Craft magic item and paragon surge


Rules Questions


Can paragon surge, which lasts 1 min/level, be used to obtain a spell or feat to fulfill a prerequisite for crafting a magic item, particularly if crafting the magic item takes longer than the duration of paragon surge?


For spells, (arguably) yes - if you are a spontaneous caster (via Expanded Arcana.) You cast the paragon surge before you cast the required spell.

For most feats, it should be similar, but it's more questionable in that case.

For the item creation feats themselves, certainly not!

---

Check with your GM for whether Paragon Surge is even allowed. It's rather powerful, and your GM might ban it.


I don't think there's an official rule, but I wouldn't allow it.


1. Buy a Ring of Continuation.

2. Cast Paragon Surge.

3. Profit.


Thank you for the response. The specific case I have in mind is a 9th level half-elf sorcerer who has the craft rod feat and wants to use the paragon surge spell to obtain the maximize spell metamagic feat to qualify for that prerequisite to craft a metamagic maximize rod.

The character has the craft rod feat as a normally selected feat, but does not want to have to take every metamagic feat to qualify for prerequisites. I realize that the character does not actually need to have the metamagic feat prerequisite, but the character does not want the DC of the spellcraft check to include the +5 for not having the prerequisite.

Grand Lodge

Deadbeat Doom wrote:

1. Buy a Ring of Continuation.

2. Cast Paragon Surge.

3. Profit.

Doesn't work.


Deadbeat Doom: The character can buy a lot of rods for the cost of that ring.


Jeff Merola wrote:
Deadbeat Doom wrote:

1. Buy a Ring of Continuation.

2. Cast Paragon Surge.

3. Profit.

Doesn't work.

Wow; they nerfed the holy hell out of that item. Why in the world would anyone be willing to burn 56,000 GP on an item that only works on spells that will most likely outlast your work day?


Pink Dragon wrote:
Deadbeat Doom: The character can buy a lot of rods for the cost of that ring.

Yeah, and if it still worked the way it does out of book, that ring plus Paragon Surge grants access to ALL Item Creation Feats. You'd make your money back in no time.


No. I don't think there's an official rule on it, but the commentary from Paizo on the boards has been that if you can't reliably (meaning have it available basically 24/7) do something then you don't qualify for using it as a prerequisite. So, since you have to use a spell to gain access to it and don't have it naturally to your character through a feat, class ability, racial, and so on, you can't then use it to do things which require it as a prerequisite.


Here's the thing.
Sor 9: +12 Spellcraft
Skill Focus Spellcraft: +3
Magical Aptitude: +2 (and +2 to UMD)
=+17, assuming you don't have an Intelligence malus.

Since item creation is 5+CL(+5 per missing prereq,) and all meta rods are CL 17, making a meta rod without the meta feat is DC 27.

You can take that penalty, and still take 10. No need for Paragon Surge here! :)

----

Edit for quick correction: forgot about the CL requisite, so it'd be DC 32, not 27. You'll need to find +5 from somewhere else, or wait until level 10 (where you'll get +5 from the skill feats augmenting themselves.)


Jeff Merola wrote:
Deadbeat Doom wrote:

1. Buy a Ring of Continuation.

2. Cast Paragon Surge.

3. Profit.

Doesn't work.

That FAQ was completely unnecessary. It already included language that limited its effect when the spell in question had limited permutations. Its original version in no way allowed for a 24 hour (constant) time stop. If it technically had, that that language could have been made more clear. They didn't have to change the spells to which it could apply so as to basically make it worthless as Deadbeat Doom illustrated.


Sandslice wrote:

Here's the thing.

Sor 9: +12 Spellcraft
Skill Focus Spellcraft: +3
Magical Aptitude: +2 (and +2 to UMD)
=+17, assuming you don't have an Intelligence malus.

Since item creation is 5+CL(+5 per missing prereq,) and all meta rods are CL 17, making a meta rod without the meta feat is DC 27.

