Fighting NPCs with Darkness and Deeper Darkness


Pathfinder Society

Grand Lodge

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories, Starfinder Society Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

I often hear on these boards that "you should be prepared to fight NPCs with Darkness and Deeper Darkness".

The thing is... I don't know how.

I mean, I guess you could cast Daylight, but if the NPCs just cast Deeper Darkness again, doesn't that counter Daylight?

Also, you can't rely on a scroll of Daylight for obvious reasons.

So how exactly does one fight the darkness?

1/5

Potion of darkvision?

Grand Lodge 1/5

Recommended - I've been in a party that was nearly shut down because of darkness.

5/5 *

currently, one of the best/easiest ways is to get a 4th level heightened continual light spell cast on something you own. Maybe a dull gray ioun stone? That way you have something permanent. I have also used dispel magic to moderate success, depends on if deeper darkness is being cast by enemies with it as an SLA (as in they can just recast it) or prepared.

4/5 ****

Darkvision doesn't help with deeper darkness.

Fly into the nebula: Obscuring Mist/Smoke Stick
Sun Cleric 8
Blind Fight Feat
Heightened Continual Flame (Must be cast by a PC)
Daylight + Torch.

Daylight, even on a scroll is more helpful that you may think.
Assuming you can find your way out of the darkness cast daylight on your gear: in the areas where deeper darkness and daylight overlap the ambient light will prevail. In this case it is helpful to have a torch or some-other non magical source of light.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories, Starfinder Society Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

Actually, if I could make friends with a Level 5 Cleric, they could just cast Continual Flame for me at Level 3, and it would even out with Deeper Darkness at least one light level, right?

Grand Lodge 4/5

Magic missile.

I kid, I kid.

A Dayfinder from the PFS Player's guide costs 10pp. That would work once. After that, you just get someone to ready a counter spell dispel magic on the darkness caster.

5/5 *

Right, it would return to whatever light it was before. Good thing about a heightened version is it would overtake it.

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories, Starfinder Society Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

That is so true! A Level 4 Continual Flame would defeat the Deeper Darkness!

Who wants to be my new best friend and play a VTT scenario so they can cast Heightened Continual Flame for me? :)

2/5 *

Daylight can still help. And a scroll can help too, just move away from the Darkness and use it. Even if someone casts Deeper Darkness 10 times in the same area, they still cancel each other out. As long as the opponent doesn't Dispel Magic your Daylight, you're ok. You'll still need non-magical light to see however.

Another problem is that the rules regarding darkness aren't 100% clear. I know I had it GMed incorrectly in one scenario by an experienced GM.

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/55/55/55/5 ***** Contributor

zean wrote:

That is so true! A Level 4 Continual Flame would defeat the Deeper Darkness!

Who wants to be my new best friend and play a VTT scenario so they can cast Heightened Continual Flame for me? :)

It's late, so I may be foggy on this, but couldn't this also be purchased as "spellcasting services" by a NPC?

5/5 5/55/55/5

Mike Bramnik wrote:
zean wrote:

That is so true! A Level 4 Continual Flame would defeat the Deeper Darkness!

Who wants to be my new best friend and play a VTT scenario so they can cast Heightened Continual Flame for me? :)

It's late, so I may be foggy on this, but couldn't this also be purchased as "spellcasting services" by a NPC?

You can't buy metamagicked potions oils scrolls or spells.

Apparently all the PFS casters have skill focuses in their dayjobs...

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/55/55/55/5 ***** Contributor

BigNorseWolf wrote:
Mike Bramnik wrote:
zean wrote:

That is so true! A Level 4 Continual Flame would defeat the Deeper Darkness!

Who wants to be my new best friend and play a VTT scenario so they can cast Heightened Continual Flame for me? :)

It's late, so I may be foggy on this, but couldn't this also be purchased as "spellcasting services" by a NPC?

You can't buy metamagicked potions oils scrolls or spells.

