I had a discussion with our new GM on alchemical silver and bludgeoning weapons like a mace but more importantly brassknuckles. His argument is this statement in the rules. On a successful attack with a silvered slashing or piercing weapon, the wielder takes a -1 penalty on the damage roll. It didn't say anywhere a bludgeoning weapon can't be silvered. That statement to me says piercing and slashing weapons take -1 damage. Possibly to represent the silvering process keeps the weapon somewhat dulled by the process.--opinions?