You can take that penalty, and still take 10. No need for Paragon Surge here! :)

Magic Item Creation wrote:
Note that all items have prerequisites in their descriptions. These prerequisites must be met for the item to be created. Most of the time, they take the form of spells that must be known by the item's creator (although access through another magic item or spellcaster is allowed). The DC to create a magic item increases by +5 for each prerequisite the caster does not meet. The only exception to this is the requisite item creation feat, which is mandatory. In addition, you cannot create potions, spell-trigger, or spell-completion magic items without meeting their spell prerequisites.

Grand Lodge

Pink Dragon wrote:
Can paragon surge, which lasts 1 min/level, be used to obtain a spell or feat to fulfill a prerequisite for crafting a magic item, particularly if crafting the magic item takes longer than the duration of paragon surge?

No because you'd have to have that access for the full day's period of work.

RPG Superstar 2012 Top 16

LazarX wrote:
Pink Dragon wrote:
Can paragon surge, which lasts 1 min/level, be used to obtain a spell or feat to fulfill a prerequisite for crafting a magic item, particularly if crafting the magic item takes longer than the duration of paragon surge?
No because you'd have to have that access for the full day's period of work.

seconded.

Just like you don't gain a bonus to a skill check if you've only got it for a few minutes (such as Inspire Competency used on a craft check over 8 hours, doesn't last that long), if you don't have the spell for the full period you're working on the item, it doesn't apply.

Note that you cast the spell over the course of the eight hours you are working on it, not all at once. Even applies to scrolls and charged items...you're slowing drawing off the energy as you craft the item. That's basically what 'accessible during the whole time period' means.

==Aelryinth


Deadbeat Doom wrote:
Sandslice wrote:

Here's the thing.

Sor 9: +12 Spellcraft
Skill Focus Spellcraft: +3
Magical Aptitude: +2 (and +2 to UMD)
=+17, assuming you don't have an Intelligence malus.

Since item creation is 5+CL(+5 per missing prereq,) and all meta rods are CL 17, making a meta rod without the meta feat is DC 27.

You can take that penalty, and still take 10. No need for Paragon Surge here! :)

Magic Item Creation wrote:
Note that all items have prerequisites in their descriptions. These prerequisites must be met for the item to be created. Most of the time, they take the form of spells that must be known by the item's creator (although access through another magic item or spellcaster is allowed). The DC to create a magic item increases by +5 for each prerequisite the caster does not meet. The only exception to this is the requisite item creation feat, which is mandatory. In addition, you cannot create potions, spell-trigger, or spell-completion magic items without meeting their spell prerequisites.

I'm aware of that; OP specified that he picked up Craft Rod at L9. What he wanted to do was use Paragon Surge to emulate the metamagic feat and avoid the +5 for not having it, because he specifically wants to avoid that +5. :)

What I missed (before edit) was the +5 for being under caster level.

So, again. He's got Craft Rod normally = can start.
5 = base.
+17 = CL
+5 = the sorcerer is lower level
+5 = not having the metamagic feat

=DC 32.

What he can have, minimally:

12 = base for L9 sorcerer.
+3 = Skill Focus
+2 = Magical Aptitude
+n = other sources (eg, Int.)

=+17+n. If n >= 5, he can take 10 and make metamagic rods without having the metamagic feats, without needing the question of Paragon Surge. Otherwise, he can easily do it at L10 when he suddenly goes to +23+n due to the skill feats improving.


Sandslice wrote:
Deadbeat Doom wrote:
Sandslice wrote:

Here's the thing.

Sor 9: +12 Spellcraft
Skill Focus Spellcraft: +3
Magical Aptitude: +2 (and +2 to UMD)
=+17, assuming you don't have an Intelligence malus.

Since item creation is 5+CL(+5 per missing prereq,) and all meta rods are CL 17, making a meta rod without the meta feat is DC 27.