Well, wasn't suggesting that - rather I meant hiring a 7th level caster to cast continual flame would make it a "level 4" continual flame, wouldn't it? Nothing metamagic about it, just paying for a caster of higher level (if available by city size etc etc).

Grand Lodge

Pathfinder Maps, Pathfinder Accessories, Starfinder Society Subscriber; Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber

Sadly no... just because you use a higher level Spell Slot, I don't believe that actually heightens its effective level.

4/5 *** Venture-Captain, Arizona—Tucson

You can try to shut down the darkness, or you can try to ignore it. There are plenty of animal companions and summoned beasts that deal well with darkness. There are also feats and abilities that make characters able to function well in darkness.

Sczarni 4/5

Scroll is 375 gp only.
Oil is 750 gp.

If you can't use scroll, buy oil for 2 PP.

1/5

1 person marked this as a favorite.

You best friend is a Hand of Glory for this situation. Gives you an extra ring slot and lets you cast Daylight and see invisibility once per day. This item lets you counter darkness, deeper darkness, and invisibility.

Your cheaper bet is to go potions of the same spells.

4/5

zean wrote:
I mean, I guess you could cast Daylight, but if the NPCs just cast Deeper Darkness again, doesn't that counter Daylight?

To be able to nullify your daylight they would have to cast it and touch the source with their charge, as deeper darkness and daylight are touch spells.

It's also *generally* accepted that two deeper darknesses + one daylight = same as one of each. Their effects don't stack, and basically their areas create a "Venn diagram" of light levels.

Dark Archive

zean wrote:
Sadly no... just because you use a higher level Spell Slot, I don't believe that actually heightens its effective level.

This is correct. Burning a higher level spell slot has no mechanical effect on the spell you cast.

And remember, the radius on the light from continual flame doesn't reach very far.

You best and cheapest bet is a scroll with 2 daylights for 2PP. If you get caught in deeper darkness, leave the area of effect and cast the spell on yourself. The only way the deeper darkness caster could counter this is by sucessfully casting deeper darkness on you, which I beleive would require a melee touch attack, and force them to come into the radius of your daylight/deeper darkness negation.

Grand Lodge 5/5 *

Yiroep wrote:
zean wrote:
I mean, I guess you could cast Daylight, but if the NPCs just cast Deeper Darkness again, doesn't that counter Daylight?

To be able to nullify your daylight they would have to cast it and touch the source with their charge, as deeper darkness and daylight are touch spells.

It's also *generally* accepted that two deeper darknesses + one daylight = same as one of each. Their effects don't stack, and basically their areas create a "Venn diagram" of light levels.

Exactly this. 2 Deeper Darkness spells doesn't overpower one Daylight spell; all 3 spells are ineffective in their overlapping areas of effect.

The only way to end an ongoing Daylight with a Deeper Darkness is to have the Deeper Darkness caster touch the item that the Daylight is emanating from. That ends the Deeper Darkness that they just cast before it starts, and dispels the Daylight. If there's still another Deeper Darkness spell in the room, it is now unhindered in its effects.

Sovereign Court 5/5 RPG Superstar 2009 Top 32, 2010 Top 8

Sopend two feat slots to get the Tiefling vision thing? (first slot gives you Darkvision 120 and low light vision, 2nd slot allows you to ignore magical darkness.)

Liberty's Edge 5/5

Don't forget that daylight only counters the darkness, meaning the room defaults to ambient light where the daylight and darkness overlap. Other magical lighting (below level 3) does not work. If the ambient lighting is dark, you still can't see. This can mean you also need a non-magical light source, such as a regular torch, sunrod, or lantern.

The Exchange 5/5

Also, a Continual Flame from a Cleric is a 3rd level spell. So, next time you adventure with a 5th level or higher cleric - get him to cast Continual Flame on something for you. Then buy sun rods.

5/5

This is all well and good until the NPCs start slinging dispel magic too. ;-)

The Exchange 5/5

Kyle Baird wrote:
This is all well and good until the NPCs start slinging dispel magic too. ;-)

So true! my bard needs to get another Continual Flame cast on her cape... so she needs to adventure with a cleric PC at the table again!.


