Sunder allows you to attack a worn or carried object, right?
A stowed polearm is a worn or carried object.
Improved Sunder lets you attempt a Sunder without triggering an Attack of Opportunity, right?
So, if you have Improved Sunder you can attempt to sunder a stowed polearm without triggering an Attack of Opportunity.
"Stowed" is not "unattended".
Well, it is if it is stowed in a cabinet, or in a locker, etc. But when it's stowed on a person's body, it's still attended.
Blake is correct. An object that is worn or carried by a creature is attended, even if they are not currently using it.
Unattended would be if it were laying on a table, or in a pile on the floor, or in a chest or cupboard. Basically anything other than being worn or carried.
I think it depends on where its stowed. I would say a sheathed weapon is a valid target.
| 4 people marked this as a favorite. |
I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
Owner - D20 Hobbies
|
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
+1
I did that to a flying wizard once from a flying monk, all his stuff fell 100 feet onto the battlefield.
I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
+1
I did that to a flying wizard once from a flying monk, all his stuff fell 100 feet onto the battlefield.
I'm imagining-
Wizard: "Fear my mastery of magics great and powerful"
Player: "That's fine, but I hope you've got an hour or two to gather up all of your junk."
-Sunders bag
I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
+1
I did that to a flying wizard once from a flying monk, all his stuff fell 100 feet onto the battlefield.
I'm imagining-
Wizard: "Fear my mastery of magics great and powerful"
Player: "That's fine, but I hope you've got an hour or two to gather up all of your junk."
-Sunders bag
That's what unseen servants are for.
That's what unseen servants are for.
Wizard: "Fear my mastery of magics great and powerful"Player: "That's fine, but I hope you've got an hour or two to gather up all of your junk."
-Sunders bag
I don't think that would be a great idea. They don't have your awareness of possession, so you can't say "pick up my belongings", and unless it was a sack with fairly specific items, it would be problematic to give them a command that would work.
Especially if it's over a populated area.
I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
I love that idea.
I'm envisioning an espadachín (spanish word for sword fighter) specializing in 2 handed weapons sundering his opponents bags, spell component pouches, what have you and yelling "¡¿Quién más tiene una piñata?!" (Who else has a pinata?!)
I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
Just remember what happends if you puncture a bag of Holding. And be ready for your teammates crying when it happends.
Just remember what happends if you puncture a bag of Holding. And be ready for your teammates crying when it happends.I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
Barb: "I BROKE HIS BAG - WAAAAAAAGH"
Rogue: "WAAAAAAARGHL"
Ranger: "Heh."
Cleric: "That's... that's horrifying! Who on this plane would carry such things?!"
The necromancer's bag of holding is spewing forth a veritable Pu Pu Platter of his life's 'reagent collection.'
| 1 person marked this as a favorite. |
Just remember what happends if you puncture a bag of Holding. And be ready for your teammates crying when it happends.I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
Barb: "I BROKE HIS BAG - WAAAAAAAGH"
Rogue: "WAAAAAAARGHL"
Ranger: "Heh."
Cleric: "That's... that's horrifying! Who on this plane would carry such things?!"
The necromancer's bag of holding is spewing forth a veritable Pu Pu Platter of his life's 'reagent collection.'
The stuff in the bag is lost for good if the bag breaks.
The stuff in the bag is lost for good if the bag breaks.Just remember what happends if you puncture a bag of Holding. And be ready for your teammates crying when it happends.I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
Barb: "I BROKE HIS BAG - WAAAAAAAGH"
Rogue: "WAAAAAAARGHL"
Ranger: "Heh."
Cleric: "That's... that's horrifying! Who on this plane would carry such things?!"
The necromancer's bag of holding is spewing forth a veritable Pu Pu Platter of his life's 'reagent collection.'
Ah I had forgotten about that. Could some attempt to forcefully turn it inside out if it's not won like a backpack on the opponent?
The stuff in the bag is lost for good if the bag breaks.Just remember what happends if you puncture a bag of Holding. And be ready for your teammates crying when it happends.I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
Barb: "I BROKE HIS BAG - WAAAAAAAGH"
Rogue: "WAAAAAAARGHL"
Ranger: "Heh."
Cleric: "That's... that's horrifying! Who on this plane would carry such things?!"
The necromancer's bag of holding is spewing forth a veritable Pu Pu Platter of his life's 'reagent collection.'
Ah I had forgotten about that. Could some attempt to forcefully turn it inside out if it's not won like a backpack on the opponent?
I dont see how. Just lille the guy and take his xp as well as his stuff.
Just remember what happends if you puncture a bag of Holding. And be ready for your teammates crying when it happends.I would say it's not valid to target if it's completely out of sight. A weapon in a sheath you can still see to target. A dagger inside a sack, not so much.
Although you could sunder the sack and see what poured out. Combat pinata.
To be fair, that's why Sunder, which can be very effective against non-monster opponents, is so rarely used. It destroys the shinies that you're expecting to forcefully inherit.