Cantrips and storing them in libraries


Rules Discussion


So the Wizard starts off with 10 cantrips which is a lot while other traditions have access to fewer.

Traditionally Wizards and Witches can use the Learn a Spell ability associated with their tradition skill to add spells to their list.

Normally they do this by gaining access to scrolls.

However, one cannot create a scroll from a cantrip. Thus, there are no scrolls with cantrips that one can learn from.

So, does this mean you cannot learn cantrips or are there other ways you can learn this ability such as being taught by a wizard that knows it, etc.

or are you set to the number shown in your class abilities for spells?

If you can learn a cantrip what would be the cost of it.

If you found another wizard's spell book for instance and got access to it could you use it to learn cantrips.


3 people marked this as a favorite.

You can get cantrips into your spellbook in the other ways you can learn spells, which is this:

Learn a Spell wrote:
"Spend 1 hour per spell rank, during which you must remain in conversation with a person who knows the spell or have the magical writing in your possession."

There's several ways to do that. Here's some examples:

- Pay someone who knows the spell so they let you copy it (or swap spells).
- Get access to a spell library, which might cost money or might not depending on the library (students of the Maaganbaya don't have to pay the school to get a book from the library).
- Find a scroll/spellbook with it in it as loot.
- Research it.

That is all GM dependent to one degree or another

Scrolls just happen to be a common source because they make convenient loot and a lot more classes can make use of them than a spellbook, as in a lot of parties a spellbook is basically vendor loot. (Had that happen in a game I'm in right now, where we found a super cool, really thematic grimoire... that no one in the party can make any use of. Big letdown because it's such a cool unique item which is something casters tend to get fewer of than martials, but a bunch of caster classes can't make any use of it whatsoever.)

Liberty's Edge

6 people marked this as a favorite.

I would definitely allow a caster to learn from a Cantrip Deck.

Sovereign Court

2 people marked this as a favorite.

Interestingly, if you learn a spell from someone else, they don't have to be the same tradition as you. A wizard could befriend a druid and learn a lot of spells from the druid, who automatically knows the whole primal spell list. The wizard can just ask about all the spells that also happen to be on the arcane list.


Ascalaphus wrote:
A wizard could befriend a druid and learn a lot of spells from the druid, who automatically knows the whole primal spell list. The wizard can just ask about all the spells that also happen to be on the arcane list.

It should be interesting scenes in the world (especially if you've read in Secrets of magic about spellcasting for druids and wizards) :)

Mechanically I think circumstance bonus to difficulty is appropriate. And even +5 is not out of the question. They really look at spellcasting very differently.
Otherwise yes, let them go at it :)

Dark Archive

As a cantrip deck of 5 costs 5g, and one of 20 costs 20g, you could assume that a single one costs 1g, or 1/4 of a 1st level scroll


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Dr. Frank Funkelstein wrote:
As a cantrip deck of 5 costs 5g, and one of 20 costs 20g, you could assume that a single one costs 1g, or 1/4 of a 1st level scroll

Thats pretty much what it is yes.

The 20 pack(Full pack) is all 20 cantrips from the CRB
the 5 pack is 5 of the same.

I wouldnt say no to someone who wanted to order a full pack with different cantrips that they wanted to learn over time. But otherwise it should be reasonably easy to learn common cantrips just by having access to a few hours of downtime in a location where you can find such.

And since OPs question about price has been unanswered, I will just mention that the Learn a Spell activity does list all prices outside of getting a scroll or tutoring fees.


Ascalaphus wrote:
Interestingly, if you learn a spell from someone else, they don't have to be the same tradition as you. A wizard could befriend a druid and learn a lot of spells from the druid, who automatically knows the whole primal spell list. The wizard can just ask about all the spells that also happen to be on the arcane list.

In this case would the wizard have to get access to primal spells somehow to learn them.

Perhaps anything on them arcane list and primal list can be considered both.

I guess to be sneaky the wizard could buy the druid archetype and thus be able to learn primal cantrips as well.

Not sure how the rules work on that.


Indi523 wrote:
Ascalaphus wrote:
Interestingly, if you learn a spell from someone else, they don't have to be the same tradition as you. A wizard could befriend a druid and learn a lot of spells from the druid, who automatically knows the whole primal spell list. The wizard can just ask about all the spells that also happen to be on the arcane list.

In this case would the wizard have to get access to primal spells somehow to learn them.

Perhaps anything on them arcane list and primal list can be considered both.

The requirements for the learner of the spell:

Learn a Spell wrote:
You can gain access to a new spell of your tradition from someone who knows that spell or from magical writing like a spellbook or scroll. If you can cast spells of multiple traditions, you can Learn a Spell of any of those traditions, but you must use the corresponding skill to do so.

is that the spell is on the tradition list that you are learning the spell for and that you use the matching skill for that tradition.

The requirements for the teacher of the spell is simply that they know the spell. No mention of spell tradition is made.

Learn a Spell wrote:
Spend 1 hour per spell rank, during which you must remain in conversation with a person who knows the spell or have the magical writing in your possession.

So a Wizard can learn an Arcane spell from a Druid just fine, as long as the spell is known by the Druid and is on the Arcane spell list (which usually means that the spell is on both the Arcane and Primal lists).

Indi523 wrote:

I guess to be sneaky the wizard could buy the druid archetype and thus be able to learn primal cantrips as well.

