| Eric Mason 37 |
| 1 person marked this as FAQ candidate. |
"You can increase the reach of your melee attacks by 5 feet"
This wording seems odd.
If it was just "you increase your reach by 5 feet", then it would be clear that your threatening range was increased. However since it is specified to melee attacks, it makes me wonder if the threat range for AoO is unchanged...
Basically that you can stretch out to hit far away, but they can still move freely though those squares when you're not activly swinging.
What I've read so far is people assuming it includes an extension of the threat range, but the "of your melee attacks" bit make me wonder if it only the melee attacks themselves that are extended.
Could you nail this down please Jason?
Nethys
|
"You threaten all squares into which you can make a melee attack, even when it is not your turn."
When you use the Lunge feat, your reach increases by 5 feet until your next turn with a penalty of -2 AC.
As this increases your reach until your next turn, this also increases your threatened range, per the above quote.
Your God of Knowledge,
Nethys
| Tangible Delusions |
"You threaten all squares into which you can make a melee attack, even when it is not your turn."
When you use the Lunge feat, your reach increases by 5 feet until your next turn with a penalty of -2 AC.
As this increases your reach until your next turn, this also increases your threatened range, per the above quote.
Your God of Knowledge,
Nethys
Actually it says:
You can increase the reach of your melee attacks by 5 feet until the end of your turn by taking a –2 penalty to your AC until your next turn.
So you extra 5ft reach ends after your attacks and doesn't have any affect on your Attacks of Opportunity
delabarre
|
You can increase the reach of your melee attacks by 5 feet until the end of your turn by taking a –2 penalty to your AC until your next turn.
So you extra 5ft reach ends after your attacks and doesn't have any affect on your Attacks of Opportunity
And right away, you can see the opening for "Improved Lunge": you don't take the -2 penalty after lunging.
(And in any event, a properly executed lunge doesn't leave you off balance afterwards. But I assume the -2 penalty and the untyped AC penalty condition were added for game balance reasons, not realism reasons.)
Nethys
|
Nethys wrote:"You threaten all squares into which you can make a melee attack, even when it is not your turn."
When you use the Lunge feat, your reach increases by 5 feet until your next turn with a penalty of -2 AC.
As this increases your reach until your next turn, this also increases your threatened range, per the above quote.
Your God of Knowledge,
NethysActually it says:
You can increase the reach of your melee attacks by 5 feet until the end of your turn by taking a –2 penalty to your AC until your next turn.
So you extra 5ft reach ends after your attacks and doesn't have any affect on your Attacks of Opportunity
You are quite correct. I guess gods even have an off day. :)
Your God of Knowledge,
Nethys
| sempai33 |
Tangible Delusions wrote:Nethys wrote:"
When you use the Lunge feat, your reach increases by 5 feet until your next turn with a penalty of -2 AC."So that means that when the PC (with a longsword) says "I use my lunge feat", until your next round, you threaten an area like a troll and can use it to make an attack of opportunity.
I regret the thing that the fighter can't use it during his turn, to make an attack with 10ft reach, because he can't move until arriving in the contact with his foe. In fact, this feat is only usable to make an attack of opportunity, isn't it ?
Nethys
|
Nethys wrote:"
When you use the Lunge feat, your reach increases by 5 feet until your next turn with a penalty of -2 AC."So that means that when the PC (with a longsword) says "I use my lunge feat", until your next round, you threaten an area like a troll and can use it to make an attack of opportunity.
I regret the thing that the fighter can't use it during his turn, to make an attack with 10ft reach, because he can't move until arriving in the contact with his foe. In fact, this feat is only usable to make an attack of opportunity, isn't it ?
I was incorrect in my initial statement. The actual text is "You can increase the reach of your melee attacks by 5 feet until the end of your turn by taking a –2 penalty to your AC until your next turn. You must decide to use this ability before any attacks are made."
While the penalty to your AC lasts until your next turn, the reach only lasts until the end of your current turn. So no, you cannot make 'reach' attacks of opportunity.
