
DM Wellard |

So the House of Mouse is to remake one of the three movies that should never be remade..(the other two are Casablanca and Gone with the Wind)
I'll withold judgement until I know more..but having said that I really enjoyed "Oz the Great and Powerful" and if Sam Raimi stays on board it could be something very special.

daemonprince |

So the House of Mouse is to remake one of the three movies that should never be remade..(the other two are Casablanca and Gone with the Wind)
I'll withold judgement until I know more..but having said that I really enjoyed "Oz the Great and Powerful" and if Sam Raimi stays on board it could be something very special.
There is nothing in the article about remaking Wizard of Oz at all. All it says is the newest Oz movie may get a sequel, just like pretty much every other movie that makes any money lately.

![]() |

Just watched the Oz prequel right now... anyone else noticed the exceptional number of Star Wars references?
1) When all the winged apes fall asleep in the flower field, on of the wicked sister shouts, "It's a trick", much in the same tone as "It's a trap!"
2) The non-green wicked sister shots lightning at the good fearie in EXACTLY the same way as the emperor attacks Luke with force lightning
3) When appearing in cloud form, Oz claims that now that his physical body is dead, he became more powerful than anyone could imagine. Anyone remember Obi-One's words to Darth Vader? "Strike me down and I'll become more powerful than you could ever imagine"... and when he died he was stripped of his physical form...
There are some more stuff that I can't seem to remember now.
Hopefully the next movie won't have any gungans in it :P

Kalshane |
Just watched the Oz prequel right now... anyone else noticed the exceptional number of Star Wars references?
1) When all the winged apes fall asleep in the flower field, on of the wicked sister shouts, "It's a trick", much in the same tone as "It's a trap!"
This more likely a reference to Raimi's Evil Dead movies.

Davia D |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |
So the House of Mouse is to remake one of the three movies that should never be remade..(the other two are Casablanca and Gone with the Wind)
The version of Wizard of Oz you are picturing in your memory with Judy Garland is a remake. Indeed, it is not even the first remake of Wizard of Oz :)

Eric Hinkle |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

Oz..is a far darker place than people think, there are some distinctly nasty things that happen in the books.
part of me hopes that a new Oz movie would be done in the same spirit as Return to Oz. That film was creepy and awesome. Especially the Nome King.
"You had her, and you let her escape... YOU HAD HER AND! YOU! LET! HER! ESCAPE!"

Aaron Bitman |
2 people marked this as a favorite. |

DM Wellard wrote:and Gone with the Wind)I assume this is because it's not a very good movie?
Yeah, I said it. Put up your dukes and fight me!
Somehow, at the moment, I don't feel afraid of getting into a flame war. (I'll probably regret this by the end of the day.)
I hated the movie Gone With the Wind. Scarlett was an unlikable brat, and none of the characters were interesting.
Many years after seeing the movie, I read the novel.
Twice.
And loved it.
But I still wouldn't think it's a good idea to remake the movie, because I feel that no movie could possibly do the novel justice. A movie couldn't get inside the characters' heads, nor delve into their past history. (I'm thinking of Scarlett's parents in particular.)
I've described my reasons for liking the book here, by the way.
And as long as I'm making these controversial statements, I might as well get on topic. Much as I loved the 1939 Wizard of Oz movie as a child, I have - as a big fan of L Frank Baum's Oz books - a serious issue with the movie. Actually, I have several issues, but the main one is the movie's repeated emphasis that the whole Oz adventure was a dream. What made the novel series so appealing to me as a child was that Oz was a living, breathing place, full of characters who had their own lives.
So making a new Wizard of Oz movie could be a good idea, if it's done right.

Thomas Seitz |

Aaron,
Firstly, I never was that much into Southern movies. So you not liking it is fine.
Never read the book because I never had any interest.
Frankly there have been SO many adaptations, (TV, movie, TV movie) that I just don't think there will ever be a 'quote' satisfactorily take 'end quote' version EVER. So yeah you might not like the original, but it's not like they haven't TRIED since 1939...

Kirth Gersen |

They shouldn't remake the musical though. They should make a new movie based on the books.
As Eric Hinkle mentioned above, Disney tried that in 1985. I thought it was great, but unfortunately it tanked.