| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
But still food, drinks and alchemical items are not magic related, while potions are.
That is actually a fairly convincing argument that imbibed alchemical items should be included in Seasoned automatically.
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
But still food, drinks and alchemical items are not magic related, while potions are.That is actually a fairly convincing argument that imbibed alchemical items should be included in Seasoned automatically.
Putting it another way, alcohol has the alchemical and poison traits and i am pretty sure it comes under drink.
I don't think this is intended RAW though, the writer probably just had a slip of the mind and forgot to mention elixirs.
Putting it another way, alcohol has the alchemical and poison traits and i am pretty sure it comes under drink.
I don't think this is intended RAW though, the writer probably just had a slip of the mind and forgot to mention elixirs.
By 'this' you are meaning the RAW interpretation that the bonus only applies to potions and mundane food, yes? (It is a bit confusing since 'this' could refer either to the second half of the sentence, or to the previous sentence.)
Because so far this thread is turning into another of the ultra-rare threads where consensus among the group is that RAW is dumb and should be ignored. Which is always amusing.
RAW isn't dumb. RAW can't take everything into account, both because the writers are humans and also because getting into all the potential nitpicking would result in an extremely big book.
In that case, I don't see why Elixir should be excluded, it's both RAW (these are drinks) and I think RAI (as I don't see a real difference between potions and Elixirs).
RAW isn't dumb. RAW can't take everything into account, both because the writers are humans and also because getting into all the potential nitpicking would result in an extremely big book.
Sorry, not meaning to be insulting to the rules or the devs that create them. But there have been a couple rare times where we have all looked at the rules as they actually are and said, 'Umm... No.' Such as the thread I linked to about using a Battle Form and then suddenly not being able to escape a grapple.
By 'this' you are meaning the RAW interpretation that the bonus only applies to potions and mundane food, yes? (It is a bit confusing since 'this' could refer either to the second half of the sentence, or to the previous sentence.)
Because so far this thread is turning into another of the ultra-rare threads where consensus among the group is that RAW is dumb and should be ignored. Which is always amusing.
I mean by alcohol is certainly considered to be a drink, setting a precedent for elxirs being impacted under RAW.
RAI I believe it is intended, but I don't believe the feat was written thinking "drinks will imply elixirs are AoK", even though the above suggests they are RAW.