Hey Guys, I know I have said on here before that my group plays pathfinder, RC, B/X, 1E/2E hybrid games depending on our whim. Out favorite is probaly RC and we have been playing our own stripped down retro version of dnd. But... with the gunslinger I have seen more of my players loving this new class, and they hated firearms in all my games in the past. My brother who is a diehard no skills or feat neccessary player, he read the gunslinger and after our first playtest with it has found it to be the funnest class he has ever played since 1EOA. That says alot. So if my group is loving it, you are definitely headed in the right direction, since they are hard to please with any new rule or mechanic. I'll try to get you some stats on how our combats go in the next week.
Keep up the good work.
Our group did think the pistol and musket should have the same misfire chance (either way as long as they are the same) because the musket had a longer load time, they did not feel it needed a highter misfire chance than the pistol. So we concluded they should both be the same. We're just not sure yet if the should both be 1 or both be 1-2. But we are still toying with it.