An elemental familiar for my Kineticist


Rules Questions


I'm looking for a way for my Magmakineticist to gain an elemental familiar, but I don't think I could pick one up using the Improved Familiar feat without a very generous interpretation of the rules. Other than multiclassing with a Wizard or other Arcane caster, is there a way for me to do this? I'm talking a full-time familiar, not a Summon Monster equivalent like in Spark of Life.

I have the all of the main line Pathfinder hardcovers, plus Occult Origins, Familiar Folio, and Animal Archives, if that helps.

Could this even possibly fall under the jurisdiction of a Wish?

This is for a home game with a fun and permissive GM, but he has to know how our characters can rules-legal do the things they want to do.


No problem! Small elementals are a fifth level improved familiar.
Iron Will -> Familiar Bond -> Improved Familiar
-or-
Variant Multiclass (Wizard, Witch, or Sorcerer with the Arcane bloodline) -> Improved Familiar

I really like VMC Wizard with Enhancement Transmutation school. Gets you some nice things as you level up, especially at seventh. It's trading out feats, so you keep full Kineticist progression. In both cases, human really helps for the free feat.


A Wysp familiar would be great... provided they provide familiar rules for these...


JiCi wrote:
A Wysp familiar would be great... provided they provide familiar rules for these...

Oh, they did provide rules. 7th level improved familiar. Glad they have that.


QuidEst wrote:
JiCi wrote:
A Wysp familiar would be great... provided they provide familiar rules for these...
Oh, they did provide rules. 7th level improved familiar. Glad they have that.
Bestiary 5 wrote:
Wysps happily offer their services to kind allies, though generally only elementally attuned creatures, kineticists, and spellcasters who summon elementals can make much use of a wysp's assistance. A 7th-level spellcaster who has the Improved Familiar feat can gain a wysp as a familiar.

I stand corrected then :P


Other than those already mentioned i believe Eldritch Heritage can get you a familiar as well.


Whoa. That's pretty cool for a familiar. I hadn't even looked at wysps.


Wow, just realized this opens up an old question of mine:

Can you take Improved Familiar based on HD and the Familiar Bond feat or similiar class feature that only grants effective wizard levels for familiar abilities?

I was going to build an Eldritch Guardian once with Improved Familiar for a Cassissian Angel but there was a lot of debate over whether the class qualifies. Since the Wysps specifically call out Kineticists one would think this is a viable route but i wouldnt be surprised to see it shot down in PFS.


There are many people for and against having non-arcane casters qualify for improved familiars.

I side with the rules don't allow it. You have an effective wizard level for the abilities of your familiar, not for the improved familiar feat. And effective wizard level does not mean arcane spellcaster level.

Especially since the investigator archetype with a familiar explicitly says it counts as a effective arcane spellcaster levels for improved familiar feat. Which it wouldn't need to if effective wizard levels for your familiar was already enough.


Chess Pwn wrote:

There are many people for and against having non-arcane casters qualify for improved familiars.

I side with the rules don't allow it. You have an effective wizard level for the abilities of your familiar, not for the improved familiar feat. And effective wizard level does not mean arcane spellcaster level.

Especially since the investigator archetype with a familiar explicitly says it counts as a effective arcane spellcaster levels for improved familiar feat. Which it wouldn't need to if effective wizard levels for your familiar was already enough.

I understand your point of view... however does that mean that a kineticist, a class called out specifically by the Wysp entry, can only select this familiar if they take a 7 level dip in Wizard or Sorcerer? That seems like some sloppy rule support for a defining bit of flavor for the creature.


it's saying the kineticist can benefit from they wysp's abilities. So if your party's wizard picks up a wysp (because they are going to summons lots of earth elementals) then the wysp's resonate has a bonus for the kineticist too.

It says nothing about a wysp being available for a kineticist as a familiar.


Chess Pwn wrote:

it's saying the kineticist can benefit from they wysp's abilities. So if your party's wizard picks up a wysp (because they are going to summons lots of earth elementals) then the wysp's resonate has a bonus for the kineticist too.

It says nothing about a wysp being available for a kineticist as a familiar.

This is the text i was referring too, "Wysps happily offer their services to kind allies, though generally only elementally attuned creatures, kineticists, and spellcasters who summon elementals can make much use of a wysp's assistance." otherwise stated as, "Wysps happily offer their services to kind kineticists" However the only rules to support a situation such as this are the ones for a familiar, which is spelled out in the following sentence to the above as a 7th level caster with Improved Familiar. I recognize it could be sloppy flavor text just as easily as sloppy rule support but either way it seems to suggest players for WIZ/SOR 7 and KIN X which is... dumb?


There's enough of a split on the boards that you're not going to get far arguing about it. You have to ask your GM. My suggestion should have included the caveat that both methods will require the GM to take the looser interpretation, or else be fine with allowing it anyway.

As far as the rules not supporting other ways of getting wysps, the rules don't prevent befriending or paying one.


You're misreading that sentence.

"Wysps happily offer their services to kind (wizards, fighters, barbs, paladins, elementals, angels, frogs), (but) generally only elementally attuned creatures, kineticists, and spellcasters who summon elementals can make much use of a wysp's assistance.

