| Kayerloth |
Mostly Heighten Spell is going to get used for one of the following:
1) To raise the DC of any saves involved.
2) To allow the spell to be used on someone within a Lesser Globe of Invulnerability or Globe of Invulnerability. Similarly it can be used to beat the various forms of Spell Immunity. Not sure if a FAQ or elsewhere has clarified whether an otherwise metagmagicked Fireball (such as Empowered) is sufficient to bypass Spell Immunity but clearly a 5th level version defeats Spell Immunity's limit of 4th level or less.
3) To defeat wording such as appears in Continual Flame and other spells (bolding mine):
Light spells counter and dispel darkness spells of an equal or lower level.
So, for example, if I had an archer companion getting routinely (or in a critical situation) shut down by Fickle Winds you can bet I would be using the last line in Fickle Winds to deal with the issue in some manner while on my Loremaster:
This spell has no effect within the area of a higher-level wind or weather spell.
| wraithstrike |
wraithstrike wrote:I dont know if a fog counts as weather.What else would you call it? Given that the National Weather Service tracks fog and issues "fog warnings" at appropriate times, you have to be pretty hard-core into disempowering PCs to argue with that.
I guess it is weather, but I never thought of it as weather. However the control weather spell does mention fog.
| Kayerloth |
What higher level wind or weather effect would you use?
Depends on the situation. If I was routinely encountering the situation I'd probably need to research a new or variant spell as a relatively quick glance shows few Sor/Wiz spells of those sort that aren't already higher level (negating the need for Heighten) or simply aren't Sor/Wiz spells. One could simply Heighten Gust of Wind. Yes your Archer companion would take a -4 to hit but at least he could use a Full Attack for the next round on the offender. Similarly I might use a Heightened Cloak of Winds. This spell is intended for use on yourself and allies but nothing prohibits you from targeting a foe either they are just likely to take advantage of the saving throw option ... which is a Fort save. I'd probably have whatever choice I came up with on a scroll since it isn't likely something I'd have memorized routinely (in Heightened form anyway) regardless of which spell I was using to deal with Fickle Winds (unless my GM really liked to use Fickle Winds, a lot). That would be one advantage of being a spontaneous caster in this situation. If it was a critical situation and/or perhaps the first time encountering the situation I might resort to using Limited Wish rather than Heightening something. Otherwise Heighten Control Winds or Control Weather could both be used by the appropriate caster.
Ninja'd big time (yeah for slow typing)
And yes Fog Cloud should work I'd think. And yes it would have been really nice to either use/create the appropriate descriptor (Wind or Weather) or make it somehow clear. As is we are left with normal English usage and all the table variation one might expect as a result.
| Kayerloth |
I think Orfamay Quest hit it out of the park, scored a hat trick and dropped a hole in one all at the same time with the response above. My mind was too focused on "Wind" spells and sort of forgot about the "Weather" side of things. If the Weather domain doesn't consist of just weather spells I don't know what would.
Lastly the long term solution my Loremaster would have probably adopted if finding himself up against Fickle Winds with any frequency would have been to Craft a Staff with an appropriate spell or two on it for nullifying Fickle Winds.
| Adept_Woodwright |
If you get the fancy to build a counterspelling (Arcane) sorcerer for a duel, you can use heightened cantrips to counter high level spells. I get a kick out of the idea of countering limited wish with a heightened prestidigitation.
(I think it can be done to Wish too, with the right set up... I can't recall if the idea leaned on mythic or not)