
fictionfan |

I am DMing in the planescape universe. I am having an artifact the can kill gods. It is completely indestructible. Because they could not destroy it the gods did the next best thing and hide it. Where do you hide something you never what to be found?
I have already thought of the plane of negative energy, but there are people of a sort there.

AM BARBARIAN |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

couldn't am barbarian just sunder that plane?
BARBARIAN AM ONLY ABLE TO SUNDER DEMIPLANES CREATED BY SPELLS OR SPELL LIKE ABILITIES. AM BE ABLE TO DO THIS MAYBE, BUT WOULD HAVE TO BE STANDING JUST OUTSIDE OF DEMIPLANE AND HAVE DEMIPLANE IN REACH. NEED TO BE GATE OR SOMETHING. LAST TIME BARBARIAN AM RUNNING INTO THIS PROBLEM, AM NOT GATE THERE, HAVE TO GET CASTY TO USE GATE TO SUNDER.
TURNED INTO BIG THING... AM HAVING TO SUNDER OTHER SIDE OF GATE, NOT GATE. TAKE BARBARIAN MANY TRIES TO GET RIGHT; CASTY RAN OUT OF 9TH LEVEL SPELLS LIKE SIX TIMES. OK, MAYBE AFTER FIRST THREE CASTS BARBARIAN DOING ON PURPOSE JUST TO MAKE CASTY CRY. BARBARIAN ENJOY CASTY TEARS... AM LIKE SWEET SUGAR OR CURE LIGHT WOUNDS POTION TO BARBARIAN.
...BARBARIAN GENERALLY PREFER JUST CHARGE GOD AND MURDER WITH RAGELANCEPOUNCE. AM WORKING FOR BARBARIAN SO FAR.

TarkXT |

fictionfan wrote:couldn't am barbarian just sunder that plane?BARBARIAN AM ONLY ABLE TO SUNDER DEMIPLANES CREATED BY SPELLS OR SPELL LIKE ABILITIES. AM BE ABLE TO DO THIS MAYBE, BUT WOULD HAVE TO BE STANDING JUST OUTSIDE OF DEMIPLANE AND HAVE DEMIPLANE IN REACH. NEED TO BE GATE OR SOMETHING. LAST TIME BARBARIAN AM RUNNING INTO THIS PROBLEM, AM NOT GATE THERE, HAVE TO GET CASTY TO USE GATE TO SUNDER.
TURNED INTO BIG THING... AM HAVING TO SUNDER OTHER SIDE OF GATE, NOT GATE. TAKE BARBARIAN MANY TRIES TO GET RIGHT; CASTY RAN OUT OF 9TH LEVEL SPELLS LIKE SIX TIMES. OK, MAYBE AFTER FIRST THREE CASTS BARBARIAN DOING ON PURPOSE JUST TO MAKE CASTY CRY. BARBARIAN ENJOY CASTY TEARS... AM LIKE SWEET SUGAR OR CURE LIGHT WOUNDS POTION TO BARBARIAN.
...BARBARIAN GENERALLY PREFER JUST CHARGE GOD AND MURDER WITH RAGELANCEPOUNCE. AM WORKING FOR BARBARIAN SO FAR.
Actually hide it in the concept of AM BARBARIAN. Not the person mind you but the concept. In order to get to the artifact you ahve to destroy the concept and erase him and all other AM BARBARIAN'S from existence.
Have fun with that.

TarkXT |

why hide it? you would think the most powerful god would just keep it. That way they have it on hand to keep safe and to add to there own power if someone tries to take it
Politics.
You and you alone have a weapon capable of destroying all others. How long do you think you would last with all the others arrayed against you?
Easier to simply have it in no ones possession.

![]() |

fictionfan wrote:couldn't am barbarian just sunder that plane?BARBARIAN AM ONLY ABLE TO SUNDER DEMIPLANES CREATED BY SPELLS OR SPELL LIKE ABILITIES. AM BE ABLE TO DO THIS MAYBE, BUT WOULD HAVE TO BE STANDING JUST OUTSIDE OF DEMIPLANE AND HAVE DEMIPLANE IN REACH. NEED TO BE GATE OR SOMETHING. LAST TIME BARBARIAN AM RUNNING INTO THIS PROBLEM, AM NOT GATE THERE, HAVE TO GET CASTY TO USE GATE TO SUNDER.
TURNED INTO BIG THING... AM HAVING TO SUNDER OTHER SIDE OF GATE, NOT GATE. TAKE BARBARIAN MANY TRIES TO GET RIGHT; CASTY RAN OUT OF 9TH LEVEL SPELLS LIKE SIX TIMES. OK, MAYBE AFTER FIRST THREE CASTS BARBARIAN DOING ON PURPOSE JUST TO MAKE CASTY CRY. BARBARIAN ENJOY CASTY TEARS... AM LIKE SWEET SUGAR OR CURE LIGHT WOUNDS POTION TO BARBARIAN.
...BARBARIAN GENERALLY PREFER JUST CHARGE GOD AND MURDER WITH RAGELANCEPOUNCE. AM WORKING FOR BARBARIAN SO FAR.
In this case its not from a spell or a spell like abbilty,
Its a small part of essence from each of the Gods.
UltimaGabe |

The reason this is so difficult is because, as a DM, you need to decide whether it is completely lost (which is the easy solution, since you can just handwave it as something that the gods did to hide it for all eternity) or if you want it to be discovered after the end of a long and arduous epic-level quest (which is the hard solution, because you not only need to come up with a really good place to hide it, but also a reason why nobody else has found it yet).

