| SuperParkourio |
If a hazard's Strike has both an attack modifier and a basic save listed, do both apply? For instance, if the attack roll crits and the basic save crit fails, I think that would do triple damage (as described in the Game Conventions sidebar). But if the save was success, that would be 2 + 0.5 - 1, so I think the resulting multiplier would be 1.5?
| SuperParkourio |
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
It's in Pathfinder Society #4-17: Trapping the Hag's Claw. It apparently also shows up in #4-08: Battle for Star's Fate. Here's the routine and Strike in question.
Ranged ◆ cannon blast +15 (range increment 40 feet, reload 2), Damage 2d8+5 bludgeoning damage to creatures in a 5-foot burst (DC 21 basic Reflex save)
| TheFinish |
Oh, that seems to be a mistake, no other Hazard in the game works like this, and neither do Siege Weapons.
I looked through the rulebooks and there doesn't seem to be an answer. The closest we get is disintegrate, where a critical hit on the spell attack roll means the target treats the subsequent save as one step worse.
I'd say this is a definite candidate for Errata but I don't think Society scenarios get those.
EDIT: Wanted to add, in the Damage Roll rules, where it specifies how to double and halve damage, at no point do the rules say what to do if you need to double twice, unlike in 1e where that was specified. Which makes me think that's not something that is supposed to happen at all, nor is doubling and halving on the same damage roll.
| SuperParkourio |
Actually, there's another mechanic in the same battle that can double the hazard's damage.
So even if we ignore the attack roll and just use the basic save, someone that crit fails can take double damage, and this can combine with that additional effect that makes it deal double damage.
And according to the Game Conventions sidebar, we combine those multipliers. 2 + 2 - 1 = 3. The hazard would deal triple damage to that creature.
The Raven Black
|
Actually, there's another mechanic in the same battle that can double the hazard's damage.
** spoiler omitted **
So even if we ignore the attack roll and just use the basic save, someone that crit fails can take double damage, and this can combine with that additional effect that makes it deal double damage.
And according to the Game Conventions sidebar, we combine those multipliers. 2 + 2 - 1 = 3. The hazard would deal triple damage to that creature.
I think the intent is that the base damage for the burst effect is doubled. And then the save is rolled and degrees of success applies. So I would rule twice the base damage, and that damage can be multiplied by 2 if crit failed.
As for the bonus to attack, maybe this means a successful attack must first hit the structure before the AoE effect happens.