Grease x2?

[TRPGinger]

Sorry if this has already been discussed somewhere (I haven't found any in what searching I did), but is there a reason why in both the "Arcane" and "Primal" magic traditions, the "Grease" spell appears as both a 1st rank and 3rd rank spell. I know each has a different short description, the 1st rank being a target or area while the 3rd saying a surface or object, but the spell only pops up once in the more detailed alphabetical list of spells, as the rank 1 spell.

I might just be missing something, but it's something I noticed while making my favorite little wizard in the remastered rules. ^^

[moosher12]

Likely a misprint.

[Perses13]

Is this in Player Core 1?

[Aristophanes]

Oh gods no!
Avoid Grease 2! Awful!
The original Grease is a classic! Great score, Olivia Newton John, wonderful!
But Grease 2? I mean, I love Michelle Pfeiffer, but the movie is an abomination!
How can you...Huh? ...What?... Ooooohhhh...Never mind.

[The Ronyon]

Aristophanes wrote:

Oh gods no!

Avoid Grease 2! Awful!
The original Grease is a classic! Great score, Olivia Newton John, wonderful!
But Grease 2? I mean, I love Michelle Pfeiffer, but the movie is an abomination!
How can you...Huh? ...What?... Ooooohhhh...Never mind.

What are you on about?

No one can beat lyric like these!

"[BOYS (& GIRLS)]
Reproduction (reproduction!)

[FRANCINE]
Put your pollen tube to work

[BOYS (& GIRLS)]
Reproduction (reproduction!)

[GIRL #1]
Make my stamen go berserk

[BOYS]
Reproduction

[GIRL #2]
I don't think they even know what a pistil is

[BOY #3]
I got your pistil right here

[MR. STUART]
Where does the pollen go?"

[Easl]

Perses13 wrote:

Is this in Player Core 1?

Yes, the misprint is in PC1.

If you look up the spell on page 331, there is only one entry and it's for a rank 1 spell. So far so good. But if you look on pages 304-305 (arcane list of spells) and 312 (primal list of spells), it does indeed show up twice, once for rank 1 and once for rank 3.

So the error is systematic. No word on if it's hydromatic...

[Farien]

Easl wrote:

No word on if it's hydromatic...

Grease is like oil, right? So maybe it is aromatic.

[Eoran]

Easl wrote:

But if you look on pages 304-305 (arcane list of spells) and 312 (primal list of spells), it does indeed show up twice, once for rank 1 and once for rank 3.

Is it the same spell in both printings? Grease does not appear to have any heightened effect, so I do not see any reason why it would have a different spell Rank for different traditions. Most likely the Rank 3 version is misprinted.

[Bluemagetim]

Farien wrote:

Easl wrote:

No word on if it's hydromatic...

Grease is like oil, right? So maybe it is aromatic.

Lol like mint and eucalyptus? Or lavander?

[Easl]

Eoran wrote:

Easl wrote:

But if you look on pages 304-305 (arcane list of spells) and 312 (primal list of spells), it does indeed show up twice, once for rank 1 and once for rank 3.

Is it the same spell in both printings?

Well it's a spell list, not a spell description, so the only thing you get is the name and about 5 words of description. But the entries are duplicated I.e. on the Arcana list the same wording shows up in both the rank 1 and rank 3 lists, and in Primal it shows up in both the rank 1 and rank 3 lists.

So yes, misprint.