Alakqualyn |

Alakqualyn wrote:portable hole + bag of holding = lost forever. thats how to deal with artifacts"If a portable hole is placed within a bag of holding, it opens a gate to the Astral Plane."
I'm pretty sure "Astral Plane" doesn't equal "Lost forever".
The Demiplane is by far the best idea so far.
i was reading what happened when you put the bag into the hole not the hole into the bag

Anetra |

Cast it into the darkness between the stars, or into one of them, preferably a dark star.
Sounds an awful lot like hiding it in The Far Realm, and I don't know if we necessarily want creatures from The Far destroying Gods. :V Give it to the Doomguard. You can totally trust Pentar with a god-killing artifact.
Seriously though? Hrm. Is this a question of "where is the best place for the PCs to hide it," or "where is the best place some NPCs have hidden it, and subsequently where the PCs will find it?"
I'm thinking the ideal stash spot is going to be the base of the Spire. You'll have to trust someone with it, when it comes right down to it, and I suspect the Rilmani are the safest group of people to risk finding the thing. Second to the base of the Spire is ... the Hinterlands, maybe. If you're only trying to hide it from evil beings, Elysium is a good idea, but since you're not just giving the thing to some high-up good deity, the idea is probably not "here guys, kill all the evil gods. Have at it!"
... Hold up, I've changed my mind. Hide it in Faerun.

Anetra |

Anetra wrote:Hide it in Faerun.I'd put it in a 4e module. No one will find it there.
I was being totes serious, though. Someone will find it on Faerun, sure, but chances are that whoever it is will be so focused on FAERUN IS THE CENTER OF EVERYTHIIIIING that they'll mess up Faerun something mighty fierce with it instead of going off-Prime and, at the end of the day, the issue is contained.

stringburka |

fictionfan wrote:couldn't am barbarian just sunder that plane?BARBARIAN AM ONLY ABLE TO SUNDER DEMIPLANES CREATED BY SPELLS OR SPELL LIKE ABILITIES. AM BE ABLE TO DO THIS MAYBE, BUT WOULD HAVE TO BE STANDING JUST OUTSIDE OF DEMIPLANE AND HAVE DEMIPLANE IN REACH. NEED TO BE GATE OR SOMETHING. LAST TIME BARBARIAN AM RUNNING INTO THIS PROBLEM, AM NOT GATE THERE, HAVE TO GET CASTY TO USE GATE TO SUNDER.
TURNED INTO BIG THING... AM HAVING TO SUNDER OTHER SIDE OF GATE, NOT GATE. TAKE BARBARIAN MANY TRIES TO GET RIGHT; CASTY RAN OUT OF 9TH LEVEL SPELLS LIKE SIX TIMES. OK, MAYBE AFTER FIRST THREE CASTS BARBARIAN DOING ON PURPOSE JUST TO MAKE CASTY CRY. BARBARIAN ENJOY CASTY TEARS... AM LIKE SWEET SUGAR OR CURE LIGHT WOUNDS POTION TO BARBARIAN.
...BARBARIAN GENERALLY PREFER JUST CHARGE GOD AND MURDER WITH RAGELANCEPOUNCE. AM WORKING FOR BARBARIAN SO FAR.
You just got this casty to cry of laughter. For real.

ralantar |

I'm not sure how it's indestructible? But wouldn't the base of the Spire on the outlands work. I seem to recall that being perfectly neutral ground where no magic works. Even the gods are magicless there and use it as a meeting place. Should render the artifact inert as well.
Which is why I don't see it as being indestructible. If it's powers are all repressed you should be able to break it like a normal item.
Maybe that's the key. The gods keep it in a place where it can be destroyed.

James Sutter Contributor |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

The sun.
I used to have a player who, every time there was an artifact or a bad guy or something that needed to be taken care of, would summon a celestial and yell "INTO THE SUN!" and make them teleport the evil whatever straight into the heart of a burning star. (After all, the celestials are selfless, and reform automatically on their home plane....)
While not exactly evil, it made the creatures he summoned a little twitchy.

Tiny Coffee Golem |

Xum wrote:The sun.I used to have a player who, every time there was an artifact or a bad guy or something that needed to be taken care of, would summon a celestial and yell "INTO THE SUN!" and make them teleport the evil whatever straight into the heart of a burning star. (After all, the celestials are selfless, and reform automatically on their home plane....)
While not exactly evil, it made the creatures he summoned a little twitchy.
Finally a use for celestials.

Jaatu Bronzescale |

I am DMing in the planescape universe. I am having an artifact the can kill gods. It is completely indestructible. Because they could not destroy it the gods did the next best thing and hide it. Where do you hide something you never what to be found?
I have already thought of the plane of negative energy, but there are people of a sort there.
In a (chest/room/dungeon/container of indeterminate size) accompanied by a ridiculous number of items of identical appearance.
I do like the 'inside a concept' ideas. Hiding it in Death or Murder would be fitting, if the concept needed destroyed to access the object.
But it seems more likely that you need your group to have a chance of recovering the macguffin, to slay a diety that needs done away with.
So, I'd put it at the end of a process that elevates those who traverse it to dieties themselves. Noob diety holding artifact designed to kill dieties comes into conflict with the artifact, and pwns himself :)

![]() |

I like the in plain sight option as well. Imagine it as a part of the adornment around the Fountain of Life. The fountain itself already emits an immense magical aura, and the artifact just blends right in with the scenery.
Now if you wanted to move it off-plane, I'd suggest Ravenloft over anything else. So you found it, great. Now, how do you get home? (Hint: you don't...)