
LordKailas |

Does it have to be an item you create from scratch? Or could you do 240,000gp worth of crafting to an existing item? Could a sentient weapon become a phylactery?
the description says something along the lines of "the typical phylactery is... , but it can be made out of rings, etc."
so, I would assume that yes it could be a sentient weapon. Though it does immediately bring to mind a plot point. What if the lich is just a sentient item since the wizard trying to become a lich screwed up the process and died a long time ago.
Then again, maybe that's what all liches are.

VoodistMonk |

I was thinking that if a Lich chooses to place his soul in a sentient weapon, does the weapon now have a soul? It's not the Lich's personality, the weapon has its own personality and motives, but now it has a soul, it's not just sentient, it's alive now. Or is the soul just sitting in there and not available for use by the sentient weapon?

Kayerloth |
Not that published adventures are "RAW", hardly, but more than a few rather non-standard phylactery's have appeared over the years. Nightmare Keep had one where the adventure itself practically occurred within the phylactery if I recall correctly from reading it many years back.
More specifically its very much in the hands of the GM as it is vaguely written and defined even by Magic Item Creation rule standards.