The Secret of NIMH returns to the big screen


Movies

Liberty's Edge

This was one of my favorite animated films as a kid. Now, we have word of this. I like that the story will be introduced to a new generation of kids, but I don't like the way this article seems to insinuate the remake might be done in the vein of *shudder* G-Force with cute, sassy, computer-animated rats cracking awful jokes and jumping around like ninjas. I really hope that isn't the direction this goes.

It's too bad Dom Deluise isn't around to reprise his role as Jeremy.


1 person marked this as a favorite.

Hack, hack.. In my day, this was a book. (God bless you, Ms. Umansky.) Of course, my daughter loved the movie. ;)

Liberty's Edge

It's still a book (and a popular one at that.) I read it and still liked the film just as much.


Just bein' crotchety. It's a good film.


I like Nicodemus and the Owl myself...


3 people marked this as a favorite.

Between NIMH and Redwall, one could work up a pretty good appetite for Mouse Guard.

EDIT: Oh, and Narnia and Despereaux.


Jenner: I've learned this much -- take what you can, when you can.

Justin: Then you've learned nothing.

One of the most memorable lines from my adolescence; I still enjoy of watching this movie, even when showing it to my daughters. (Lest anyone think I'm being partial here, I only have daughters thus far.)

I wonder how well this type of story would come off using Mouse Guard as a game engine? Hmmmm... *steeples fingers*

Liberty's Edge

Readerbreeder wrote:
I wonder how well this type of story would come off using Mouse Guard as a game engine?

While not quite the same, I've toyed with the idea of a campaign where all the players are awakened animals. I think a Redwall or NIMH-styled game could be very interesting.

Liberty's Edge

Readerbreeder wrote:

Jenner: I've learned this much -- take what you can, when you can.

Justin: Then you've learned nothing.

One of the most memorable lines from my adolescence; I still enjoy of watching this movie, even when showing it to my daughters. (Lest anyone think I'm being partial here, I only have daughters thus far.)

I wonder how well this type of story would come off using Mouse Guard as a game engine? Hmmmm... *steeples fingers*

Jeremy: None of the girls I meet wanna get serious.

Mrs. Brisby: I doubt they'd survive...

Jeremy: Huh?

I also recall that Nichodemus made good use of cantrips.


Wow, just looking through the voice actors behind the original animated film. Wow.

Shadow Lodge

Velcro Zipper wrote:
This was one of my favorite animated films as a kid. Now, we have word of this.

No, just no...

Why? Why ruin something by remaking it? The originals are always better!

Velcro Zipper wrote:
While not quite the same, I've toyed with the idea of a campaign where all the players are awakened animals. I think a Redwall or NIMH-styled game could be very interesting.

I'd play in it. I've been toying with the idea of playing an awakened animal in my weekend game, but I can't choose which animal.


Well, if you're not playing Mouse Guard, the answer is obvious: Celestial Dire Badger!

The Exchange Contributor, RPG Superstar 2008 Top 6

Mairkurion {tm} wrote:
Just bein' crotchety. It's a good film.

Hmm. I'll up the cranky. While the film is enjoyable, the book was great without all the added violence and added villainy. I'd like a movie that stuck to the book better.

Liberty's Edge

Dragonborn3 wrote:


No, just no...
Why? Why ruin something by remaking it? The originals are always better!

Two words for you: Lord of the Rings. Ok technically four. Still - it took over 20 years, but was definitely a superior remake.


Crankiness is one of those things that is better shared. ;)

ADD: @ Count Buggula. Superior to the Ralph Bakshi? Sure.

Liberty's Edge

Dragonborn3 wrote:
I'd play in it. I've been toying with the idea of playing an awakened animal in my weekend game, but I can't choose which animal.

I once played an awakened rooster necromancer with a worm for a familiar.

Russ Taylor wrote:
I'd like a movie that stuck to the book better.

I'm always of two minds on this. On the one hand, I agree with something Clive Barker once said about translating his own writing to film. To paraphrase, Barker said making a movie from one of his stories gives him a chance to tell a version of what could have been and lets the audience see a version of the story where they don't exactly know what is going to happen. This is great when the movie is good. The LOTR trilogy, The Crow and Barker's own Hellraiser are just a few examples of movies that diverge a little from the source material and still turned out to be pretty good. On the other hand, you have the vast amount of other book-to-movie adaptations that went horribly wrong. In the case of The Secret of NIMH, despite the addition of the mystical/fantasy element, I think everything went right.


Honestly, I enjoy the movie more. It's prettier than it would have been if it'd been totally faithful, has a lot of nice twists, and a really classic Don Bluth villain. I also like that it focuses more on "Brisby".

Yes, I'm necromancing old threads. Wanna fight about it?

Scarab Sages

Kobold Cleaver wrote:


Yes, I'm necromancing old threads. Wanna fight about it?

Actually yes, I do. I was all excited to go see Secret of NIMH in the theater, but then I saw the post date was in 2009.

*sad face*


I'm pretty sure this thread was about a rumored remake, so don't blame me. ;D


I blame Kobold Cleaver. Bad Kobold! ~takes away his cleaver~


Hey, I need that to chop vegetables and gnomes!

The Exchange

In the spirit of getting contentious over remakes that probably aren't happening, I was pretty "Meh" about the film when I saw it as it most left out my favorite bit of the book - the long section of the rats' journey from the lab. Other than that, can't remember much.


The remake probably ain't happening. If it does, it's gonna be stupid, for the same reason a CG remake of The Little Mermaid would be stupid.


Kobold Cleaver wrote:
The remake probably ain't happening. If it does, it's gonna be stupid, for the same reason a CG remake of The Little Mermaid would be stupid.

CG fodder for rule 34?


And hand-drawn isn't? ;P

Community / Forums / Gamer Life / Entertainment / Movies / The Secret of NIMH returns to the big screen All Messageboards

Want to post a reply? Sign in.
Recent threads in Movies