This feat is only used to gain reach on your turn in exchange for the -2 penalty until your next turn. This can be useful in a number of situations. Say your enemy is too far away for you to move 30 feet and attack by one square. Lunge would let you 'reach' across to attack him.
Or say your enemy is one square too far for a 5 ft. step to reach. Lunge would allow you to take your 5 ft. step and still get a full attack action in.
All at the cost of the -2 AC penalty, of course.
Your God of Knowledge,
Nethys
| sempai33 |
sempai33 wrote:Nethys wrote:"
When you use the Lunge feat, your reach increases by 5 feet until your next turn with a penalty of -2 AC."So that means that when the PC (with a longsword) says "I use my lunge feat", until your next round, you threaten an area like a troll and can use it to make an attack of opportunity.
I regret the thing that the fighter can't use it during his turn, to make an attack with 10ft reach, because he can't move until arriving in the contact with his foe. In fact, this feat is only usable to make an attack of opportunity, isn't it ?I was incorrect in my initial statement. The actual text is "You can increase the reach of your melee attacks by 5 feet until the end of your turn by taking a –2 penalty to your AC until your next turn. You must decide to use this ability before any attacks are made."
While the penalty to your AC lasts until your next turn, the reach only lasts until the end of your current turn. So no, you cannot make 'reach' attacks of opportunity.
This feat is only used to gain reach on your turn in exchange for the -2 penalty until your next turn. This can be useful in a number of situations. Say your enemy is too far away for you to move 30 feet and attack by one square. Lunge would let you 'reach' across to attack him.
Or say your enemy is one square too far for a 5 ft. step to reach. Lunge would allow you to take your 5 ft. step and still get a full attack action in.
All at the cost of the -2 AC penalty, of course.
Your God of Knowledge,
Nethys
That's exactly the way I was interpreting the feat. Before attacking, you decided to use it, gain 5feet of reach for your attack, but loose 2pts for your AC (like a charge in fact).
That's a good point.| OgeXam RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32 |
You can use the extra reach for AoO during your turn though.
Let's say you are using lunge to attack creature A 10 feet away, creature B had a ready action that if you attack creature A he will run away. You kick in lunge have 10' reach, you attack A. It is still your turn and B runs away which was also 10' away, you would get your AoO since it is still your turn.
You only have the +5' to reach during your turn.
| Father Dale |
You would still be subject to soft cover in such a situation.
I've seen this used with great effect by a fighter with great cleave. He was using a longsword, but when power attacking and great cleaving with lunge there were times he could basically AoE a bunch of enemies. It would take some planning at times because he would have to go in a certain order due to having to attack targets adjacent to the prior target, but when there were a lot of creatures surrounding him he could put out quite a lot of hitpoints worth of damage in a single round.
There were a couple times though in those situations that he'd drop a natural one and that would end the attack cycle.
I'd imagine whirlwind attack would be a little bit better, since you get the attacks even if you miss.
A reach weapon with lunge would also allow for a great many more potential attacks. I'm not certain but I don't think you'd be able to switch weapons for your attacks when using cleave/great cleave, so that with a reach weapon you'd lose the attacks against adjacent targets. (The initial text for cleave says you attack two targets with a single swing.) SO I don't think it would be possible for say a fighter using a reach weapon + lunge + great cleave who also has armor spikes or a bite attack to attack every creature within 15'. I don't think whirlwind attack has this limitation though.
A Polearm Master fighter could pull it off though, switching his polearm to non-reach as an immediate action but taking a -4 to attacks when doing so. Using a dorn-durger you could also do this if you have the right feats for it.
I like the idea of a battle oracle using lunge. At 2nd level the battle oracle gets enlarge person as a bonus spell. Thus he could use a reach weapon and have a massive attack range, bigger even than the diameter of a fireball. Combined with polearm master or a second attack that threatens at close range he could have a rather impressive reach, rivaling that of a colossal creature.