Pathfinder Maps Subscriber

Dotted for interest.

Lantern Lodge 3/5

zean wrote:
Sadly no... just because you use a higher level Spell Slot, I don't believe that actually heightens its effective level.

A heightened spell (using the metamagic feat) actually raises the effect spell level of a spell. The description of the feat gives an example of bypassing a lessor Globe of Invulnerability due to spell level by using this method.

Similarly, a heightened continual light spell would work.

Silver Crusade 2/5

Kyle Baird wrote:
This is all well and good until the NPCs start slinging dispel magic too. ;-)

This is why the real solution is an 8th level cleric with the Sun domain.

Workin' on it, I'm almost 4th! :D

5/5

Stupid sun clerics always screwing up my evil plans.

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/55/55/55/5 ***** Contributor

nosig wrote:
Also, a Continual Flame from a Cleric is a 3rd level spell. So, next time you adventure with a 5th level or higher cleric - get him to cast Continual Flame on something for you. Then buy sun rods.

An Ioun Torch apparently has a caster level of 12 (as I learned to my surprise a few minutes ago), so those would be an inexpensive way to counter Deeper Darkness, methinks, since the stone would already be lit (even if in a pocket or somesuch). Take it out and start to orbit, and there's your magical counter, I believe?

(Followed by Sunrods/Torches for the rest, as previously mentioned).

1/5

Mike Bramnik wrote:
nosig wrote:
Also, a Continual Flame from a Cleric is a 3rd level spell. So, next time you adventure with a 5th level or higher cleric - get him to cast Continual Flame on something for you. Then buy sun rods.

An Ioun Torch apparently has a caster level of 12 (as I learned to my surprise a few minutes ago), so those would be an inexpensive way to counter Deeper Darkness, methinks, since the stone would already be lit (even if in a pocket or somesuch). Take it out and start to orbit, and there's your magical counter, I believe?

(Followed by Sunrods/Torches for the rest, as previously mentioned).

It's not about the caster level that was used when casting a spell / making an ioun torch. It is about the actual spell level. In this case, continual flame cast by a wizard is a lvl 2 spell and would not counter deeper darkness. However, as nosig pointed out, a cleric casts continual flame as a 3rd lvl spell and thus a clerics continual flame will counter deeper darkness.

The Exchange 5/5

Lab_Rat wrote:
Mike Bramnik wrote:
nosig wrote:
Also, a Continual Flame from a Cleric is a 3rd level spell. So, next time you adventure with a 5th level or higher cleric - get him to cast Continual Flame on something for you. Then buy sun rods.

An Ioun Torch apparently has a caster level of 12 (as I learned to my surprise a few minutes ago), so those would be an inexpensive way to counter Deeper Darkness, methinks, since the stone would already be lit (even if in a pocket or somesuch). Take it out and start to orbit, and there's your magical counter, I believe?

(Followed by Sunrods/Torches for the rest, as previously mentioned).

It's not about the caster level that was used when casting a spell / making an ioun torch. It is about the actual spell level. In this case, continual flame cast by a wizard is a lvl 2 spell and would not counter deeper darkness. However, as nosig pointed out, a cleric casts continual flame as a 3rd lvl spell and thus a clerics continual flame will counter deeper darkness.

I have a cleric that used to cast Continual Flame on an Ioun Stone at the start of each scenario (cost 1 third level spell and 50gp). Now (with 4.2!) I get to keep it from adventure to adventure! Yeah! But I often have the spell ready, so that I can cast it on other players stuff (one each). The other player notes my Caster Level, character number, the fact that it's 3rd level (Divine spell) and that he spent 50gp on the materieal Components, all on his Chronicle and the just signs off on conditions gained. Just doing my part to make the Society a better place.

