Learning new spells


Rules Discussion


Since it's going to be asked here eventually, I may as well.

Necromancer doesn't have the usual Learn A Spell text that other casters have. Does or does this not preclude it and any future classes from using the Learn A Spell exploration activity anyway since they fulfill the prerequisites.

Similarly archetypes also don't have this text.

My personal stance is that as long as the prerequisites are fulfilled everything's fine, for both Necromancer and every spellcasting archetype. In addition, the necromancer states spells are added to the dirge, so they would follow a repository of spells, like a wizard.

The activity, for easy reference:

Quote:

Learn a Spell

Concentrate Exploration
Source Player Core pg. 230
Requirements You have a spellcasting class feature, and the spell you want to learn is on your magical tradition's spell list
You can gain access to a new spell of your tradition from someone who knows that spell or from magical writing like a spellbook or scroll. If you can cast spells of multiple traditions, you can Learn a Spell of any of those traditions, but you must use the corresponding skill to do so. For example, if you were a cleric with the bard multiclass archetype, you couldn't use Religion to add an occult spell to your bardic spell repertoire.
...
Learned Spells
A spell you learn is added to your repository of spells, such as a spellbook for a wizard, familiar for a witch, or spell list for a cleric or druid. If you have a spell repertoire, such as a bard, it's not automatically added since you can only know a limited number of spells. Instead, you can select it when you add or swap spells.


Yeah, Learn a Spell gives 2 options, for repository of spells or spell repertoire; since Necromancer is clearly not a spell repertoire caster, and are called out as preparing spells, what's left is having a repository of spells. And having a repository of spells means "automatically added" spells when Learning a Spell.

Where things go off the rails, IMO, is the sentence about learning a spell to gain access, which makes it seem like it's talking about the repertoire option of Learn a Spell. It should drop the learn a spell part or spell out the exception if it's some weird level up method that breaks the normal rules.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

> Where things go off the rails, IMO, is the sentence about learning a spell to gain access, which makes it seem like it's talking about the repertoire option of Learn a Spell.

I read that first sentence as spelling out which spells you can use Learn a Spell on. If you don't normally have access, such as if a spell is uncommon, you can Learn it if you find it on a scroll as loot or another spellcaster who knows it shares their knowledge. If it's common, all you need is to buy its scroll to try and Learn it


Baarogue wrote:
I read that first sentence as spelling out which spells you can use Learn a Spell on. If you don't normally have access, such as if a spell is uncommon, you can Learn it if you find it on a scroll as loot or another spellcaster who knows it shares their knowledge. If it's common, all you need is to buy its scroll to try and Learn it

If it's meant to say that, then there's no need to tie it to the sentence in the Necromancer gaining leveling up as it'd be used for gaining any uncommon spell learned and not the ones from level up.

"Each time you gain a level, you add two occult spells to your dirge, of any spell rank for which you have spell slots, chosen from common occult spells or others you gain access to and learn via Learn a Spell."

The above bolded contains text never happens with repository of spells but reiterates the rule for adding spell repertoire when added with the leveling up. Using Learn a Spell grants access AND adds the spell to your repository of spells; this means that if you use Learn a spell at level up to get access, you have already added it before you get the opportunity to use your level additional spells as the same activity that grants access also adds it. This means you'll only ever add a common spell at level up for repository of spells.

Learn a Spell: "You can gain access to a new spell of your tradition from someone who knows that spell or from magical writing like a spellbook or scroll."
...
Learned Spells: "A spell you learn is added to your repository of spells, such as a spellbook for a wizard, familiar for a witch, or spell list for a cleric or druid.

This is why Wizard, for example says "Each time you gain a level, you add two arcane spells to your spellbook, of any spell rank for which you have spell slots, chosen from common spells of your tradition or others you gain access to and the Learn a Spell reference is "You can also add spells to your spellbook with the Learn a Spell activity." Witch and Magus are worded similarly.

In conclusion, it's just plain wrong to reference Learn a spell for level up additional spells for repository of spells but would be expected for spell repertoire.


Sorry, I thought you were talking about the line about gaining access from the Learn a Spell action, "You can gain access to a new spell of your tradition from someone who knows that spell or from magical writing like a spellbook or scroll."

You're right about that line from necromancer seeming out of place


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Baarogue wrote:

Sorry, I thought you were talking about the line about gaining access from the Learn a Spell action, "You can gain access to a new spell of your tradition from someone who knows that spell or from magical writing like a spellbook or scroll."

You're right about that line from necromancer seeming out of place

Ah, I'm sorry too as it seems I wasn't clear enough in my 1st post. ;)


I'm not going to dig into the historical archives of lost pdf versions, but supposedly Wizard had this exact same "problem" until the remaster made it explicit how it added spells to their book without having to reference the skill entry.

I think people let Wizards learn spells to add to their book back then, and they should let Necromancers add to their dirge now.


gesalt wrote:
Necromancer doesn't have the usual Learn A Spell text that other casters have. Does or does this not preclude it and any future classes from using the Learn A Spell exploration activity anyway since they fulfill the prerequisites.

I don't think the lack of reminder text in the class's rules would prevent them from using the standard Learn a Spell activity.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / Rules Discussion / Learning new spells All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.