2-3, it will end up with a 4-5. I like running the 2-3 in a 5-hour slot because, as a newer GM, I have no concept of running to an exact time. That's something I need to learn, along with many other things.
|
|
medtec28 wrote:My only experience with the scenario length was a Gencon, and I truly hope they can figure this out before next year. Most of my tables finished around the 90 minute mark, which I felt wasn’t the experience I had paid for.Which scenario?
The only PF2e scenario I own is 8-01 Intro to the Year of Clockwork Mystery. By my word count, it's shorter than all the SF2e 2-3 hour scenarios. I'm courious what the word count is on the other PF2e session 8 scenarios 8-01 is only 4207 words by my count. Some of the SF2e 2-3 hour scenarios are over 5500 words. I'm counting from Adventure Background to end of the end of adventure part of the scenario including stat blocks if at the end , but not handouts. If Include handouts the longest SF2e short scenario I've found so far is 6318 words, that's a huge difference compaitred to 4207 words.I'm wondering if the problem isen't all 2-3 hour scenarios but just the PF2e season 8 scenarios are all on the short side of the 2-3 hours scenarios. Of all the SF2e season 1 theres only 3 that stand out as on the short side of the 2-3
Multiple Scenarios, I don’t think there was a single scenario that lasted for the full slot. 08-03 was the biggest culprit. I think we finished in less than 90 minutes. And those were $22 a seat tables. And there is no “Just run another scenario” option like everyone seems to say.
Driftbourne
|
Driftbourne wrote:Multiple Scenarios, I don’t think there was a single scenario that lasted for the full slot. 08-03 was the biggest culprit. I think we finished in less than 90 minutes. And those were $22 a seat tables. And there is no “Just run another scenario” option like everyone seems to say.medtec28 wrote:My only experience with the scenario length was a Gencon, and I truly hope they can figure this out before next year. Most of my tables finished around the 90 minute mark, which I felt wasn’t the experience I had paid for.Which scenario?
The only PF2e scenario I own is 8-01 Intro to the Year of Clockwork Mystery. By my word count, it's shorter than all the SF2e 2-3 hour scenarios. I'm courious what the word count is on the other PF2e session 8 scenarios 8-01 is only 4207 words by my count. Some of the SF2e 2-3 hour scenarios are over 5500 words. I'm counting from Adventure Background to end of the end of adventure part of the scenario including stat blocks if at the end , but not handouts. If Include handouts the longest SF2e short scenario I've found so far is 6318 words, that's a huge difference compaitred to 4207 words.I'm wondering if the problem isen't all 2-3 hour scenarios but just the PF2e season 8 scenarios are all on the short side of the 2-3 hours scenarios. Of all the SF2e season 1 theres only 3 that stand out as on the short side of the 2-3
I agree scenarios that short at Gen Con is a bad combination. Cost and expectations are high, and a lot of the options to run longer are not available.
I looked up the timeline of events, and it looks like the Gen Con scenarios would have been in development around the same time as the layoffs happened. Pathfinder organized play was hit harder by that than Starfinder was. That might be why some scenarios feel incomplete. I wonder if that, plus the complaints of scenarios being too short, is also why season 8 was ended early and was replaced with Paizo printables. Perhaps Paizo printables had a different development team that wasn't affected as much by the layoffs? It looks like the newer Paizo printables are supposed to be around 5000 words, which is longer than the really short 2-3 scenarios. I'm hoping that the Paizo printables err on the long side of 5000, and not the short side. Doesn't make this year's Gen Con any better. I'm sure Paizo is aware of the complaints about too-short scenarios, and without dealing wiht layoffs in the middle of production, I'd imagine next year should be better.
Driftbourne
|
I certainly hope so. Not sure they will get a third opportunity to disappoint. But I’m not sure I buy your reasoning. Most of the scenarios are written by freelancers instead of staffers, I think. Honestly, if ever there were a year to skip Paizo’s gencon experience, 2027 is probably the one.
What the writer turns in is not the final version that gets printed; there are multiple categories of things the Paizo developers check and rewrite, like balance, lore continuity, length, style, copyfitting, and for PF2e scenarios those are the people that got laid off.
Since there is a year's worth of scenarios between one year's Gen Con and another, it should be pretty easy to tell if Paizo has made any changes. If Paizo sticks with the changes they are making, there won't ever be PF2e scenarios at Gen Con 2027; it will be Paizo Printable adventures. If Paizo allows Infinite scenarios at Gen Con 2027, there could be 4-5 hour long scenarios again.
Sorry you had a bad time at Gen Con; I got a game to GM in 4 hours.
Driftbourne
|
I bought 8-03 For the Love of Vanity last night; it's a quick read. I checked the word count; it's only 4236 words. Love the idea, but beside short, I think some scenarios have a problem with feeling small. Both 8-01 and 8-03 use a single map. 8-01 is even just in a single room, and the 80+% map for 8-03 is one area. There is no getting-there exploration or info gathering outside of the mission briefing.
Yesterday I ran SF2e 1-02 Mystery of the Frozen Moon for the 3rd time. Yesterday the session lasted almost exactly 3 hours, but half an hour of that was things I added. The word count is 5507 and, as written, would have been short of 3 hours, but it had an NPC interaction in the Drift, some exploration on the planet, 2 encounters on different maps, and some NPC interaction at multiple steps of the scenario before and after encounters. So at least it doesn't feel small.
It's really easy to add to short scenarios; it's really hard or more time-consuming to add to small scenarios.
1-04 The Great Absalom Relay (5337 words) runs really short, 1:45 to 2:30, only has one map, but doesn't feel small; the events move all over Absalon Station. Even for running that short, it still has a higher word count than the PF2e scenarios listed in this comment, and The Great Absalom Relay has nothing but great reviews.
That's my 2 cents, adjusted for inflation and tariffs, is probably worth nothing...
|
|
It's really easy to add to short scenarios; it's really hard or more time-consuming to add to small scenarios.
After drilling into PFS GMs for over a decade that they shouldn't be significantly modifying the scenario, it feels like a pretty dramatic reversal to now want them to add onto the scenario to fill in a reasonable length time slot.
I mean, "this entire scenario is one room and you don't really need to gather any info" sounds more like a quest than a scenario. Those weren't all that popular around here because just don't feel very meaty.
I don't know if Starfinder is just better suited to this or if Pathfinder players have different expectations or what, but "well thats what Starfinder does" doesn't really seem like its translating super well.
Driftbourne
|
Driftbourne wrote:After drilling into PFS GMs for over a decade that they shouldn't be significantly modifying the scenario, it feels like a pretty dramatic reversal to now want them to add onto the scenario to fill in a reasonable length time slot.It's really easy to add to short scenarios; it's really hard or more time-consuming to add to small scenarios.
The real problem is trying to find a length of scenario that fits everyone's needs. Groups running at game stores on weekdays that start at 6 pm and run to 9 pm because the stores are closing need 3-hour scenarios. I think one of the reasons Paizo went with all short scenarios besides cost is that everyone has time for short scenarios, but not everyone has time for a long scenario. I don't play on VTTs, but for the VTTs that automate some of the work, I imagine short scenarios are run even shorter?
The way I see it, either Paizo makes the short scenarios longer, and GMs use the old ways, and time-manage scenarios to prevent them from running over the time slot.
Or GMs get creative and make short scenarios longer to fill in the time slot. But even then, the scenarios should be closer to 3 hours than they are now, there a big difference between making a scenario run longer and having to make up completely new parts for it.
Or Paizo makes both short and long scenarios, which Infinite scenarios might take that role if enough people write scenarios. The problem here is if you make equal numbers of both, you end up selling half as many of each for the same workload.
Or make variable-length scenarios that can fit more than one time slot. This also works great for making repeatable scenarios more repeatable too. Downside: more expensive to make. There are a few ways that are easy to do and don't take up a lot of space. I think variable-length chases are one, and if a party wipes out an encounter on the first round, apply the harder adjustment (when the harder adjustment is add more creatures). If needed, add the harder adjustment more than once.
I mean, "this entire scenario is one room and you don't really need to gather any info" sounds more like a quest than a scenario. Those weren't all that popular around here because just don't feel very meaty.
It does feel like the short PF2e season 8 scenarios feel more like quests instead of 2-3-hour scenarios. And what you describe as not feeling very meaty is what I'm saying in my last comment about feeling small. I think the goal for 2-3 hour scenarios should be 3 +or a little bit. Fitting a scenario to a tight time limit can't be easy.
I don't know if Starfinder is just better suited to this or if Pathfinder players have different expectations or what, but "well thats what Starfinder does" doesn't really seem like it's translating super well.
Most of the Starfinder scenarios seem to be 1000 to 1300 words longer than PF2e Season 8 scenarios. That alone is a big difference. Either that, or the grass is just greener in Starfinder; I'm assuming it's the word count.
|
|
But they didn’t got to all shorter scenarios, they tried it, had less than stellar results and killed the line in favor of the miniatures line. We don’t need to argue whether it worked out or not, Paizo has told us it didn’t.
One thing is for sure to me, if they want to shorten things this much, those Gencon Seat prices need to drop significantly.
|
One thing is for sure to me, if they want to shorten things this much, those Gencon Seat prices need to drop significantly.
Please bear in mind that I have NO INSIDE INFORMATION about this, and this is JUST SPECULATION.
But, I would imagine that the ballroom that Paizo use each year at GenCon is exceptionally expensive to hire for the period, and that the games tickets sold have never covered that cost. Let alone all the others accrued in running such an event for four days.
In "normal" times Paizo would PROBABLY absorb the difference as a marketing(?) cost; but this year was FAR from normal times, and it may well have been price-hike or no ballroom.
|
|
They also sold 30% more tickets with their shorter slots. And I’m sure they don’t like players like me complaining about being screwed by their excessively short and overpriced tables. I also was not the only one complaining.
The standard cost for Gencon seems to be fixed around &5 per seat per hour. at $22 for 90 minutes Paizo is charging me thrice that.
|
|
medtec28 wrote:
One thing is for sure to me, if they want to shorten things this much, those Gencon Seat prices need to drop significantly.Please bear in mind that I have NO INSIDE INFORMATION about this, and this is JUST SPECULATION.
But, I would imagine that the ballroom that Paizo use each year at GenCon is exceptionally expensive to hire for the period, and that the games tickets sold have never covered that cost. Let alone all the others accrued in running such an event for four days.
In "normal" times Paizo would PROBABLY absorb the difference as a marketing(?) cost; but this year was FAR from normal times, and it may well have been price-hike or no ballroom.
I also wonder how much of it goes to GMs for hotel rooms and such.