Petrified and teleportation effect or disintegrate


Rules Discussion


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Hello, I have a question about petrified condition and about teleportation effect or disintegrate.

Quote:
You become an object with a Bulk double your normal Bulk (typically 12 for a petrified Medium creature or 6 for a petrified Small creature), AC 9, Hardness 8, and the same current Hit Points you had when alive. You don’t have a Broken Threshold. When you’re turned back into flesh, you have the same number of Hit Points you had as a statue. If the statue is destroyed, you immediately die.

If the statue is destroyed, is it when the Hit Points falls to zero ?

Dimension door :

Quote:
you instantly transport yourself and any items you're wearing and holding from your current space to a clear space

Is it possible to use dimension door if the character is holding the statue of a petrified opponent ?

Disintegrate :

Quote:
An object you hit is destroyed (no save), regardless of Hardness, unless it's an artifact or similarly hard to destroy.

Is it possible to disintegrate a petrified opponent ?

Thanks for your future help.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

An item (or object) is destroyed when its HP reaches 0.

Teleporting with a statue depends on your strength score - You can't hold or carry more Bulk than 10 plus your Strength modifier (you can drag a larger item, but that doesn't count as holding it). To be able to hold a petrified medium creature, you need a +2 strength modifier minimum to meet the max bulk capacity of 10 + str mod(assuming you aren't carrying any other bulk, otherwise you will need a higher strength modifier) - just touching or holding onto an item doesn't count as the item being held, "an item you are holding" refers to something you have actually picked up.

Disintegrate automatically destroys objects, and a petrified opponent is an object, so yes, it destroys a petrified creature outright (as they die if their petrified object form is destroyed).

edit: note that even if you can hold the statue, you will be encumbered if it is more than 5 + your str mod


3 people marked this as a favorite.

And this is why the incapacitation trait exists ;)

Grand Archive

6 people marked this as a favorite.

Do remember:

Shrink Item exists for your petrifying, trophy collecting, serial killer needs.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

My question on the dimension door and other teleportation effects is that they usually list that you can't take another creature with you. Does a petrified creature still also count as a creature? Or can you game the system by petrifying someone, teleporting them along with you, then unpetrifying them?


1 person marked this as a favorite.
breithauptclan wrote:
My question on the dimension door and other teleportation effects is that they usually list that you can't take another creature with you. Does a petrified creature still also count as a creature? Or can you game the system by petrifying someone, teleporting them along with you, then unpetrifying them?

Petrify says you're an object so you're an object. This system is written to be read as casual language, and it requires a more technical reading to have it count not just creatures and objects but also creature-objects.

That said though, it's not really gaming the system to bypass a small limitation with a heavy resource cost (and also random chance because there's no form of petrification I know of that doesn't involve a saving throw and there's no rule allowing voluntary failure of saving throws). Like, if you use flesh to stone, dimension door, then stone to flesh you've spent an extra 4 actions and 12 spell levels just to squeeze out the benefit of one extra 4th-level spell... that's not really a benefit.


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber

At least 12 spell levels. Flesh to Stone does have Incapacitation on saves after the first one, and you need enough fails or critical fails to get them all the way petrified, which isn't guaranteed even if you allow the target to worsen their result by one step (similar to what's suggested in the Gliminal sidebar).


I'm aware that it is a high cost, low probability gimmick. But it is still allowing something that is otherwise expressly forbidden by the game rules. Should it still be allowed anyway?


3 people marked this as a favorite.

It's not allowing anything "expressly forbidden" though... you're allowed to petrify creatures which makes them objects, and you're allowed to dimension door with carried objects, and you're allowed to try to unpetrify petrified creatures.

Treating the combination of all the spent spell slots and all the rolls going the right way and having a character that can both cast dimension door and carry all their normal gear plus still have enough encumbrance limit left over to heft up a statue as a "cheat" is nonsensical and ignores that this isn't just high cost & low probability - it's incredibly impractical to the point that it will only come up if someone has dedicated themselves to making it come up, and even then it will probably fail and even when successful takes multiple rounds of set-up just to pull off so you may as well just build for mobility and spend those rounds Striding 3 times if covering distance is your goal.


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Adventure Path, Starfinder Roleplaying Game, Starfinder Society Subscriber

I also don't see the ambiguity, here. Teleporting a statue with Dimension Door is not bringing a creature with you.


Well, I'm not entirely convinced. But I'll let it drop. It certainly isn't worth debating extensively.

I certainly agree that it is extremely unlikely to ever come up in an actual game.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
breithauptclan wrote:

Well, I'm not entirely convinced. But I'll let it drop. It certainly isn't worth debating extensively.

I certainly agree that it is extremely unlikely to ever come up in an actual game.

It could be used as a neat Oceans 11 style heist gimmick though. I'm imagining a situation where some sort of art collector has various busts and statues of fabled heroes, one of which just happens to be an easily impersonated Halfling... Hijinks ensue.

Liberty's Edge

I remember this sort of happened to me in a 3.5e game. My PC got turned to stone then plane shifted to the astral plane.


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Leomund "Leo" Velinznrarikovich wrote:

Do remember:

Shrink Item exists for your petrifying, trophy collecting, serial killer needs.

And when the heroes tracked the the disappearances back to his villainous basement lair and put an end to his evil machinations, there they found not only the miniaturized petrified remains of his many victims, but also what looked like maps and tomes about a fictional land, and the creative beginnings of some sort of new game's rule set.


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber
Leomund "Leo" Velinznrarikovich wrote:

Do remember:

Shrink Item exists for your petrifying, trophy collecting, serial killer needs.

When the heroes finally tracked the disappearances to the dastardly villain's subterranean lair and put a stop to his evil machinations, not only did they find the miniaturized, petrified remains of his numerous victims, they also uncovered several maps and tomes detailing a fictional world, pouches of polyhedral gemstones engraved with numbers, and what appeared to be the creative beginnings of a new game's rule set.


Pathfinder Roleplaying Game Superscriber; Pathfinder Starfinder Roleplaying Game Subscriber

Odd. I thought the forum monster ate my original post.


Ravingdork wrote:
Odd. I thought the forum monster ate my original post.

Most of the time it just spits them out later.

Liberty's Edge

Errenor wrote:
Ravingdork wrote:
Odd. I thought the forum monster ate my original post.
Most of the time it just spits them out later.

Indeed. Always good to double check.

Liberty's Edge

Ravingdork wrote:
Leomund "Leo" Velinznrarikovich wrote:

Do remember:

Shrink Item exists for your petrifying, trophy collecting, serial killer needs.

When the heroes finally tracked the disappearances to the dastardly villain's subterranean lair and put a stop to his evil machinations, not only did they find the miniaturized, petrified remains of his numerous victims, they also uncovered several maps and tomes detailing a fictional world, pouches of polyhedral gemstones engraved with numbers, and what appeared to be the creative beginnings of a new game's rule set.

"Gary Gygax, you're under arrest."

:-D

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder Second Edition / Rules Discussion / Petrified and teleportation effect or disintegrate All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.