Bureaucracy > Science


Off-Topic Discussions


There are, of course, other examples of this (feel free to share in this thread), but this one left me speechless:

EU bans claim that water can prevent dehydration

Sure, our so-called public servants here in the U.S. think that a smear of pizza sauce counts as a vegetable serving, but I'm pretty sure they still know that water is wet.

Liberty's Edge

....... WHAT!? They... I.. I have no words.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Clearly, the Water Elementals need to pump up their lobbying skills.

Grand Lodge

It makes sense in it's own way. Making the claim the manufacturers make about Bottle Water can be construed to be suggesting that the product is superior to tap water when it comes to handling hydration.

Scarab Sages

Clearly the officials involved should be locked in a room for several days without access to water in any form.

After several days have passed, they can be permitted access to water to see if it helps their dehydrated condition.

The Exchange

You can't do that, Artanthos. Not because of any hippie "moral" concerns, either. You can't do that because when the door was unsealed, all you'd find would be one very big, fat EU official with a taste for human blood. And then he'd drain you dry and go on a 2-day rampage ending with the Swiss Army having to vaporize him (thus justifying the existence of the Swiss Army at last.)

...Wait, wasn't this on MST3K once?


Lincoln Hills wrote:

You can't do that, Artanthos. Not because of any hippie "moral" concerns, either. You can't do that because when the door was unsealed, all you'd find would be one very big, fat EU official with a taste for human blood. And then he'd drain you dry and go on a 2-day rampage ending with the Swiss Army having to vaporize him (thus justifying the existence of the Swiss Army at last.)

...Wait, wasn't this on MST3K once?

If not, it should have been.


LazarX wrote:
It makes sense in it's own way. Making the claim the manufacturers make about Bottle Water can be construed to be suggesting that the product is superior to tap water when it comes to handling hydration.

Yeah. Even if it's obviously true (in which case you don't need to advertise it) saying that insinuates that other beverages don't. That's be like if Pepsi's new slogan was "With 100% less cancer than other leading sodas!"


meatrace wrote:
LazarX wrote:
It makes sense in it's own way. Making the claim the manufacturers make about Bottle Water can be construed to be suggesting that the product is superior to tap water when it comes to handling hydration.
Yeah. Even if it's obviously true (in which case you don't need to advertise it) saying that insinuates that other beverages don't. That's be like if Pepsi's new slogan was "With 100% less cancer than other leading sodas!"

Yep, that's the point.

And as a rule of thumb, European authorities are quite unwelcoming with foods claiming to have effects on health (such as "this yogurt will make you lose weight", etc.), to the great sorrow of marketing guys everywhere.

You should also know that (at least in France), for historical reasons, norms of potability are MORE severe for tap water than for bottled water. Some of the latter wouldn't be allowed, coming from a tap. In short, at the start of the twentieth century, some very mineralized water were seen and sold more or less as health enhancing products. At the time, being radioactive was even a plus! Thus, any claim from water companies that their product is better in any way than tap water is seen in a very unfavorable light, and properly hammered down.

You should see that as a match between, in the left corner, big water companies, in the right, the consumer rights european bureaucracy. Ding! And of course, papers ridiculing the UE stance are part of the fight.

The Exchange

Smarnil le couard wrote:
...You should also know that (at least in France), for historical reasons, norms of potability are MORE severe for tap water than for bottled water...

It would be so nice to live in a country with cultural mores that cause them to strongly oppose industrialized food. I try to inform people (without being preachy), but they just shrug, think "conspiracy nut" and continue shoveling contaminated factory-farm eggs and tasteless (as well as dangerous) beef-fed beef into their face holes.

Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Off-Topic Discussions / Bureaucracy > Science All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Off-Topic Discussions