Silver and Wooden Holy Symbols


Rules Questions

Liberty's Edge

I cannot find anything in the rules to imply that a silver holy symbol is in any way superior to a wooden holy symbol. Is there any reason to buy the more expensive silver holy symbol? A holy symbol is required to channel energy, and presumably for the divine focus component of spells, but I see no functional difference between the silver and wood symbols.


Karrek wrote:
I cannot find anything in the rules to imply that a silver holy symbol is in any way superior to a wooden holy symbol. Is there any reason to buy the more expensive silver holy symbol? A holy symbol is required to channel energy, and presumably for the divine focus component of spells, but I see no functional difference between the silver and wood symbols.

There really isnt much, i believe it's easier to sunder a wooden symbol as opposed to a silver one. Thats pretty much it in terms of raw that I am aware of.


There is no functional difference. It's a roleplaying difference, though. A poor, backwoods priest isn't likely to be able to afford a silver holy symbol, while someone from a big city wouldn't be caught dead with a wooden one, etc.

Liberty's Edge

And Torag might be happier if his clerics used metal holy symbols rather rhan wood...

RPG Superstar 2010 Top 32

As far as I know, a silver holy symbol is just bling for clerics. You just can't have a high priest performing the weekly rituals with a wooden holy symbol.

Silver Crusade

Joe Wells wrote:
As far as I know, a silver holy symbol is just bling for clerics. You just can't have a high priest performing the weekly rituals with a wooden holy symbol.

Depends on the deity.

Dark Archive

Wear it loud, wear it proud! I think it's a personal choice and, for some people, represents a greater degree of respect or worship to have a more expensive holy symbol( you're putting more of your money into it ). If things get tight you can always use it to make holy water...

RPG Superstar 2010 Top 32

Andrew Besso wrote:
Joe Wells wrote:
As far as I know, a silver holy symbol is just bling for clerics. You just can't have a high priest performing the weekly rituals with a wooden holy symbol.
Depends on the deity.

Depends on how detailed deities are in the campaign setting. Some will have copious information about holy symbols, fonts, altars, and places of worship while others will hand-wave a lot of that.

For the base-line generic setting, a silver holy symbol is mostly there as a show-piece.


They are mostly there for RP purposes. And in some cases a priest may feel the wood is better then the silver due to a vow of poverty or revering nature. But silver is technically worth more, so more important NPC priests would carry one. In theory they should list gold and platinum as options too.


Pathfinder Adventure Path Subscriber

Well, you could throw your silver holy symbol at a werewolf and overcome its DR.... and a wooden holy symbol you could set on fire and stop a troll's regen... just sayin'

Liberty's Edge

I had a wooden symbol up to now, but surely a dwarf in Torag's service should have a silver holy symbol. I have the cash; I'll have to upgrade.

I do think there ought to be some consequence to the material, though. Surely a wooden symbol is more appropriate for an "outdoorsy" deity like Erastil, while Torag would insist on metal.

Silver Crusade

Garreth Baldwin wrote:
Well, you could throw your silver holy symbol at a werewolf and overcome its DR.... and a wooden holy symbol you could set on fire and stop a troll's regen... just sayin'

Great...

A silver holy symbol might do 1d(0.5) damage if thrown.


Or pawn it.

Sovereign Court

The silver one can be polymorphed into a silver weapon or silver mirror or silver powder (for magic circles vs. evil and bless water spell components...)

As a DM I'd even allow a cleric to take small shavings and use them as material components for spells, etc.


Karrek wrote:

I had a wooden symbol up to now, but surely a dwarf in Torag's service should have a silver holy symbol. I have the cash; I'll have to upgrade.

I do think there ought to be some consequence to the material, though. Surely a wooden symbol is more appropriate for an "outdoorsy" deity like Erastil, while Torag would insist on metal.

Its a roleplay thing. Just like a nobles outfit costs more then a travelers outfit. Theres very little mechanical distinction, its just a matter of roleplay and character preferences most of the time.

Contributor

1 person marked this as a favorite.

Not every piece of equipment has to have a mechanical benefit.


Sean K Reynolds wrote:
Not every piece of equipment has to have a mechanical benefit.

Heresy!

Community / Forums / Pathfinder / Pathfinder First Edition / Rules Questions / Silver and Wooden Holy Symbols All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Rules Questions