The wisp is the wizards familiar

Wysp: "Hey fighter you're kind, here's a boost to your fire attacks"
Fighter: "I can't make much use of this assistance"

Wysp: "Hey wizard you're kind, here's a boost to your fire attacks"
Wizard : "Perfect, summon fire elemental to make use of it!"

Wysp: "Hey kineticist you're kind, here's a boost to your fire attacks"
Kineticist: "perfect"

Wysp: "Hey Other kineticists you're mean, I'm not helping you boost your fire attacks"
Other Kineticist: "dang"

So it's not saying that they offer their service to kind kineticists, it's saying that even though it's willing to help people, only a few people can really benefit from that help.


Chess Pwn wrote:

You're misreading that sentence.

"Wysps happily offer their services to kind (wizards, fighters, barbs, paladins, elementals, angels, frogs), (but) generally only elementally attuned creatures, kineticists, and spellcasters who summon elementals can make much use of a wysp's assistance.

The wisp is the wizards familiar

Wysp: "Hey fighter you're kind, here's a boost to your fire attacks"
Fighter: "I can't make much use of this assistance"

Wysp: "Hey wizard you're kind, here's a boost to your fire attacks"
Wizard : "Perfect, summon fire elemental to make use of it!"

Wysp: "Hey kineticist you're kind, here's a boost to your fire attacks"
Kineticist: "perfect"

Wysp: "Hey Other kineticists you're mean, I'm not helping you boost your fire attacks"
Other Kineticist: "dang"

So it's not saying that they offer their service to kind kineticists, it's saying that even though it's willing to help people, only a few people can really benefit from that help.

... that makes the write up very obtuse and Wysps as a whole almost pointleesly niche to ever see play. Its basically right out in PFS and a home game would require a lot of planning ahead of time to get synergy in builds just for a +1 to hit and damage for one chracters. Wysps just became slow, lonely, clap teriitory of needless page space to me :(

So they have a direct and called out benefit to Kineticists that cant take them as familiars and otherwise the ability is only of use for summoners who specialize in elementals as there are not any PC races with an elemental subtype.


It's still useful in home games because many GMs allow general access to Improved Familiar. Just because some people take a particular RAW reading of something doesn't mean it's usually run that way. (I would also be surprised if Kineticists didn't get more direct access to them in the future.)

Designer

2 people marked this as a favorite.
QuidEst wrote:
It's still useful in home games because many GMs allow general access to Improved Familiar. Just because some people take a particular RAW reading of something doesn't mean it's usually run that way. (I would also be surprised if Kineticists didn't get more direct access to them in the future.)

For now, they're on the monstrous leadership chart in Intrigue (so you can have them progress in bard and become conductors; I suggest flame dancer for a fire wysp!), and in home games, the PCs might befriend a wysp non-mechanically as well.

However...I think your parenthetical may be on to something as well. Hmm, can't wait to see what the deal is with that elemental whispers ability mentioned on the blog.


QuidEst wrote:
It's still useful in home games because many GMs allow general access to Improved Familiar. Just because some people take a particular RAW reading of something doesn't mean it's usually run that way. (I would also be surprised if Kineticists didn't get more direct access to them in the future.)

I wouldnt be surprised either, there has been an obvious push to give every class a familiar or companion option... but almost all of those come with the same problem of not being clear on improved familiar options.

I wouldnt characterize it as "some people" though, it seems to be a fairily strong split.


Mark Seifter wrote:
QuidEst wrote:
It's still useful in home games because many GMs allow general access to Improved Familiar. Just because some people take a particular RAW reading of something doesn't mean it's usually run that way. (I would also be surprised if Kineticists didn't get more direct access to them in the future.)

For now, they're on the monstrous leadership chart in Intrigue (so you can have them progress in bard and become conductors; I suggest flame dancer for a fire wysp!), and in home games, the PCs might befriend a wysp non-mechanically as well.

However...I think your parenthetical may be on to something as well. Hmm, can't wait to see what the deal is with that elemental whispers ability mentioned on the blog.

That was indeed what I was parenthetically alluding to! It seemed like a likely fit. (Hoping Void gets some love there, though.)


Okay... This situation has been answered in the FAQ!! And Paizo says that it DOES work. See here.

That actually makes me think about possibly getting a Wysp for some of my kineticist. Happy hunting OP!


JiCi wrote:
A Wysp familiar would be great... provided they provide familiar rules for these...

Reviving an old thread but wanted everyone to know that they gave Kineticists two wild talents to get a familiar/improved familiar.

Improved Familiars can only be small elementals or wysp of your element type


Avanish wrote:
JiCi wrote:
A Wysp familiar would be great... provided they provide familiar rules for these...

Reviving an old thread but wanted everyone to know that they gave Kineticists two wild talents to get a familiar/improved familiar.

Improved Familiars can only be small elementals or wysp of your element type

Yep, the Elemental Whispers wild talents from Ultimate Horror ;)

Shadow Lodge

Mark Seifter wrote:
Hmm, can't wait to see what the deal is with that elemental whispers ability mentioned on the blog.

:)

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / An elemental familiar for my Kineticist All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions