Enlarge person on things that are already large or bigger


Rules Questions


So I'm looking at the Summoner, and I have a question about enlarge person. If my Eidolon is already Huge from the evolution, and I use spell share to cast Enlarge Person on it (the ability allows me to use it even though the target is an outsider), the spell says it "changes the creature’s size category to the next larger one."

Then it goes on to say what the stat changes are...

But they are horrible compared to the real stat changes from huge to Gargantuan. Do I use the +2 Str... (from the spell) or the size changes from table 2-2 in the bestiary (p.296) the changes from the Evolution: Large/Huge follow the chart, I am hoping the spell follows the same internally consistent pattern.


You use the stat changes granted by the spell.


Wow, now that I look at it, Enlarge person is a ripoff, you get all the downsides of increased size, but virtually none of the benefits.


You get the increase to reach and increased weapon damage dice. In all, the reach is the biggest benefit.


you also lose out on 6 points of STR, 4 points of CON, (from huge to garg. you also SHOULDN'T lose DEX) and a 3 points of natural armor of armor, that's a lot of benefit to lose out on.


It's a 1st level spell and amazing for melee fighters. It's not going to make your high level eidolon much more amazing than it already is.

Liberty's Edge

Umbral Reaver wrote:
You get the increase to reach and increased weapon damage dice. In all, the reach is the biggest benefit.

Anyone who thinks Enlarge is a rip-off has never seen a polearm fighter with Combat Reflexes or Quick Reflexes in action. Enlarge is arguably the most powerful 1st-level spell in the game in terms of how much extra damage and defensive utility it can grant a concept-built character exploiting reach and AoOs.


Mike Schneider wrote:
Umbral Reaver wrote:
You get the increase to reach and increased weapon damage dice. In all, the reach is the biggest benefit.
Anyone who thinks Enlarge is a rip-off has never seen a polearm fighter with Combat Reflexes or Quick Reflexes in action. Enlarge is arguably the most powerful 1st-level spell in the game in terms of how much extra damage and defensive utility it can grant a concept-built character exploiting reach and AoOs.

Very true. And it's also one of a handful of first level spells that are still worth an action (occasionally) in combat at higher levels, in support of that build. Also, makes an awesome wand, 1 minute duration is plenty for one fight.

Scarab Sages

This.

You don't "lose out" on anything, since you're using enlarge to go beyond your normal size limitation. Or, in other words, without the spell you wouldn't even be getting the reach and str bonus.

Still, reduce might be more beneficial for that creature. AC bonuses and the ability to fight in places other than featureless plains :p


*laughs*

And I thought I was the only une using the Reduce spell (on party members) as a means of combat.

Ray-blasting mage gets an effective +2AC, plus an effective +2 to hit with his rays when reduced...

Liberty's Edge

Reduce the spellcasters. Enlarge anyone with Power Attack and a two-hander.


Righteous Might, a higher level cleric (or oracle) only spell, gives better benefits along with the size increase.

Think of the size increase and stats boost as a function of "how much power the spell will give". Should a 1st level spell be giving +8 or +16 strength bonus? Not really.. that's a little excessive for the cost involved.

Similar to how the polymorph spells were changed in pathfinder. Spell power now dictates how much benefit you get.

RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32

Fenrisnorth wrote:
Wow, now that I look at it, Enlarge person is a ripoff, you get all the downsides of increased size, but virtually none of the benefits.

Anybody got a violin?

A small one will work.


No need to be a jerk about it Oge, I was just stating my opinion based on the rules in the bestiary. We obviously disagree, yet you have chosen to be nasty about it instead of saying it straight out.

The Exchange

I think you really do need to look at balance when it comes to spell buffs in this case. The bonuses you're wanting out of the spell belong in the 4th to 6th level range of spells.

Honestly from experience enlarge person is seriously BA as a melee buff. You just have to weigh ALL of the benefits with ALL of the disadvantages.

Case in point: You can't charge a foe that's been enlarged from medium to large without provoking an attack.


Well, no. The case in point is going from huge to gargantuan. The person charging already provokes 2 AoO. The question wasn't why doesn't enlarge do "x" it was what happens if you do "y" which the spell does not specify.

The Exchange

Side rules note here: They'd provoke only one attack of opportunity.

I'm pretty sure the "y" is fairly specific. You just wish it was more powerful.

It's understandable wanting more bang for less buck, but there's a reason they built the spell the way they did.


Summoner is the new druid.


meatrace wrote:


Very true. And it's also one of a handful of first level spells that are still worth an action (occasionally) in combat at higher levels, in support of that build. Also, makes an awesome wand, 1 minute duration is plenty for one fight.

A 1 round casting time in combat is the big price of it. Meanwhile a real spell lasting level minutes could be cast out of combat as opposed to the wand.

-James


Well, after careful consideration, I have determined that what I actually should do is morph it to Large, then Reduce Person it to Medium. It can fit in dungeons, is still 6 Str ahead of the game, is 2 AC up, and only loses a step of damage, the spell only says it reduces your reach if you go from Small to Tiny.

Thank you for helping me beat the system.


Fenrisnorth wrote:

Well, after careful consideration, I have determined that what I actually should do is morph it to Large, then Reduce Person it to Medium. It can fit in dungeons, is still 6 Str ahead of the game, is 2 AC up, and only loses a step of damage, the spell only says it reduces your reach if you go from Small to Tiny.

Thank you for helping me beat the system.

/slowclap

Well played, well played!


Yeah, now I feel dirty, I need to go take a shower.


Fenrisnorth wrote:
Yeah, now I feel dirty, I need to go take a shower.

many men sitting in front of a computer for prolonged periods of time could use a shower.


thepuregamer wrote:
Fenrisnorth wrote:
Yeah, now I feel dirty, I need to go take a shower.
many men sitting in front of a computer for prolonged periods of time could use a shower.

Now, now, I refrained from that cheap shot for a reason. ;p

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Enlarge person on things that are already large or bigger All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions