
Loztastic |
Female Genital Mutilation is something i discussed in my thesis (what a charming document it was!)
one of the major problems is that it is so hard to get witnesses to come forwards - and in many cases, the victims refuse to testify themselves (and, being children at the time, it is very hard to know it has happened, untill many years later)
it is a similar problem to forced marrage or other similar problems with a strong cultural basis - it is very hard to get victims come forwards when there is both a strong cultural bias, and testifying against your own parents
what is needed is education - of course, this would be done through PSE in schools (for children). of course, parents are allowed to withdraw children from any education on reproductive health, sexual education or similar subjects, which of course they will do in this situation. there is also a tendancy for women in the communities where this happens to be isolated from outside influences, through both deliberate and incidental reasons.
its one of the many things in the world today that makes me very angry

![]() |

Not particularly religious, but sometimes the primal nature in me wants to claw its way to the surface and exact a little bit of the ole testament reciprocity upon the inflictor(s).
The problem is that in most cases the inflictor(s) HAVE had this done to them in the past.
Mothers and Grandmothers in those communities have most likely had it done and are often equally vehement in the belief that it is a necessity.
Read the book Infidel by Ayan Hirsi Ali (I believe that's the title and author, it's been a few years) if you want a really terrifying glimpse at the mindset of the perpetrators of these types of crimes (the grandmother in this instance)

Patrick Curtin |

Urizen wrote:Not particularly religious, but sometimes the primal nature in me wants to claw its way to the surface and exact a little bit of the ole testament reciprocity upon the inflictor(s).The problem is that in most cases the inflictor(s) HAVE had this done to them in the past.
Mothers and Grandmothers in those communities have most likely had it done and are often equally vehement in the belief that it is a necessity.
Read the book Infidel by Ayan Hirsi Ali (I believe that's the title and author, it's been a few years) if you want a really terrifying glimpse at the mindset of the perpetrators of these types of crimes (the grandmother in this instance)
+1 on Infidel. Also the book gives a glimpse into cultural mindset that equates a female with an intact clitoris as virtually a hermaphrodite. Ms. Hirsi Ali suffers a lot of taunting before her grandmother takes her for the proceedure.

Loztastic |
The sad thing Steven is that most parents who allow this to be done to their daughters truely believe that they are doing what is best for her. The believe that only by doing this will she remain "pure" and worthy of a good husband.
there is also a belief that it is needed for "hygene" reasonsm for "purity" reasons, and for all sorts of other reasons - and, given the isolation of women in those communities, it can be very difficult to provide education
its similar, but in a more hidden way, to the issue of "forced marrage" - which, thankfully, is now starting to be treated more seriously, and lead to prosecutions.
Over the years, i have seen young people - both male and female, from various ethnic communities (generally south east asain) in forced marrages. There was also a case that hit the news here in the UK, where 3 women escaped from a forced marrage, where they were basically used as slaves for an extended family
The matriarch of the family ended up getting a 7 year prison sentence BBC report
this has helped other young women, and a few men, come forward, as they know the police will take them seriously. I wonder if a similar prosecution for FGM will help women come forward for that

The Jade |

If you leave a woman anatomically incapable of fully enjoying sex, then she can't really tell a dud from a stud, thus she has little reason to dream of other men.
Now, to bring it home, force her to walk around in a Hefty cinch-sak with an eye slit, then condone gender specific stoning to death for infidelity, then do whatever you can to keep her from a proper education and you've finally done it... you've created a woman with such fear, lack of allure, and narrow perspective that she will likely never cheat. Wrapped in a burka, the perfect gift for the utterly insecure fella.
I'm not into cultural bondage myself. I like free range b@#$%es. <-- (Please forgive the "for comic effect only" crudeness.)

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

What ever happened to the good old days of treating these issues like the Brits are attributed when it came to Sati?
"You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours."

![]() |

I think it might be fairer to ask what is wrong with the communities where this is practiced. Parts of East Africa used to be part of the Empire so we have some immigrants (and refugees) who seem to think this is a good idea (and it is tied up - falsely - with Islam, so many of the practicers think it is in the Koran or something) and, as pointed out above, it is very difficult to get much intelligence on this from the individuals and communities. It is also probably happening in the US too, since you have immigrant from practically everywhere, and probably there aren't too many convictions on your side either. I don't want to sound too indignant that this is being painted as a British phenomenon , especially since it is a horrible practice which should be stamped out wherever it happens, but it might be better to ask "What's wrong in Somalia (or other parts of the Horn of Africa)?" (Answer - lot's of things.)

The Jade |

The Jade wrote:I'm not into cultural bondage myself. I like free range b@#$%es. <-- (Please forgive the "for comic effect only" crudeness.)I'm so offended.
OK, I'm over it.
lol... well it was exactly your delicate sensibilities around which I walked on eggshells, and let me warn you, a heap of white shrapnel sunk pretty deep into my foot meat and I'll be suing you for new therapeutic goth frankenbootery. ;) I have one pair of boots that push me up over 6'6". I'm fairly disgusting at that height. But I seem to be losing sight the topic at hand. Ah yes... genital butchery.

The Jade |

Does anyone else remember when this used to be called "female circumcision?" Yeah, right.
Maybe it's the cultural brainwashing in me, but I like it better when my partner can enjoy the fooling around stuff with me.
If gender roles were reversed I don't think men could easily imagine having their tingle helmet cauterized with a hot iron in the name of purification. Then again... diff'rent strokes. Some people get off on stranger stuff than that.

Urizen |

Read the book Infidel by Ayan Hirsi Ali (I believe that's the title and author, it's been a few years) if you want a really terrifying glimpse at the mindset of the perpetrators of these types of crimes (the grandmother in this instance)
I remember just seeing it on the shelves at Half Price Books earlier today on my way home. A good read, you say?

Kruelaid |

... I don't want to sound too indignant that this is being painted as a British phenomenon , especially since it is a horrible practice which should be stamped out wherever it happens, but it might be better to ask "What's wrong in Somalia (or other parts of the Horn of Africa)?" (Answer - lot's of things.)
I reckon it happens in Canada, too. But genital mutilation parties? That is so f#+~ed. Am I repeating myself?

![]() |

Readerbreeder wrote:If gender roles were reversed I don't think men could easily imagine having their tingle helmet cauterized with a hot iron in the name of purification. Then again... diff'rent strokes. Some people get off on stranger stuff than that.Does anyone else remember when this used to be called "female circumcision?" Yeah, right.
Maybe it's the cultural brainwashing in me, but I like it better when my partner can enjoy the fooling around stuff with me.
What can I say? I was young and feeling invincible.

The Jade |

The Jade wrote:What can I say? I was young and feeling invincible.Readerbreeder wrote:If gender roles were reversed I don't think men could easily imagine having their tingle helmet cauterized with a hot iron in the name of purification. Then again... diff'rent strokes. Some people get off on stranger stuff than that.Does anyone else remember when this used to be called "female circumcision?" Yeah, right.
Maybe it's the cultural brainwashing in me, but I like it better when my partner can enjoy the fooling around stuff with me.
Yeah but CH? Nobody pulled off scar tip like you that year. You set the standard, man.

Patrick Curtin |

lastknightleft wrote:Read the book Infidel by Ayan Hirsi Ali (I believe that's the title and author, it's been a few years) if you want a really terrifying glimpse at the mindset of the perpetrators of these types of crimes (the grandmother in this instance)I remember just seeing it on the shelves at Half Price Books earlier today on my way home. A good read, you say?
An excellent read. I did the audio book that Ms. Hirsi Ali narrated herself (she has a lovely speaking voice). She really informs you of her journey in life, and the journey of her homeland as well. It really gives a lot of explanations as to WHY Somalia has the troubles it does today (failed Soviet client state, traditional rival clan structure, staging ground for fundamentalist Muslims looking to expand their presence in Africa, etc.)

Urizen |

An excellent read. I did the audio book that Ms. Hirsi Ali narrated herself (she has a lovely speaking voice). She really informs you of her journey in life, and the journey of her homeland as well. It really gives a lot of explanations as to WHY Somalia has the troubles it does today (failed Soviet client state, traditional rival clan structure, staging ground for fundamentalist Muslims looking to expand their presence in Africa, etc.)
HPB has their 20% sale going on through EOD Wednesday, so when I take the missus to the doctor for post-op follow up, maybe I can persuade her for me to step in for a minute to get this. Not that she doesn't think I spend enough time there. Ha!

![]() |

Patrick Curtin wrote:An excellent read. I did the audio book that Ms. Hirsi Ali narrated herself (she has a lovely speaking voice). She really informs you of her journey in life, and the journey of her homeland as well. It really gives a lot of explanations as to WHY Somalia has the troubles it does today (failed Soviet client state, traditional rival clan structure, staging ground for fundamentalist Muslims looking to expand their presence in Africa, etc.)HPB has their 20% sale going on through EOD Wednesday, so when I take the missus to the doctor for post-op follow up, maybe I can persuade her for me to step in for a minute to get this. Not that she doesn't think I spend enough time there. Ha!
Which one do you normally go to? I hit the one in Westerville a lot, and the one on Bethel almost as often. Don't get to Lane Ave nearly as much as I should.

![]() |
1 person marked this as a favorite. |

What ever happened to the good old days of treating these issues like the Brits are attributed when it came to Sati?
"You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours."
Matthew,
We did. That's why it's illegal. The problem is getting prosecutions. The girls generally don't want to give evidence as it will mean their parents going to jail, especially if they believe this is a valid cultural practice because they haven't seen any different. Believe it or not, women comparing genitals doesn't happen all that often outside of porn films. [j/k] After all, it happened to their mothers, grand-mothers, sisters, etc, so how can they say it's wrong?
Urizen |

Urizen wrote:HPB has their 20% sale going on through EOD Wednesday, so when I take the missus to the doctor for post-op follow up, maybe I can persuade her for me to step in for a minute to get this. Not that she doesn't think I spend enough time there. Ha!Which one do you normally go to? I hit the one in Westerville a lot, and the one on Bethel almost as often. Don't get to Lane Ave nearly as much as I should.
I guess it all depends on where I'm working or what path I'm driving on a particular day and if I have at least a half hour I can spare and just state I was stuck in traffic. :P
Since I've been working out of the Sawmill Rd area the past several weeks, I've been frequenting the Bethel Rd store as of late (stopped by yesterday). Since I live on the far east side, I also stopped by the Brice-Tussing store too (which is actually underrated). I'll probably swing by the Westerville store next week. The Graceland store, I go to the least.
But Lane avenue is still the king. It's those bookstores near campuses that always have the treasures you stumble upon.

Loztastic |
10year maximum sentence in law for any of the offences linked to FGM
however, it's a "specified" offence, and so if "public protection" provisions (basically, if the Court feels there is a "significant" risk of any future offence you commit leading to serious harm, rather than a determinate sentence, you get life)

![]() |

lastknightleft wrote:Read the book Infidel by Ayan Hirsi Ali (I believe that's the title and author, it's been a few years) if you want a really terrifying glimpse at the mindset of the perpetrators of these types of crimes (the grandmother in this instance)I remember just seeing it on the shelves at Half Price Books earlier today on my way home. A good read, you say?
Honestly one of the best books I've read and one that really sheds like on the extreme fundamentalism in the muslim world without being one-sided in anti-muslim hysteria. The book both made me sad and disgusted at times, but I felt like I actually had a strong intellectual grasp of the issues at hand afterwards as opposed to most people who seem to just repeat whatever they hear from talking heads.

![]() |

Urizen wrote:Honestly one of the best books I've read and one that really sheds like on the extreme fundamentalism in the muslim world without being one-sided in anti-muslim hysteria. The book both made me sad and disgusted at times, but I felt like I actually had a strong intellectual grasp of the issues at hand afterwards as opposed to most people who seem to just repeat whatever they hear from talking heads.lastknightleft wrote:Read the book Infidel by Ayan Hirsi Ali (I believe that's the title and author, it's been a few years) if you want a really terrifying glimpse at the mindset of the perpetrators of these types of crimes (the grandmother in this instance)I remember just seeing it on the shelves at Half Price Books earlier today on my way home. A good read, you say?
She is an incredible woman.