Forum seems unable to handle long URLs....


Website Feedback


For example lets say i were to paste a URL : http://paizo.com/threads/rzs2qqpm?Why-wont-Paizo-release-an-errata-for-the- Ice#14

You will notice that it adds a space between "the" and "-ice", which makes the URL invalid.


2 people marked this as a favorite.

Or you could just use URL tags. See "How to format your text".


Why cant the forums do that automatically? This is literally the first forum ive seen that doesnt do that, or screws up a URL by adding random spaces in the middle of it.


The adding of spaces in the middle of a lengthy continuous string of characters (URL or otherwise), is a fairly standard anti-vandalism measure. Many sites use such a mechanism to prevent the site formatting from being broken by someone who falls asleep with their face on the keyboard.

As for why the forums don't automatically detect and wrap a long URL with the appropriate URL tags i.e. [url=click here]? Well, my understanding is that the whole site has been coded from the ground-up, and there are other issues with higher priority ahead of such niceties.


Im confused, how would a long string of continous characters break site formatting?

If someone posts 100 letter As, whether or not theres a space in the middle is not going to stop the post from looking like, well, 100 As.


It's related to how word-wrapping is handled in web browsers. The simple version is that text that would be too long to fit on the current line gets moved down to the next line at the preceding space character. However, lets say the content area of a webpage (e.g. the area where the text of our posts shows up) is only 80-characters wide. If we then have 100 continuous characters with no breaks, there is no preceding space to wrap that text.

At that point, the web browser will instead expand that content area to accommodate the additional width. This then would make our posts windows (which are only supposed to take up a set amount of space) extend off the right-hand side of the screen, and people would start seeing horizontal scroll bars.

This isn't so bad when the content area for each post is self-contained, but on many older boards, all those posts would go into a single table column. On such site, that would cause everyone's posts to scroll off the right-hand side of the screen. Exploiting this was a time-honored tradition of many a troll, and a source of thermonuclear flaming for less technically adept users.

So yeah, that's why more modern sites break up lengthy strings of characters.

(If anyone else wants to take a stab at a more technically accurate description, be my guest.)


1 person marked this as a favorite.
Laithoron wrote:

The adding of spaces in the middle of a lengthy continuous string of characters (URL or otherwise), is a fairly standard anti-vandalism measure. Many sites use such a mechanism to prevent the site formatting from being broken by someone who falls asleep with their face on the keyboard.

As for why the forums don't automatically detect and wrap a long URL with the appropriate URL tags i.e. [url=click here]? Well, my understanding is that the whole site has been coded from the ground-up, and there are other issues with higher priority ahead of such niceties.

It serves as an anti-spam measure, as well. Spambots generally don't know how to use BBCode, so their URLs are prevented from linking up by this feature.

RPG Superstar 2008 Top 32

1 person marked this as a favorite.
Laithoron wrote:
(If anyone else wants to take a stab at a more technically accurate description, be my guest.)

That's pretty accurate.


Question wrote:
Why cant the forums do that automatically? This is literally the first forum ive seen that doesnt do that, or screws up a URL by adding random spaces in the middle of it.

I, OTOH, have never seen a message board adding URL tags automatically.

It's not that hard to do yourself.

RPG Superstar 2008 Top 32

Fabius Maximus wrote:
Question wrote:
Why cant the forums do that automatically? This is literally the first forum ive seen that doesnt do that, or screws up a URL by adding random spaces in the middle of it.

I, OTOH, have never seen a message board adding URL tags automatically.

It's not that hard to do yourself.

Indeed. And adding [url] tags to text is way more readable and aesthetically pleasing than raw URLs.


Well i tried adding url tags but that resulted in very weird results so i ended up having to remove them.

testing :

[url=www.google.com][/url]

Either way i would like to suggest to the web team that the forum auto put in URL tags for URLs if possible.

Shadow Lodge

A couple of things, Question.
1) You need http:// before the url, otherwise it tries linking to a page here on the paizo forums.

2) you actually have to put text between the ][

So your link would be like this


Yea i was hoping it would be able to display the URL instead of requiring additional text to "name" the URL...


Question wrote:
Yea i was hoping it would be able to display the URL instead of requiring additional text to "name" the URL...

Why? If you put descriptive text in there, it looks cleaner.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

You can always do it this way {url=url here}url here again{/url} if you really want it that way


http://paizo.com/threads/rzs2qqrg?Forum-seems-unable-to-handle-long-URLs#15

Something like this.

Community / Forums / Paizo / Website Feedback / Forum seems unable to handle long URLs.... All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Website Feedback