Ectoplasmic Phantom Phase Lurch vs. Incorporeal Phantom

[GM PDK]

Ectoplasmic Phase Lurch states that the phantom must start and end the Phase Lurch next to the wall it's crossing. It moves at half speed so that limits the Ectoplasmic Phantom to 10-foot thick walls, assuming a speed of 30.

Incorporeal Phantom is limited to a 5-foot thick wall (assuming medium-size phantom), based on the Incorporeal Universal Monster Rule: "An incorporeal creature can enter or pass through solid objects, but must remain adjacent to the object's exterior, and so cannot pass entirely through an object whose space is larger than its own."

Do I have this right?

[GM PDK]

.

[GM PDK]

I like to be right the first time... I guess I understand the class correctly! :)

[willuwontu]

Phase Lurch wrote:

A phantom in ectoplasmic form has the ability to pass through walls or material obstacles. In order to use this ability, it must begin and end its turn outside whatever wall or obstacle it’s moving through. An ectoplasmic phantom can’t move through corporeal creatures with this ability, and its movement speed is halved while moving through a wall or obstacle. Any surface it moves through is coated with a thin, silvery mucus that lingers for 1 minute

An incorporeal phantom does not gain the phase lurch ability, only ectoplasmic phantoms do.Instead, it uses the standard incorporeal rules.