Liberty's Edge 5/5 **

When facing dark folk (who have Deeper Darkness at-will) you're not going to out-Daylight their Darkness. Your best bet is to coordinate the party and arrange actions such that you can burst them down with the one turn you have before they put the Deeper Darkness back up.

Silver Crusade 2/5

Feral wrote:
When facing dark folk (who have Deeper Darkness at-will) you're not going to out-Daylight their Darkness. Your best bet is to coordinate the party and arrange actions such that you can burst them down with the one turn you have before they put the Deeper Darkness back up.

Sun cleric still wins! :D

The Exchange 5/5

Feral wrote:
When facing dark folk (who have Deeper Darkness at-will) you're not going to out-Daylight their Darkness. Your best bet is to coordinate the party and arrange actions such that you can burst them down with the one turn you have before they put the Deeper Darkness back up.

I am confused by your use of the phrase "...put the Deeper Darkness back up." Both Deeper Darkness and the 3rd level light spells (Daylight/Continual Flame) will over lap and continue to exist. A second Deeper Darkness doesn't make it darker...

1/5

nosig wrote:
Feral wrote:
When facing dark folk (who have Deeper Darkness at-will) you're not going to out-Daylight their Darkness. Your best bet is to coordinate the party and arrange actions such that you can burst them down with the one turn you have before they put the Deeper Darkness back up.
I am confused by your use of the phrase "...put the Deeper Darkness back up." Both Deeper Darkness and the 3rd level light spells (Daylight/Continual Flame) will over lap and continue to exist. A second Deeper Darkness doesn't make it darker...

I think some people play it as the spells cancel each other out and go away...kind of like a dispel magic. Then the enemy just casts deeper darkness again.

" Darkness can be used to counter or dispel any light spell of equal or lower spell level."

I play it as the spells never go away, it's just that where their effects overlap the light level is whatever it is naturally. I think if they wanted it to work like dispel magic they would have said something to that extent.

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

2 people marked this as FAQ candidate.
Lab_Rat wrote:
nosig wrote:
Feral wrote:
When facing dark folk (who have Deeper Darkness at-will) you're not going to out-Daylight their Darkness. Your best bet is to coordinate the party and arrange actions such that you can burst them down with the one turn you have before they put the Deeper Darkness back up.
I am confused by your use of the phrase "...put the Deeper Darkness back up." Both Deeper Darkness and the 3rd level light spells (Daylight/Continual Flame) will over lap and continue to exist. A second Deeper Darkness doesn't make it darker...

I think some people play it as the spells cancel each other out and go away...kind of like a dispel magic. Then the enemy just casts deeper darkness again.

" Darkness can be used to counter or dispel any light spell of equal or lower spell level."

I play it as the spells never go away, it's just that where their effects overlap the light level is whatever it is naturally. I think if they wanted it to work like dispel magic they would have said something to that extent.

Summary of how it actually works:
If Daylight and Deeper Darkness are already active, and they're brought within each other's range, the overlapping area reverts back to unmodified light levels. Neither effect is dispelled, and additional castings of either spell has no increased effect.

If one is active, the other can be cast on the same target (keeping in mind the range is "touch") and used to dispel the first without producing any additional effect. In this case, neither spell is active afterwards, and therefore an additional casting of one or the other will have full effect.

"Negated in the overlap" and "dispel" are two entirely separate things.

The Exchange 1/5

or you could also go the other route.

strong defense by an even stronger offense.

have the summoner of your party call in some support:
earth elementals have tremor sense - plus they are immune to sneak dmg
giant spiders do too - and they can web, ensare, and grapple
giant bats have blindsense

take their advantage away with spells like:
blacklight - all but the cast can now see
cast your own deeper darkness - unless you are fighting darkfolk
cast improved invisibility
beast shape 2 gives you tremorsense

use tactics:
close the door and smoke the room till they die of suffocation
ready an action to grapple the next thing that attacks you

or, i dont know, step out of the darkness.

Grand Lodge 2/5

We're considering an all Half-Orc party to use standard darkness against NPC's.


