Being general here for a starting point, but spell casters, neutrals to undermine the paladins, high will saves to undermine the illusions, with high ACs. I'm sure others can come up with more specifics.
You know, now that I think about it, there's nothing wrong with this group that several golems/constructs couldn't fix.
Moar mooks.
Also, when the party is that big, and nearly all of them close-range types, AoE can be fun.
Other than more targets, more health, and stronger (templates can be fun) ...
(1) Environment, specifically environment that gives tactical advantage to the baddies or negates your party's tactical advantage. Battles on cliff faces, within antimagic fields, in dark rooms with a Sphere of Annihilation randomly rolling around (my personal favorite), etc. Let the environmental challenge be something that they couldn't prepare for so they need to adjust.
(2) Heavily increase the damage output of your baddies so they are put on the defense more than I suspect they currently are.
| 2 people marked this as a favorite. |
Put 'em in a maze with a bunch of Blink Dogs and other such critters.
Where is your god now, Paladin?
Just checking that your using the latest errata for the paladins. First printing of the core Rulebook (if anyone has one that hasn't fallen apart) was nerfed very soon after it's initial release.
I have never been the kind of Gm that says we need a balanced party whatever you feel like playing as long as we have the source books to support it is fine. Now that has caused an issue, the latest campagin I began to run I have 7 pcs no biggie adjust encounters with things like max hp for notable npcs and add more mooks and sometimes tougher mooks.
The problem was that after everyone one prepared their characters the shake down ended up as follows.
1 human vanilla paladin twf sword and board
2 human paladin hospitaler
3 monkey person ranger sorry cant recall name of that right now
4 human gunslinger/inquistor
5 human brawler
6 human illuluiosnist
7 teifling gunslingerThe problem is the about of damage they throw down is just crazy.
they quickly wipe crs of them +6-8 with little problem. Any suggestions on how to keep things chalenging for them? I'm not try to utterly destory them as they are level 8 I dont plan to throw a cr20 their way, but In dont want them to be bored with such easy combat.
There are a couple important things at work here. You need to be aware of all of them, and manage it.
First off the basics: The game assumes you will have one primary combatant and maybe one or two secondary combatants. In your party you have 6. They probably put out as much damage as 4 'standard' parties. If they are optimized or have better then a 15 point buy the disparity will be even greater.
Second, you have alot of players. Action economy matters in pathfinder, like alot. You also have a wide variety of damage dealers. Paladins are generally good at taking down a single target, brawlers can lay down hurt against multiple targets, gunslingers are ranged, the ranger might also be ranged (you didnt specify). So any single thing you do wont necessarily make the encounters more challenging.
My advice:
Step 1. No single enemy encounters. Heck no encounters with fewer then 5 enemies. And that doesnt mean throwing in 'mooks'. There should be at least 5 meaningful enemies in every fight. With 2 paladins and 2 gunslingers, you simply dont have the option of a single big bad guy in a fight. There should be 4 of them. Of equal or near equal strength. Have the big bad guy and his 4 powerful leutenants. Mooks are fine, but they wont extend encounters. You need multiple enemies in every fight that are a meaningful threat. That way, one round of full attacks from 2-3 characters cant wipe out the primary objective of an encounter.
This also has the advantage of bringing the action economy back towards your favor. And it is among the better ways to beef up encounters for lots of players. Each bad guy is the same threat to any individual party member, where as buffing one or two bad guys to try to survive against a 7 person damage dealing party is going to lead to disaster. So build your encounters to a CR of around APL+5 or +6, but do it with at least 5 opponents having crs right around APL.
Step 2. Consider your party's standard operating procedure in combat. Every group has one. They are a team after all. Try to come up with situation that disrupts that somehow. Dont outright negate the characters, just require a little bit of extra trouble to get into position, or otherwise bring their badassery to bear. Paladins in armor have trouble with difficult terrain, acrobatics checks, gaps to jump over, etc. Ranged characters might have trouble with concealment in fog that blocks line of sight past a certain distance, things like that. This will not only make encounters more challenging, but they will also allow different characters to shine more at different times.
Other than more targets, more health, and stronger (templates can be fun) ...
