Dear Paizo, I would like to request further definition of reincarnate to be listed in the PH-II book. It is not clear cut what exactly you get to keep and get in many situations of a PC. Also perhaps this could be cleared up with future races as well.
Such as an example of a Human Cleric who gets reincarnated as a Half Orc.
Sense he put his +2 into Wisdom, would he keep it because it is a mental bonus? I assume so sense that physical stats are the only ones changed. Would the human now get Orc Ferocity? Or is that more of a mental thing?
I love the spell, and it shows a differance in beliefs between the druids and the clerics. I also know you could probably fix things up rather well on your own, but here is my suggestion. He probably would not get Intimidating, but maybe that is purely physical feature? In the end it is a guess, and up to the GM.
Go to each race and simply label each trait as ether mental (mnt) or physical (phy).
After a listing of the current PC PH-I races are listed, just adding this simple lable to the future races will keep things clear.
Perhaps others have another idea on how to do this?