If your opponents can see in darkness, a simple Obscuring Mist will pretty much level the playing field. You still cannot see a thing, but neither can they.

Of course, this fails against opponents with blindsight or tremorsense.

2/5

Midnight_Angel wrote:

If your opponents can see in darkness, a simple Obscuring Mist will pretty much level the playing field. You still cannot see a thing, but neither can they.

Of course, this fails against opponents with blindsight or tremorsense.

Blindsense and tremorsense do not let you ignore concealement. They just let you know what square enemies are in. Blindsight does let you ignore concealment however.

The Exchange 4/5

Jiggy wrote:
Lab_Rat wrote:
nosig wrote:
Feral wrote:
When facing dark folk (who have Deeper Darkness at-will) you're not going to out-Daylight their Darkness. Your best bet is to coordinate the party and arrange actions such that you can burst them down with the one turn you have before they put the Deeper Darkness back up.
I am confused by your use of the phrase "...put the Deeper Darkness back up." Both Deeper Darkness and the 3rd level light spells (Daylight/Continual Flame) will over lap and continue to exist. A second Deeper Darkness doesn't make it darker...

I think some people play it as the spells cancel each other out and go away...kind of like a dispel magic. Then the enemy just casts deeper darkness again.

" Darkness can be used to counter or dispel any light spell of equal or lower spell level."

I play it as the spells never go away, it's just that where their effects overlap the light level is whatever it is naturally. I think if they wanted it to work like dispel magic they would have said something to that extent.

** spoiler omitted **

CORRECT

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

If my brothers and I lived in the same area, we'd probably build a coordinated all-tiefling team and all of us take Fiend Sight twice to gain the See In Darkness monster ability. By mid levels, at least one of us would be capable of casting deeper darkness... maybe even save up for a wand of it. And at least one of us would be a rogue or ninja, and we'd always play the characters together.

>:D

The Exchange 5/5

Jiggy wrote:

If my brothers and I lived in the same area, we'd probably build a coordinated all-tiefling team and all of us take Fiend Sight twice to gain the See In Darkness monster ability. By mid levels, at least one of us would be capable of casting deeper darkness... maybe even save up for a wand of it. And at least one of us would be a rogue or ninja, and we'd always play the characters together.

>:D

so... no girls allowed? is this like a tree-house boys club?

Female Tiefling Arcane Trickster

Shadow Lodge 4/5 5/5 RPG Superstar Season 9 Top 8

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Jiggy wrote:

If my brothers and I lived in the same area, we'd probably build a coordinated all-tiefling team and all of us take Fiend Sight twice to gain the See In Darkness monster ability. By mid levels, at least one of us would be capable of casting deeper darkness... maybe even save up for a wand of it. And at least one of us would be a rogue or ninja, and we'd always play the characters together.

>:D

Jiggy, when I read the title of this thread, I thought it was about PCs with darkvision using darkness to their advantage...

Like a PFS team comprised of people that can see in darkness: elemental races / fetchling / dwarf / gnome / half-orc PCs... a kind of black ops team.

You could have a frontliner, a shadowdancer, a cleric or inquisitor with the darkness domain, a ranged rogue (sneak attack all the time :D). Have them all invest in the "see in darkness" line of feats from the ARG. They'd be the group that the Venture Captains send in to "clean up" after the other Pathfinders drop the ball *yet* again. The best of the best of the best.

"In 4672 a crack adventuring unit was sent to an prison by an Aspis-bribed court for a crime they didn't commit. These men promptly escaped from a maximum security stockade to the Absalom underground. Today, still wanted by the consortium, they survive as pathfinders of fortune. If you have a problem, if no one else can help, and if you can find them, maybe you can hire the A-Team."

Grand Lodge 2/5 RPG Superstar 2015 Top 32, RPG Superstar 2012 Top 32

Pretty much. :D

Community / Forums / Organized Play / Pathfinder Society / Fighting NPCs with Darkness and Deeper Darkness All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.