(1) Environment, specifically environment that gives tactical advantage to the baddies or negates your party's tactical advantage. Battles on cliff faces, within antimagic fields, in dark rooms with a Sphere of Annihilation randomly rolling around (my personal favorite), etc. Let the environmental challenge be something that they couldn't prepare for so they need to adjust.
(2) Heavily increase the damage output of your baddies so they are put on the defense more than I suspect they currently are.
More health is pretty boring.
It's pretty annoying for the players as well. They've spent time and effort making their ultimate death machines. Going 'oh well, I guess y'all should all have made Sword 'n board fighters instead' can come off as a little... You know how sometimes, you get the feeling that the DM is just arbitrarily raising the bonus on saves, DC, and ac so you need a 12 to hit/save/for the enemy to fail?
Like that. That crap is crap.
A thing to remember, it's unlikely to be important, but still: think about if the players would have more fun if they had more challenge. If adding challenge substracts from fun, don't add challenge. On the other hand, if it does add fun (and it will for most groups, I think), then go right ahead. Or if you're bored, and want fun too, dammit, well, the tarrasque is right here.
Also, I didn't see a rogue in that party, how is their trap spotting/disarming skills?
Make traps that impose negative levels on the whole damn party, then spring the ambush a few minutes later. That party will also need outside help to deal with blindness, curses etc., depending on the paladins' mercies(can't remember what they cure off-hand.)
Their will saves are only so-so. The paladins' touch ac is bad. You know this; it can be abused. They also have little access to dispel magic.
Long-range battles with stuff that is faster than them? Flight works too, I think. Low on dispel and fly, right? Guns only target touch out to first Range increment, 20ft for pistols, I think. Long corridors with a wind-wall in the middle and a wizard with fireball in the end could work. Difficult terrain or long distance ensures he gets away. If in a dungeon, rinse and repeat. + traps.
Best spell for powerful parties: confusion and dominate. Paladins can make that difficult though.
Invisible vampires.
use charm and dominate effects to get them to attack each other, use hold person like spells to reduce the number that can work effectively.
Try splitting the party, either using battlefield tactics like entangle or they have to be in two different places at roughly the same time. If you split the party be well prepared and run the action in parallel.
Make closing to melee difficult or dangerous.
Try a few damage reduction enemies, or enemies that are good at grappling or things that can swallow whole, use flyby/hit and run tactics.
But also play to their strengths, ie neigh endless horde of zombies they have to cut their way through, it might not be threatening at first but eventually resource exhaustion will occur.
Give them goals that can't be solved by killing the mook (either because the mook is much stronger then them or they would get in trouble with the local laws etc).
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I don't know about that. Getting to kill sparkly vampires sound like a fun mini-game, at least.
Also, paladins kind of demolish evil undead.
Golems: the slingers laugh at them as on has scattershot.
I'm not familiar, but just THAT manages to bypass say DR 15/adamantine?
Maybe something "out of the box" that you don't normally find in PF? Some things that come to my mind are:
Basically, try to come up with something that can be overcome with the little grey cells, and not brute force.
so they are level 10? EDIT, saw they are level 8, most of this is still within scope though.
enemy casters should be taking advantage of miss chance, concealment, cover, without line of effect they can't be hit by most things. Walls of stone or ice will be an effective barrier.
Outsiders like demons and devils have an excellent suite of SLA and sometimes caster levels, and greater teleport at will lets them move around the battlefield without much hassle.
At level 10 they certainly have access to fly but that's nothing a dispel magic can't fix, and they likely don't have a redundant source, plummeting 100+ feet hurts.
Use multiple encounters a day, have the first few not be so much challenging but exhausting, hit them with poisons, diseases, curses, negative levels, ability damage, get them to expend their channels and consumables.
Spells like solid fog, acid fog, darkness, make strategy and teamwork difficult.
Introduce weather effects, range becomes either difficult or nearly impossible, if they can only see 60 feet around them in a blizzard they will have trouble locating the casters(who are flying above) especially as mooks come charging at them.
throw more AoO spells at them, little bits of damage will add up and also spread unevenly as some make more saves then others.
Enemies with a high DR that only some of them can overcome will encourage them to split up, use polymorphs or illusions to bait and switch the enemies they are fighting.
Dragons using aerial attacks. They never have to land to fight, just strafe them.