Not sure how the rules work on that.

A Wizard with multiclass Druid could learn Arcane spells from a Druid using their Arcana skill. They could learn Primal spells from the Druid (needed for Uncommon spells) using their Nature skill.


I do not think the wizard could archetype into druid and "tutor" themselves into translating primal cantrips into arcane cantrips. but yes. a spell that is both on the primal and arcane list doesn't have a restriction in needing to learn it from a primal or arcane caster specifically.

same with scrolls, They don't have a tradition per say as a wizard can craft scrolls for druids and bards alike. The only thing that matters is that said spell appears on the casters spell-list or that the caster somehow has access to it (like that of a clerics granted spells)


1 person marked this as a favorite.
NorrKnekton wrote:
I do not think the wizard could archetype into druid and "tutor" themselves into translating primal cantrips into arcane cantrips.

If you're talking about cantrips on both the Arcane and Primal lists being selected by a multiclass druid, then scribed into their wizard-class spellbook, I'm not actually sure what prevents it. The closest I can think of is the bit about "remaining in conversation" with your prospective tutor, that sounds hard to do when it's just you, but I could see talking to yourself flying in some circumstances.

It'd be a slow process, but I think you could potentially do it?


Tridus wrote:

You can get cantrips into your spellbook in the other ways you can learn spells, which is this:

Learn a Spell wrote:
"Spend 1 hour per spell rank, during which you must remain in conversation with a person who knows the spell or have the magical writing in your possession."

However cantrips don't have a spell rank so technically you can't meet that requirement. :)


2 people marked this as a favorite.
Gisher wrote:
However cantrips don't have a spell rank so technically you can't meet that requirement. :)

No they absolutely do if you read the "reading spells" section. Everyspell has a nameline or header, The spell's name line also lists the type of spell if it's a cantrip or focus spell, as well as the level.

Most cantrips one can normally learn are level 1 and gains additional benefits per heightened level. But there are still cantrips of higher ranks gained from class features. Shattered Mind for example is third rank because thats whats written in its header.


Perpdepog wrote:
NorrKnekton wrote:
I do not think the wizard could archetype into druid and "tutor" themselves into translating primal cantrips into arcane cantrips.

If you're talking about cantrips on both the Arcane and Primal lists being selected by a multiclass druid, then scribed into their wizard-class spellbook, I'm not actually sure what prevents it. The closest I can think of is the bit about "remaining in conversation" with your prospective tutor, that sounds hard to do when it's just you, but I could see talking to yourself flying in some circumstances.

It'd be a slow process, but I think you could potentially do it?

It's only from a rules perspective that it is wonky, it makes absolute sense from a world perspective. Even if a GM forbids selftutoring it doesn't stop the absolutely rules legal method of crafting the scroll or cantrip deck and then learning it as a wizard spell from that.


NorrKnekten wrote:
Perpdepog wrote:
NorrKnekton wrote:
I do not think the wizard could archetype into druid and "tutor" themselves into translating primal cantrips into arcane cantrips.

If you're talking about cantrips on both the Arcane and Primal lists being selected by a multiclass druid, then scribed into their wizard-class spellbook, I'm not actually sure what prevents it. The closest I can think of is the bit about "remaining in conversation" with your prospective tutor, that sounds hard to do when it's just you, but I could see talking to yourself flying in some circumstances.

It'd be a slow process, but I think you could potentially do it?

It's only from a rules perspective that it is wonky, it makes absolute sense from a world perspective. Even if a GM forbids selftutoring it doesn't stop the absolutely rules legal method of crafting the scroll or cantrip deck and then learning it as a wizard spell from that.

I may need to do some of this in a game I'm in. I have a wizard character who would definitely spend months or potentially years learning the ways of druids or clerics or whatever just so he could pilfer any overlapping spells. They just love knowing spells that much.


NorrKnekten wrote:
Gisher wrote:
However cantrips don't have a spell rank so technically you can't meet that requirement. :)

No they absolutely do if you read the "reading spells" section. Everyspell has a nameline or header, The spell's name line also lists the type of spell if it's a cantrip or focus spell, as well as the level.

Most cantrips one can normally learn are level 1 and gains additional benefits per heightened level. But there are still cantrips of higher ranks gained from class features. Shattered Mind for example is third rank because thats whats written in its header.

Thank you!

I hadn't noticed that with the remaster the word "level" had been changed to "rank" in the Reading Spells section.

Sovereign Court

Gisher wrote:
NorrKnekten wrote:
Gisher wrote:
However cantrips don't have a spell rank so technically you can't meet that requirement. :)

No they absolutely do if you read the "reading spells" section. Everyspell has a nameline or header, The spell's name line also lists the type of spell if it's a cantrip or focus spell, as well as the level.

Most cantrips one can normally learn are level 1 and gains additional benefits per heightened level. But there are still cantrips of higher ranks gained from class features. Shattered Mind for example is third rank because thats whats written in its header.

Thank you!

I hadn't noticed that with the remaster the word "level" had been changed to "rank" in the Reading Spells section.

It's one of the nicer improvements. Instead of spells and counteract "levels" being something different than character/monster/item/feat levels but still being called level, now all those 1-10 scale things are "ranks". Saves confusion.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / Rules Discussion / Cantrips and storing them in libraries All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.