You can take that penalty, and still take 10. No need for Paragon Surge here! :)

Magic Item Creation wrote:
Note that all items have prerequisites in their descriptions. These prerequisites must be met for the item to be created. Most of the time, they take the form of spells that must be known by the item's creator (although access through another magic item or spellcaster is allowed). The DC to create a magic item increases by +5 for each prerequisite the caster does not meet. The only exception to this is the requisite item creation feat, which is mandatory. In addition, you cannot create potions, spell-trigger, or spell-completion magic items without meeting their spell prerequisites.

I'm aware of that; OP specified that he picked up Craft Rod at L9. What he wanted to do was use Paragon Surge to emulate the metamagic feat and avoid the +5 for not having it, because he specifically wants to avoid that +5. :)

What I missed (before edit) was the +5 for being under caster level.

So, again. He's got Craft Rod normally = can start.
5 = base.
+17 = CL
+5 = the sorcerer is lower level
+5 = not having the metamagic feat

=DC 32.

What he can have, minimally:

12 = base for L9 sorcerer.
+3 = Skill Focus
+2 = Magical Aptitude
+n = other sources (eg, Int.)

=+17+n. If n >= 5, he can take 10 and make metamagic rods without having the metamagic feats, without needing the question of Paragon Surge. Otherwise, he can easily do it at L10 when he suddenly goes to +23+n due to the skill feats improving.

My bad; I got your post mixed up in my head with the side discussion about Paragon Surge.


There is the option of buying or crafting a Headband of Int boosting, to wear when crafting. It's only really of use during downtime, not if he's crafting whilst adventuring, but it could also have a craft skill linked to it. And craft skills (unlike Spellcraft) are much easier to enhance.

Crafter’s Fortune or masterwork tools or items of competence boosting.

The Exchange Owner - D20 Hobbies

Pink Dragon wrote:
paragon surge spell to obtain the maximize spell metamagic feat to qualify for that prerequisite to craft a metamagic maximize rod.

No, as you would lose the pre-req before completing the day's work.

Sovereign Court RPG Superstar 2011 Top 32

Sandslice, there is no caster level requirement for metamagic rods. Unless it's listed under Prereqs it's not a requirement, so the DC without the metamagic feat is indeed 27. Few items actually require their caster level.

It's more likely that he doesn't have Skill Focus and Magical Aptitude, which still leaves him at a +12 or so looking for a 27 - thus the desire to try and get the prereq.


ryric wrote:

Sandslice, there is no caster level requirement for metamagic rods. Unless it's listed under Prereqs it's not a requirement, so the DC without the metamagic feat is indeed 27. Few items actually require their caster level.

It's more likely that he doesn't have Skill Focus and Magical Aptitude, which still leaves him at a +12 or so looking for a 27 - thus the desire to try and get the prereq.

I blame the little devil on my left shoulder who informs me that the item CL *should be* a prereq. It's a bit strange that it's not. So re-scrubbing that, +12+int against 27. +5 shouldn't be hard to make up.

---

@OP: If your sorcerer is doing this just to get the meta rods, craft (weapons) might be an easier path. This isn't optimised, but takes no feats other than craft rod:
Artisan (trait): +2
Mwk tools (circ): +2
12 Int: +1
Class skill bonus: +3
Ranks: +9

=+17. This is 27 on take 10, which is enough.


The character will have a spellcraft roll of +20 at 9th level:
+9 ranks
+3 class skill
+2 magical aptitude
+3 skill focus
+1 classically schooled trait
+2 for 14 INT

The GM has ruled that caster level of the rod counts as a prerequisite, so the DC will be 32. He has also ruled that taking 10 is not permitted. Hence, I was looking for ways to boost the chances of successful crafting.

I have asked the GM to rule on Paragon Surge to get the metamagic maximize spell feat as a prerequisite, but I agree with most of the posters that the work-around shouldn't be permitted.

I have also asked the GM for a ruling on the masterwork tool.

At 10th level, the character will get the extra +2 for magical aptitude and the extra +3 for skill focus, which will help, but I would like to start crafting rods at 9th level with a good chance of success.

All the advice here has been good. Thank you.

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Craft magic item and paragon surge All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.